Minutes · Oct 29, 2026
October 29, 2026, Special Meeting
3293549f5fcd4faec1ecfcfd64910c0ac796096af407369474af1bd92b0be1a5Indexed text
t on the operation of that U-turn facility, or that left turn lane. Ms. DiLorenzo said, okay, and how about how having additional cars making U-turns in two (2) different spots will impact pedestrians trying to cross the street and isn't that going to increase the danger level for people trying to cross? Mr. Taylor said absolutely not. That the U-turns are done while the pedestrians crossing the same leg of traffic have to stop, right? It's done when the left turns are permitted, and the pedestrians crossing Prospect are not allowed to cross at the same time as the left turn lane is going. So there's really no interaction between the U-turn, U-turning vehicle and the pedestrians crossing that intersection. Ms. DiLorenzo asked referencing the parking, spot study. Asking for clarification that, it was based on looking at Mavis as primarily a tire store, is that correct? Mr. Taylor answered saying not exactly because the 25 number comes from an application of the closest applicable land use within the ordinance, within the municipality's ordinance. The total number of 25 is because of the number of bays, the number of retail space, and just the use, the intrinsic use of the service station. The justification that used to draw, and the way he came to his professional opinion, is that Mavis looked at a more applicable, similar-type land use that the Institute of Transportation Engineers publish, which is a Tire Store, which is the retail business of selling tires, and is what Mavis does here and the data says that per employee, it would be 1.66 spaces of demand per employee for the (7) employees, that translates into a demand of 12 parking spaces, which is easily accommodated within the 22 spaces that are proposed. Ms. DiLorenzo asked about the other study mentioned where it requires 25 versus the 22, that's still more than a 10% reduction in what there should be, correct? Mr. Taylor said that the applicant is providing 90% of what's required or the closest applicable ordinance, land use, would say that is required.
Break 9 :29 PM- 9 :39 PM Upon return from break, Chairperson Neuer had a roll call performed and a quorum was again confirmed. PUBLIC QUESTIONS (Continued) e Andrew Matt (6 Cerone Court) asked if Mr. Taylor prepared this study personally. Mr. Taylor said it was prepared under his supervision. That he was reviewing everything as it was prepared and reviewed it before it went out underneath his signature. e Mr. Matt asked for confirmation utilizing Table 4 what the entering and exiting trips for the weekday evening peak hour are? Mr. Taylor answered that for the evening peak hour the total traffic out is 14, in is 10 vehicles, totaling 24 vehicles. Mr. Matt followed up by asking if the study classifying a trip made to pick up a previously serviced vehicle as a primary trip? Mr. Taylor said yes. Mr. Matt asked for confirmation of Mr. Taylor’s previous testimony of 177 daily trips, which is about 88 vehicles asking how many of those are employees, and how many were customers coming back to pick up a car. Mr. Taylor said that the trip generation data does not separate between employees and customers. Mr. Matt asked for confirmation that the demand is eight (8) to 12 spaces based on employees and if that includes the cars of customers waiting on site during a one and a half (1%) to two (2) hour service? Mr. Taylor said yes, it does. e Mr. Matt asked for confirmation on questions about, this site being considered a service station and if he is not aware that the D1 use variance is for a motor vehicle service station. Mr. Taylor said yes, that he understands that the West Orange Ordinance Land use definition that could be applied here is the motor vertical service station but it doesn't have within the Ordinance a specific land use code for both use and parking that is really directly applicable to what is being proposed which is why applications like these rely on national data published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers to come up with the projections of both trip generation and parking for the real specific land use. e Mr. Matt asked for confirmation saying that although this is requesting a D1 variance for a motor vehicle service station, he thought it was more appropriate to use the ITE's data on a tire store. Mr. Taylor said yes, that he felt that what Mavis does is more applicable, or more closely resembles what's within the ITE Land Use Code.
