Supporting Documentation · Nov 10, 2026
3001-26 TM Assoc. Report.pdf
755a122816ae4facc247b960d76db0b35b7b271a0ec34a23a13e13d131f5aec1Indexed text
Page 1 of 5 September 21, 2026 VIA EMAIL (zcarballo@westorange.org) Zayibeth Carballo, PE, PLS, PP, CME, CFM, CFS Director, Municipal Engineer Department of Engineering Township of West Orange 25 Lakeside Avenue West Orange, New Jersey 07052 Re: Stop Sign Evaluation Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace West Orange Township, Essex County, New Jersey Dear Ms. Carballo: T&M Associates has been tasked by the Township of West Orange to perform an evaluation of the existing traffic controls at the intersection of Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace to assess the safety conditions at the intersection and determine the appropriate location for ‘stop’ control consistent with the 11th Edition of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). This letter report represents our findings: Existing Conditions Field investigations were conducted by T&M to obtain an inventory of existing roadway conditions, traffic control, adjacent land uses and lane configurations. The following is a brief description of the roadways involved: Garfield Avenue Garfield Avenue is a local roadway with a general north/south orientation under the jurisdiction of West Orange Township and spans approximately 300 feet from Shelley Terrace. There are no posted speed limit signs on Garfield Avenue – the speed limit is assumed to be 25 mph, consistent with the statutory speed limit established for New Jersey via Title 39 for residential streets. The roadway is approximately 30 feet wide and accommodates two-way traffic and parking on both sides. No pavement markings are present on the roadway. Land uses along Garfield Avenue are residential in nature.
Page 2 of 5 Shelley Terrace Shelley Terrace is a local roadway with a general east/west orientation under the jurisdiction of West Orange Township and spans approximately 1,000 feet from Roosevelt Avenue. There are no posted speed limit signs on Shelley Terrace – the speed limit is assumed to be 25 mph, consistent with the statutory speed limit established for New Jersey via Title 39 for residential streets. The roadway is approximately 30 feet wide and accommodates two-way traffic and parking on both sides. Crosswalk, double yellow, and stop bar striping are present at various locations on the roadway. Land uses along Shelley Terrace are residential in nature. The intersection of Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace is uncontrolled ‘T’ style intersection. Other than the crosswalk striping across Garfield Avenue, no pavement markings are present at the intersection. However, the intersection functions as a single approach lane in each direction. The intersection location is depicted in Figure 1 below. Figure 1: Study Intersection Location Map Legend Study Intersection Garfield Avenue Study Intersection Shelley Terrace
Page 3 of 5 Data Collection Crash History The New Jersey Department of Transportation’s Numetrics based crash database was consulted to review the existing crash history at the intersection. Based on the Numetrics database, there have been no vehicular crashes at the intersection of Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace from January 1, 2019 to August 1, 2026. Field Observations T&M conducted a field investigation on September 10, 2026 to determine existing conditions, existing traffic control and note any significant issues that may influence the location of any proposed traffic control. The intersection is currently uncontrolled and sight lines are obstructed due to overgrown foliage. A photo of the intersection is provided below in Figure 2. Figure 2: Shelley Terrace & Garfield Avenue Shelley Terrace
Page 4 of 5 Analysis and Recommendations It is our recommendation that stop control be implemented along the southbound, Garfield Avenue approach at the study intersection. Treatments which can be considered include but are not limited to: Sight Distance Improvements - At the intersection of Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace, the line of sight of approaching vehicles was found to be obstructed. We observed that if vehicles stop closer to the mainline on Shelley Terrace, then they would have clear visibility of the traffic conditions at the intersection and would be able to safely make a turn onto Shelley Terrace. It is our opinion that sight distance at the intersection can be improved by trimming trees and overgrown foliage within the sight triangles. We recommend that the Township coordinate with residents, as reasonable, to remove sight obstructions. It is our recommendation that stop control be implemented along the southbound, Garfield Avenue approach consistent with Figure 3 below. The installation of a stop sign at the head of the T intersection is consistent with driver expectation. Figure 3: Shelley Terrace & Garfield Avenue STOP Sign Installation STOP Shelley Terrace
