Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026
Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index
61cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9Indexed text
ve representations as to what the county will do. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Thank you. MR. TRACTENBERG: Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you, Mr. Tractenberg. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Rachel Klein, please state your name and address for the record. MS. KLEIN: Rachel Klein, Howell Drive. Sorry, Mr. Chairman. I have to do a quick preamble to
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 43 my question. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go ahead. MS. KLEIN: I was doing a little research into Crestmont Country Club, basically as if I were going to be -- host a wedding there to find out what their lot capacity was, and they say it’s about 250 to 290 cars now. I know that we’re also not looking at the 2017 application for on-site seasonal housing, but my question is has anyone ever seen this lot filled up that we need to actually be going through all these major changes and huge retaining walls and things for 36 more spots when their capacity is -- seems to be adequate now? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I -- I -- it is not the planning board’s job to decide what is or is not good for business. It’s our job to decide does it fit the zone plan? Is it consistent with the master plan? What variances are needed and what the applicant has to do to -- to comply with the zone plan an the master plan and all variances. How’d I do? Malvika, did I do okay with that? MS. APTE: Yeah. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Chairman, can I suggest a suggestion to the members of the public that -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yes. Mr. Schkolnick?1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 44 MR. SCHKOLNICK: -- we’re in the question -- we’re in -- we’re in the time period of the questioning of the planner, the cross examination. Ms. Klein is certainly free to make comments, comment on the other applicants, but there’s a time and a place for that, that’s during the public comment -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I got it, Mr. Schkolnick. MR. SCHKOLNICK: -- portion, so -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: We hear you. MR. SCHKOLNICK: -- suggesting that -- that suggestion to help move us along in a reasonable time frame. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yeah. I got it. Ms. Klein, would you go -- thank you for your comment. Would you go right ahead now? Ask Mr. Moronski a question about his testimony, please. MS. KLEIN: I -- that was all. Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Oh. Thank you. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Richard Baum, please state your name and address for the record. MR. BAUM: All right. Richard Baum, 10 Kinzel Lane, West Orange, New
testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Richard Baum, please state your name and address for the record. MR. BAUM: All right. Richard Baum, 10 Kinzel Lane, West Orange, New Jersey.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 45 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead, Sir. MR. BAUM: Thank you. So, I come in and out of Oval Road frequently, probably five to ten times a day because we live right behind the Pleasantdale Chateau in The Grande. Based on what I’ve heard, the variances for the steep slope wall of 21 feet high and 13 feet long is a requirement of changing this driveway location. Is that correct? MR. MORONSKI: It does -- it does factor -- it does factor in, but it’s also to deal with the basins for stormwater as well. MR. BAUM: So if you didn’t move this driveway to where you want to move it, you wouldn’t need the steep slope wall or -- or the -- the length and the height of it. 21 feet is pretty high. MR. MORONSKI: Well, as I said, it’s -- it’s not just the driveway, it’s also the stormwater improvements as well. MR. BAUM: Well, I’ve -- I’ve lived here for 25 years and I -- I don’t think Oval Road in this location has much stormwater problems. So, if the club could build 36 new parking spaces because they feel they need those spaces and leave the driveway alone, that would basically require no high wall or -- or, you know, long wall here to -- you know, a retaining wall1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 46 or a variance. Is that correct? MR. MORONSKI: We don’t know that. This is the application that’s in front of us. Each design stands on its own merits and if you do a different design, it may have different consequences. The design that was proposed is because you need the basins for both the widening and the parking, also. So you may have another design which could have more detrimental -- potentially detrimental effects on the site. MR. BAUM: So you think the traffic from Oval Road and the club can easily be handled with a stop sign instead of a traffic light? MR. MORONSKI: I -- I think the -- the traffic testimony mentioned about how the intersection would handle traffic, and I defer to -- I defer to the previous traffic testimony. MR. BAUM: Are you aware of any other four- way intersections like this in West
