Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 13, 2026

281-26 Daughters of Israel - Final Version of Settlement Agmt mjs redline 10.8.26.doc.pdf

Preserved file SHA-2564f6caec6f3e903ba8eeba0f02ae2c802e461b06d571f39d159996f614470fb20

Indexed text

Page 1

12840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 281-26 AFFORDABLE HOUSING AGREEMENT THIS Affordable Housing Agreement (“Agreement”), made this day of September, 2026 (the “Effective Date”), by and between: The TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE, a municipal corporation of the State of New Jersey, County of Essex, having an address at 66 Main Street, West Orange, New Jersey 07052, (hereinafter the “Township” or “West Orange”). and DAUGHTERS OF ISRAEL, INC., a not for profit entity formed under the laws of the State of New Jersey, with offices located at 1155 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange, New Jersey 07052, together with any current owner(s) of the Property defined below, and its/their permitted successors and assigns (collectively, “Daughters” and, with the Township, collectively referred to herein as the “Parties”). and And, for purposes of Paragraph 1.3, infra, only, FAIR SHARE HOUSING CENTER, a non-profit entity formed under the laws of the State of New Jersey, with offices located at 510 Park Boulevard, Cherry Hill, New Jersey 08002 (“FSHC”). RECITALS WHEREAS, the Township of West Orange is a municipal corporation of the State of New Jersey located in Essex County; and WHEREAS, the Township filed a declaratory judgment action in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Essex County, bearing Docket No. ESX-L-886-25, seeking a court- managed path to compliance with its Fourth Round affordable housing obligations pursuant to the New Jersey Fair Housing Act, N.J.S.A. 52:27D-301, et seq., as amended by P.L. 2024, c. 2, Administrative Directive #14-24, and N.J.S.A. 52:27D-313; and WHEREAS, the Court fixed the Township’s Fourth Round affordable housing obligations at a rehabilitation/present need obligation of 409 units and a prospective need obligation of 660 units, and the Township’s current draft Fourth Round Housing Element and Fair Share Plan (“Fourth Round HEFSP” or “Housing Plan”) identifies an RDP of 0 and an unmet need of 660 units; and Formatted: Right Deleted: n

Page 2

22840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 WHEREAS, Daughters is the long term lessee of certain real property located at 1155 Pleasant Valley Way also known as Block 171, Lot 12 on the Township’s tax map (hereinafter the “Property”); and WHEREAS, the Property was previously included in the Township’s fourth round housing element Fair Share plan; and WHEREAS, the Property is currently owned by the Jewish Community Foundation of Greater MetroWest NJ, Inc. (the “Foundation”) which is a registered Not for profit entity, and the Foundation intends to transfer title of the Property to Daughters, subsequent to the Daughters’ receipt of all necessary approvals for the Inclusionary Project, infra, and Daughters are authorized by the Foundation to enter into this Agreement in connection therewith; and WHEREAS, the Property consists of approximately 344,124 square feet, or approximately 17 acres, and is located in the Township’s R-2 Zone; and WHEREAS, Daughters have, since 1962, served the needs of the aging and the larger community in the Township by providing health and social-related services to the elderly and others in need, regardless of their ability to pay. Daughters have long utilized their existing facility located on the subject Property and provided short-term rehabilitation for sub-acute care and temporary respite stays, long-term skilled nursing and memory care, as well as a broad array of specialty programs and services. Daughters existing services also include Meals on Wheels to Township residents, quality transportation for health and social services, and use of the existing facility as a training site for the Essex County College School of Nursing for student clinical on- site rotation, the 1199J Pace (Youth Train to Work) program, and the Essex County College C.NA. and Nursing program, and the Morris County Vocational Technology School of Nursing for LPNs; and WHEREAS, Daughters’ existing facility on the Property is becoming obsolete and must be redeveloped as a Continuing Care Retirement Community (“CCRC”) facility to enable Daughters to continue their not-for-profit mission and provide long-term care to its seniors, including Medicaid recipients who rely upon Daughters’ critical services; and WHEREAS, absent a prompt rezoning and redevelopment, Daughters will have no choice but to shut down its

Page 2

re to its seniors, including Medicaid recipients who rely upon Daughters’ critical services; and WHEREAS, absent a prompt rezoning and redevelopment, Daughters will have no choice but to shut down its operations in the Township, sell the Property, and construct a CCRC facility in another community; and WHEREAS, consistent with the foregoing, Daughters previously filed, in November 2021, and presented a development proposal to the Township’s Zoning Board of Adjustment (the “Zoning Board”), seeking approval for a Continuing Care Retirement Community (“CCRC”) facility, ultimately consisting of 311 total units, which application was denied by the Zoning Board following 11 hearings on the application; and Formatted: Font: Bold Formatted: Font: Bold