Page 5 of 5 Figure 4: Intersection Sight Distance After the installation of stop control, we recommend the intersection be monitored to determine if supplemental traffic control devices are necessary such as a stop bar or double yellow line or if intersection sight distances should be improved. Conclusions It is our recommendation, based on our review of the data presented herewith, and the guidance from the MUTCD and Title 39, that the Township of West Orange should implement stop control on the southbound, Garfield Avenue approach at the intersection of Garfield Avenue and Shelley Terrace. The intersection should be monitored after installation to determine if additional signing or striping is necessary. If you have any questions or require any additional information regarding this intersection, please feel free to contact this office at 973-859-5330. Sincerely, T&M ASSOCIATES Joseph A. Fishinger, PE, PP, PTOE Group Manager, Traffic NJ PE# 24GE04613400
Page 1 of 5 September 21, 2026 VIA EMAIL (zcarballo@westorange.org) Zayibeth Carballo, PE, PLS, PP, CME, CFM, CFS Director, Municipal Engineer Department of Engineering Township of West Orange 25 Lakeside Avenue West Orange, New Jersey 07052 Re: Stop Sign Evaluation Shiel Court & McGuire Drive West Orange Township, Essex County, New Jersey Dear Ms. Carballo: T&M Associates has been tasked by the Township of West Orange to perform an evaluation of the existing traffic controls at the intersection of Shiel Court & McGuire Drive to assess the safety conditions at the intersection and determine the appropriate location for ‘stop’ control consistent with the 11th Edition of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). This letter report represents our findings: Existing Conditions Field investigations were conducted by T&M to obtain an inventory of existing roadway conditions, traffic control, adjacent land uses and lane configurations. The following is a brief description of the roadways involved: Shiel Court Shiel Court is a local roadway with a general north/south orientation under the jurisdiction of West Orange Township and spans approximately 150 feet from McGuire Drive. There are no posted speed limit signs on McGuire Drive – the speed limit is assumed to be 25 mph, consistent with the statutory speed limit established for New Jersey via Title 39 for residential streets. The roadway is approximately 30 feet wide and accommodates two-way traffic and parking on both sides. No pavement markings are present on the roadway. Land uses along Shiel Court are residential in nature.
Page 2 of 5 McGuire Drive McGuire Drive is a local roadway with a general east/west orientation under the jurisdiction of West Orange Township and spans approximately 1,900 feet from Colonial Woods Drive. There are no posted speed limit signs on McGuire Drive – the speed limit is assumed to be 25 mph, consistent with the statutory speed limit established for New Jersey via Title 39 for residential streets. The roadway is approximately 30 feet wide and accommodates two-way traffic and parking on both sides. No pavement markings are present on the roadway. Land uses along McGuire Drive are residential in nature. The intersection of Shiel Court & McGuire Drive is uncontrolled ‘T’ style intersection. Pavement markings are not present at the intersection, however the intersection functions as a single approach lane in each direction. The intersection location is depicted in Figure 1 below. Figure 1: Study Intersection Location Map Legend Study Intersection Shiel Court Study Intersection McGuire Drive
Page 3 of 5 Data Collection Crash History The New Jersey Department of Transportation’s Numetrics based crash database was consulted to review the existing crash history at the intersection. Based on the Numetrics database, there have been no vehicular crashes at the intersection of Shiel Court & McGuire Drive from January 1, 2019 to August 1, 2026. Field Observations T&M conducted a field investigation on September 10, 2026 to determine existing conditions, existing traffic control and note any significant issues that may influence the location of any proposed traffic control. The intersection is currently uncontrolled and sight lines are generally clear. A photo of the intersection is provided below in Figure 2. Figure 2: McGuire Drive & Shiel Court McGuire Drive
Page 4 of 5 Analysis and Recommendations It is our recommendation that stop control be implemented along the northbound, Shiel Court approach consistent with Figure 3 below. The installation of a stop sign at the head of the T intersection is consistent with driver expectation and proper sight lines are present. Figure 3: McGuire Drive & Shiel Court STOP Sign Installation Figure 4: Intersection Sight Distance STOP McGuire Drive
Page 5 of 5 After the installation of stop control, we recommend the intersection be monitored to determine if supplemental traffic control devices are necessary such as a stop bar or double yellow line or if intersection sight distances should be improved. Conclusions It is our recommendation, based on our review of the data presented herewith, and the guidance from the MUTCD and Title 39, that the Township of West Orange should implement stop control on the northbound, Shiel Court approach at the intersection of Shiel Court & McGuire Drive. The intersection should be monitored after installation to determine if additional signing or striping is necessary. If you have any questions or require any additional information regarding this intersection, please feel free to contact this office at 973-859-5330. Sincerely, T&M ASSOCIATES Joseph A. Fishinger, PE, PP, PTOE Group Manager, Traffic NJ PE# 24GE04613400
File revisions (1)
- Nov 7, 2026
755a122816ae4,049,426 bytes