y mentioned about how the intersection would handle traffic, and I defer to -- I defer to the previous traffic testimony. MR. BAUM: Are you aware of any other four- way intersections like this in West Orange? MR. SCHKOLNICK: Objection to the question. You can answer. MR. MORONSKI: I -- I don’t understand what you mean by these type of four-way intersections. MR. BAUM: Low volume exiting vehicles from Crestmont, high volume from Oval Road. Are you aware of any four-way --
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 47 MR. MORONSKI: Well -- MR. BAUM: -- four-way intersections like this? MR. MORONSKI: Again, it’s -- it’s too vague. It’s too vague and I -- I really -- I really can’t answer that question. MR. BAUM: You know, I’ve lived her for 25 years. I’ve never seen more than one car waiting to exit Crestmont Country Club. I -- I certainly don’t see the reason for this -- this change if you can put 36 spots in that parking lot, which you can easily do in other locations. Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Keith Sly, please state your name and address for the record. MR. SLY: Keith Sly, 757 Eagle Rock Avenue, Pleasantdale Chateau, objector to this application, for the record. And the -- I believe the board was copied on the objection letter as well, so all members should have seen that. If not, it can certainly be reissued. MS. McGOVERN: The board can’t accept just documents without verification. You’re here today, if1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 48 you want to read the letter to the board, you can feel free to do that at the public comment time. Right now, it’s questions. MR. SLY: I’m happy to do that. I’m just trying to provide some clarification for pre -- previous objections from the attorney. In this sort of Schrödinger’s cat scenario where there’s both a traffic light and not a traffic light, can you, Mr. Moronski, explain as you have mentioned in your words repeatedly no impairment or detriment involved to all, how having to compete for residents exiting Oval Road to now, without a traffic light, have to compete with people exiting across from them, how that is -- improves the situation rather than actually makes the situation worse for people exiting from Oval Road. MR. MORONSKI: Well, what I said was no substantial detriment. I didn’t say no impediments or no substantial, and that’s a term of art in the Municipal Land Use Law. And the traffic testimony described the circulation and I believe the -- the traffic testimony and the engineering testimony helped to support when I described why the application presented no substantial detriment to the public good for
he circulation and I believe the -- the traffic testimony and the engineering testimony helped to support when I described why the application presented no substantial detriment to the public good for the several reasons I noted in my testimony. MR. SLY: Would it not then be your1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 49 professional recommendation to have the traffic engineer re-present information based on the specifics of not having a traffic light, as that would material -- materially change the situation? MR. MORONSKI: The traffic engineer presented his testimony. MR. SLY: That was not the question. Would you recommend having him re-present with a different scenario involved? MR. MORONSKI: It’s not my place -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: Objection to the question. Chair -- Chairman, this is not a proper question. This is not what he testified about. And he -- he’s asking for our -- our presentation strategy of which witnesses we want to present and whether we should have a rebuttal case? It’s not appropriate -- MR. SLY: If I -- if I may clarify to help, excuse my -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead. Go right ahead. MR. SLY: -- naivete, but I believe he’s testifying that he reviewed that information and assessed in his own personal or professional capacity that there was no impairment. I believe that does justify the -- the question as to his professional1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 50 assessment being based on particular information. MR. MORONSKI: I -- I would ask -- MR. SLY: So the question stands, in my mind. MR. MORONSKI: I would ask again, it’s -- the word “substantial” is important here, and it is -- it is what you see in the record, ultimately, in the resolution. And to say I’m saying no impairment or no detriment is misrepresenting my testimony. MR. SLY: Okay. Let’s take out the word “substantial” do you find that there is -- MR. MORONSKI: No. Put it in. Put it in. Substantial. I said no substantial. You said no detriment. MR. SLY: Okay. I must have misquoted you, but I would refer back to the transcript for what you had said, and I'll let the coun -- the board decide on that. Excuse my mistake, if so. Have you ever physically visited Pleasantdale Chateau? MR. MORONSKI: Have I visited Pleasantdale Chateau? MR. SLY: Yes, Sir. MR. MORONSKI: In
oun -- the board decide on that. Excuse my mistake, if so. Have you ever physically visited Pleasantdale Chateau? MR. MORONSKI: Have I visited Pleasantdale Chateau? MR. SLY: Yes, Sir. MR. MORONSKI: In what capacity? I don't understand the question. MR. SLY: Have you ever approached, anyone from Pleasantdale Chateau to ask how they could be