Page 3

32840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 WHEREAS, Daughters challenged the Zoning Board’s denial by filing an action in lieu of prerogative writs, bearing Docket No. ESX-L-4045-23, which action is currently pending before the Appellate Division under Docket No. A-000164-24 (the “Zoning Board Litigation”); and WHEREAS, Daughters filed a builder’s remedy / exclusionary zoning action against the Township and Planning Board, bearing Docket No. ESX-L-5603-25 (the “Builder’s Remedy Action”; and WHEREAS, by Order entered on April 10, 2026, the Builder’s Remedy Action was consolidated with the Township’s declaratory judgment action, Docket No. ESX-L-886-25, for purposes of mediation and discovery, without prejudice to any party making an application to have all issues tried at the same time, and Elizabeth McManus was designated to continue as Special Adjudicator; and WHEREAS, following discussions among the Township and Daughters, the Parties reached an agreement to which Daughters agreed to withdraw its Builder’s Remedy Action and settle the Zoning Board Litigation, and the Parties agreed, subject to finalization of this written settlement agreement and required implementing municipal action, that the Property would be included in the Township’s Fourth Round HEFSP and related implementing measures for the provision of 7 affordable housing units, discussed infra; and WHEREAS, the Parties desire to resolve the Builder’s Remedy Action, settle the Zoning Board Litigation, avoid further litigation, provide certainty regarding the development of the Property, and provide the Township with affordable housing credits that may be applied toward the Township’s Fourth Round affordable housing obligation; and WHEREAS, Daughters seek to develop the Property with a rental inclusionary CCRC facility consisting of 311 total units with a maximum building height of five floors (including 163 independent living units, 64 assisted living units, and 84 skilled nursing units), approximately 347 parking spaces, and various site improvements, all intended to be consistent with the concept plan attached hereto as Exhibit A (the “Concept Site and Elevation Plans”) and the zoning ordinance attached hereto as Exhibit B (the “Ordinance”). As noted subsequently, the CCRC facility will include 41 Medicaid eligible beds, but only 7 of the

Page 3

t Site and Elevation Plans”) and the zoning ordinance attached hereto as Exhibit B (the “Ordinance”). As noted subsequently, the CCRC facility will include 41 Medicaid eligible beds, but only 7 of the assisted living beds shall be affordable housing creditable in accordance with the Uniform Housing Affordability Controls, N.J.A.C. 5:80-26.1 et seq. (“UHAC”), the Fair Housing Act, applicable Court orders, and the Township's Court approved affordable housing plan (the “Inclusionary Project” or “Project”); and WHEREAS, the Project shall include no fewer than 347 on site parking spaces; and Deleted: (with the potential for 34 additional parking spaces in the future)…

Page 4

42840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 WHEREAS, as set forth in greater detail in Paragraph 1.3, supra, and subject to the conditions enumerated therein, a material consideration for settlement by the Township is that the Daughters’ Property and CCRC facility, as proposed herein, will generate a 0 realistic development potential (“RDP”) for the Township while also providing 7 affordable housing credits towards the Township’s satisfaction of its 25% unmet need obligation pursuant to N.J.S.A. 52:27D-310.1; and WHEREAS, another material consideration for settlement by the Township is that, in the event the Property is sold or operated by a for-profit entity, as set forth in Paragraph ___, supra, the set-aside for the Project will require 20% of the units to be deed restricted and creditable towards the Township’s Fourth Round obligation; and WHEREAS, the Parties wish to enter into this Affordable Housing Agreement which sets forth the terms, conditions, responsibilities and obligations of the Parties relative to the Inclusionary Project and the affordable housing units to be provided on the Property. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises and the mutual obligations contained herein, and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged by each of the Parties, the Parties hereto agree to the terms set forth as follows: ARTICLE I – BASIC TERMS AND CONDITIONS 1.1 Purpose The purpose of this Agreement is to resolve the disputes between the Parties, including Daughters’ Builder’s Remedy Action and the Zoning Board Litigation, and to create and maintain a rental Inclusionary Project on the Property in which 7 assisted living beds or the percentage of units set forth in accordance with Paragraph 1.8 of this agreement (if triggered), shall be shall be affordable housing creditable in accordance with UHAC standards, the Fair Housing Act, the Mount Laurel doctrine, and the Township's Court approved Fourth Round HEFSP. The development will be substantially consistent with the Concept Plan dated 9/18/26 and the Ordinance attached hereto as exhibits A & B respectively. The Parties intend that the Affordable Units to be constructed as part of the Inclusionary Project shall be included in the Township's Fourth Round HEFSP and related implementing measures and