it was more appropriate to use the ITE's data on a tire store. Mr. Taylor said yes, that he felt that what Mavis does is more applicable, or more closely resembles what's within the ITE Land Use Code. Mr. Matt asked if any other considerations were made besides the tire store. Mr. Taylor said that they did not, because this is the most applicable land use code to what Mavis does. Mr. Matt asked for confirmation on Mr. Taylor’s testimony about the reasoning about using the national ITE rates, instead of that Mavis’. Mr. Taylor answered that Mavis is closed, and it goes back to utilizing national data. When applicable, and when available for the individual use. e Mr. Matt referenced Table 6’s build analysis relying on the write in, write out restriction with some correspondence with the County and a restriction on Blueberry Bend. Even though the spaces along Blueberry Bend were set deeper for the truck circulation mentioned and Mr. Taylor said yes because they utilize both the site driveway and Blueberry Bend. Mr. Matt followed up by asking where the tire delivery truck stands while unloading. Mr. Taylor said that it is in stages in the Southeast corner of the building up against the face of the building outside of peak hours. Mr. Matt asked if cars are still able to pass in both directions. Mr. Taylor said yes and it is mentioned in the study on page 10 under site access and circulation it says the site plan indicates, the site can sufficiently
accommodate a large wheelbase vehicle, such as a single-unit truck, and emergency vehicles. Alan Culler (118 Coccio Drive) asked about the testimony regarding U turns and whether in the traffic study, did he look at what the current, usage of that for U-turns is. Mr. Taylor said that intersection (Rooney Circle), because it did not rise to the level of needing to, based on the NJDOT thresholds. Marcia Davis (109 Coccio) asked whether aging was considered in the demographics of his study. Mr. Taylor said that is not a metric typically analyzed. Ms. Davis followed up by asking if he is aware of the demographics of the Eagle Ridge community. Mr. Taylor answered that it was not material to the analysis performed. Sandra Kaplan (191 Zeppi Lane) wanted clarification on the notion that traffic at Garino might not be impacted, Sandra Kaplan: Could you explain why there were no studies of the current traffic patterns in and out of the driveways there, because there are people who do make turns into the driveway, thinking that they can make a U-turn around the gatehouse, and sometimes they drive into the wrong way which clearly is a safety issue. So why was that not included as part of the traffic study? Mr. Taylor answered that there are a couple reasons. First off, the thresholds used as traffic engineers on intersections in need of study, right? It's the DOT threshold of 100 new peak hour trips, and the entire development doesn't generate more than a third of what that threshold is. So, the analysis based on that criterion is not something that needed to be done. But a little further, the vehicles entering Guarino, the only people that are leaving this facility that would be entering Guarino is somebody that lives within that gated community that just had their tires done at the Mavis. So the turns into it were not really part of the study or of the analysis, strictly for that reason. Michaela Bennett (Old Indian Road) asked about methodology for the trucks and delivery (deliver, turn around, and exit). Mr. Taylor said for vehicle delivery, the vehicle would enter off of Prospect into the driveway navigating the Southeast corner of the building and it would egress out of Blueberry Bend. Ms. Bennett asked if it has been determined how trucks will be ingressing and egressing. Mr. Taylor answered saying that vehicle circulation templates provided show the
egress out of Blueberry Bend. Ms. Bennett asked if it has been determined how trucks will be ingressing and egressing. Mr. Taylor answered saying that vehicle circulation templates provided show the vehicle entering off of the site driveway and exiting off of Blueberry Bend. Ms. Bennett asked for confirmation that coming out of this site, someone would have to cross two (2) lanes of traffic to get into that turning lane. Mr. Taylor said yes. Ms. Bennett followed up her questioning asking for confirmation while taking a quick look at an aerial view of that turning lane, where she sees a left-hand turn, but no U-turn, point. Mr. Taylor answered that if she was looking at the same Google Ariel Image, then yes, that's correct. Ms. Bennett asked about about the traffic study, and did if he accounted separately for vehicles that are being dropped off and picked up, employee parking, and delivery trucks. Mr. Taylor answered yes, that within the trip generation numbers quoted earlier, as well as the parking numbers, all those types of users are incorporated into the maximum demand. So, about ITE projects 1.66 spaces per employee translates into 12 vehicles demand that can be accommodated within the 22 parking spaces. If you were to utilize the square footage number, it translates into 18 vehicles, again, accommodated by the 22 that are proposed and that is a combination of both employees, customers dropping off their vehicle, and the vehicles being worked on.