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 51 potentially affected by the changes proposed here? MR. MORONSKI: I -- I -- I've been to Pleasantdale Chateau years ago for an event, but beyond that, I -- I have not visited the -- the Pleasantdale Chateau in conjunction with this application, no. MR. SLY: Okay. All right. Well, hopefully you enjoyed your time there. MR. MORONSKI: I did. It was very nice. Thank you. MR. SLY: Great. And hopefully more hospitable than we are today. So, those two statements you still believe align that you can confidently say that being said, that there is no substantial impairment in your assessment? MR. MORONSKI: Oh, I stand by my testimony. MR. SLY: Very good. Thank you. MR. MORONSKI: Thank you. MR. SLY: I have more questions, if you don’t mind. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead. MR. SLY: I think as Ms. Apte helped to clarify in the last meeting regarding understanding meeting the burden of proof for the hardship necessities and criteria for variances, does that best case or -- or lowest-impact plan con -- have1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 52 considerations of engineering possibilities for access on Laurel Avenue at the existing entrance or other scenarios in which you had just previously today said that it would have to stand on its own merits? MR. MORONSKI: I -- I did not testify regarding hardship. My testimony was under the -- what’s call the c(2) criteria, Section 70c(2) of the Municipal Land Use Law in which the overall benefits of the project outweigh the detriments that might be caused from the granting of the variance. There was no reference to hardship. MR. SLY: Okay. It -- it appears I’ve run out of time. I would just like to state for the record, particularly given the new information presented to the consideration of traffic light or lack thereof, that I would like an opportunity to present additional questions, if available. MR. MORONSKI: I just have -- MR. SLY: If I can be indulged. MR. MORONSKI: -- one clarification, I’m sorry. With regards to the slopes, there was a -- what’s called a c(1)(b) variance that had to do with the extraordinary topographic features of the site. So I wanted to clarify that to make sure I gave you a complete answer regarding the justification for
called a c(1)(b) variance that had to do with the extraordinary topographic features of the site. So I wanted to clarify that to make sure I gave you a complete answer regarding the justification for the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 53 variances. MR. SLY: Thank you. MR. MORONSKI: Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. -- Mr. Sly, I’ll give you two more minutes. MR. SLY: Okay. Thank you. I -- much appreciated, Doctor. There was also much discussion over the expanse of the wall that was to be put into place. Has there been submitted a hardscape rendering in any form so that everyone concerned, board members included, can get a more broad scale of the aesthetic impact along Eagle Rock Avenue? MR. MORONSKI: All the plans -- the plans have been submitted. They’re available for review. MR. SLY: Okay. I believe there’s prior testimony that this great wall which was described as akin to what’s seen in typical developments will cover approximately 1300 feet. Is that correct? MR. MORONSKI: Well, no. The length of the wall is 1300 feet. That doesn’t necessarily mean that all of it has the highest height of -- the highest height. It varies -- it varies in height, and that’s noted in the plans. MR. SLY: And you raise an interesting point that Ms. McGovern and I believe Mayor McCartney had1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 54 raised last meeting, which I believe you’d asked for time to get an answer on, the average height of the wall. I know there was a soaring 21 and a half feet, I believe, at highest, but is -- is there an average you can provide at this point, please? Or can you, I guess, to form it in the phrase of a question? MR. MORONSKI: I -- I don’t have -- I don’t have the average height, but they do -- they do var -- along Eagle Rock Avenue, I do note that it averages about eight to nine feet to minimize the impacts on existing trees. The point that was made by Mr. Cote with the proposed walls was to minimize the -- the tree disturbance to the extent -- to the extent possible. MR. SLY: And this improvement is -- of the addition of a block wall, it will be in place of the native old-growth trees that are in place currently? MR. MORONSKI: Well, as was noted -- MR. SLY: Is that correct? MR. MORONSKI: As was noted in the -- in the testimony, there
will be in place of the native old-growth trees that are in place currently? MR. MORONSKI: Well, as was noted -- MR. SLY: Is that correct? MR. MORONSKI: As was noted in the -- in the testimony, there will be a substantial new number of trees that are being proposed. You know, 303 trees -- 303 trees are being remove, 191 percent of them are on slopes greater than 10 percent, but there are going to be 597 replacement trees, 500 -- 539 -- 313 removed -- I’m sorry. 539 trees restored and off-site, 55 trees,
File revisions (1)
- Nov 20, 2026
61cfd83a303f413,643 bytes