Page 4

ctively. The Parties intend that the Affordable Units to be constructed as part of the Inclusionary Project shall be included in the Township's Fourth Round HEFSP and related implementing measures and shall be applied toward the Township's Fourth Round affordable housing obligation, subject to approval by the Court, Special Adjudicator, Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program, or other reviewing authority, as applicable. Deleted: to

Page 5

52840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 1.2 Affordability Controls to Run with the Land As a critical and non-severable component of this Agreement, the affordability controls applicable to the affordable units in the inclusionary project, including without limitation recorded deed restriction(s), restrictive covenants, and any other recorded affordability instruments required by UHAC, the Fair Housing Act, the Township's affordable housing ordinances, or any Court approved compliance plan, shall run with the land. The obligations and benefits hereunder shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the Parties, their successors and assigns, including any person, corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or other legal entity which at any particular time may have a fee title interest in the Property which is the subject of this Agreement. Daughters’ obligations with respect to the Affordable Units shall continue during Daughters’ ownership or operation of the Property and shall be assumed by any successor owner for the full affordability control period, subject to the express conditions set forth herein. 1.3 RDP Calculation of the Property and Unmet Need Provision Fair Share Housing Center and the Township agree that, in the context of global settlement agreement with FSHC, the Project and the Property shall not contribute to West Orange’s realistic development potential (“RDP”). Instead, the Project shall be considered as a “realistic” redevelopment opportunity site, which is specifically rezoned, and for which the 7 associated affordable housing credits count towards the Township’s obligation to address the “at least 25% of its unmet need by identifying sites likely to redevelop and adopting realistic zoning” language of N.J.S.A. 52:27D-310.1 In the event that FSHC and the Township do not reach an omnibus agreement, then both FSHC and the Township reserve all rights as it pertains to the RDP of the Property and the Township’s obligation to zone for this obligation if deemed to exist by a Court with competent jurisdiction. The foregoing notwithstanding, the Township shall proceed with its rezoning obligations contained herein and this Agreement with Daughters shall be submitted to the Court for review at a fairness hearing, which FSHC shall support. In the event the Township does not

Page 5

s rezoning obligations contained herein and this Agreement with Daughters shall be submitted to the Court for review at a fairness hearing, which FSHC shall support. In the event the Township does not settle its Fourth Round case with FSHC and the matter is instead litigated between FSHC and the Township, the Court’s ultimate decision on this limited issue shall have no impact on the rezoning of the Property or the Parties’ obligations hereunder. FSHC’s rights under this Agreement are limited to the within paragraph. 1.4 Project Description Deleted: and Deleted: control Deleted: “ Deleted: ”

Page 6

62840-07495\#1267165v1 Formatted: Font: 8 pt Deleted: 2840-07495\#1267165v12840-07495\#1266058v1 The Inclusionary Project shall consist of the following, subject to final site plan approval, outside agency approvals, and consistency with the Ordinance: a. 311 total units, including 163 independent living units, 64 assisted living units, and 84 skilled nursing units; b. No independent commercial component; c. 7 assisted living beds that shall be designated as affordable housing creditable; d. No fewer than 347 on-site parking spaces g. stormwater management, landscaping, lighting, trash/recycling, facade, circulation, and other improvements substantially consistent with the Concept Plan dated 9/18/26 attached here to as Exhibit A. and/or as may be approved by the Planning Board; and h. such other improvements as are reasonably necessary to construct and operate the Inclusionary Project in accordance with applicable law. 1.5 Exhibits The following exhibits are incorporated into and made part of this Agreement: a. Exhibit A – Concept Plan / Site Plan dated 9/18/26 and Conceptual Elevations dated____ for the Inclusionary Project b. Exhibit B – Ordinance _____. ARTICLE II – DEVELOPER’S OBLIGATIONS 1.6 Obligation to Resolve All Pending Litigation and Withdraw Opposition Upon the latter of the execution of this Agreement, the non-appealable Court approval of this Agreement at a fairness hearing, and the non-appealable adoption of the Ordinance attached as Exhibit B, Daughters shall file voluntary a stipulation of dismissal with prejudice of the Builder’s Remedy Action and the Zoning Board Litigation Such stipulations shall be filed within five (5) business days after the later of the foregoing events, unless another date is agreed to in writing by the Parties or ordered by the Court. Daughters shall execute and file, or consent to the filing of, any stipulation, consent order, withdrawal, dismissal, or other document reasonably required by the Township, the Planning Board, Zoning Board of Adjustment the Special Adjudicator, or the Court to effectuate the stay, Deleted: Commented [MS1]: Any reference to future banked parking spaces must be omitted/ Commented [MS2]: The elevations must show adequate screening to underbuilding parking Deleted: .

File revisions (1)