Ms. Bennett asked about trash and the picking up including the involvement of how old tires are going to be picked up. Mr. Taylor said obviously there was a dumpster and its picking up once a week typically or less frequently depending on the need. The tires are taken away be the same people who deliver the tires so that truck is every two (2) weeks and all of the tires are picked up during the day during the potential off peak hours (potentially mid-morning but not overnight.) Amy Krompier (58 Musano Court) asked about safety vehicles getting through if the number of cares getting through and they are using spaces what the logistics of how a fire truck would get through bypassing the other vehicles being serviced. Mr. Taylor said that the vehicle being serviced would be directly within the bay. The vehicle's either waiting to be serviced, or the employee vehicles will be parked in the parking spaces, and the emergency vehicle circulates through the circulation aisles. In the event of needing more than one (1) emergency vehicle they would all be able to stage within the circulation aisles of the facility. But there is room within the 30-foot aisle along the face of the building for emergency vehicles to stage. There's also room within Blueberry Bend and the north-south aisle on the eastern side of the parking field for vehicles to stage. So there's adequate room for multiple emergency vehicles to be on site at the same time. In doing a study it modeled a 47-foot-long fire truck circulating through the site and it can adequately circulate through the site. So, that coupled with an ambulance, or a police car, can all be on the site at the same time. If the emergency responders felt that it was necessary to either move vehicles or evacuate vehicles. They would guide that, operation. Mindy Feld (193 Zeppi Lane) asked about creating the sidewalk going towards the traffic light at Guarino and asked for confirmation that they are pushing pedestrian traffic so that customers of Mavis can cross at the light where there is indeed a crosswalk. Mr. Taylor said yes that they are providing pedestrian accommodations and a sidewalk across the entire frontage of the building but the intent would be for a customer to drop their car and go to the shopping center (Essex Green) they would travel north along the sidewalk to the north and utilize the crosswalks and pedestrians’
but the intent would be for a customer to drop their car and go to the shopping center (Essex Green) they would travel north along the sidewalk to the north and utilize the crosswalks and pedestrians’ accommodations at that signal. Barbara Quakenbos (369 Stiles Court) asked if'a crash analysis was performed in any safety study for any client other than Mavis. Mr. Taylor said yes that he has, but he could not recall which customers or clients those were. Nicholas Strontses (214 Cerone Court) asked if any of the other applications he has done for Mavis were for a use variance. Mr. Taylor said that he believes so, referenced the Marlboro, NJ location but he didn’t recall if there were any other ones and it was granted with them opening and operating presently. Stephanie Regan (265 DeRose Court) for clarification on Mavis selling tires and also performing minor vehicular maintenance, because they are trying to fit in what Mavis does into the existing guidelines and metrics. Mr. Taylor said that from an Ordinance perspective and a parking requirement perspective, yes, the applicant tried to utilize the most applicable land use. The general automotive maintenance falls right within the purview of the land use code used. Whether it's a personal vehicle or a fleet vehicle tire installation repair and general automotive maintenance is what is done. So, yes, the land use chosen and utilized for analysis is directly applicable to what Mavis does. Lara‘ Thompson (79 Vacca Drive) asked how the trucks are getting to Prospect Avenue. Mr. Taylor answered saying that the truck circulation provided shows the vehicles entering from the south and the rationale behind that is that it is a more restrictive turning movement.
When analyzing the driveways, it has been designed to accommodate the right turn maneuver. It was at this point in the meeting that Ms. John-Basta requested an adjournment to the next available meeting. Chairperson Neuer agreed to carry this application with preservation of notice to a Special Meeting scheduled for December 3, 2026, via Zoom. Chairperson Neuer adjourned the meeting at 10:57 PM Adopted: wf q [2024 10
File revisions (1)
- Nov 21, 2026
3293549f5fcd4,933,324 bytes