Supporting Documentation · Nov 23, 2026
3002-26 Multi Way Stop Analysis - Woodland Ave Redwood Ave.pdf
a3412be1b8c497f75441774dd73e64c1797400cfeeab9f8aed9f8722084e1681Indexed text
3002-26 Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey Prepared for: October 26, 2026 ____________________________________ 11 Tindall Road Middletown, NJ 07748 732-671-6400 Joseph A. Fishinger, Jr., PE, PP, PTOE NJ PE License Number 46134 T&M Project Number TWOR-00091
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey _____________________________________________________________________________________ Table of Contents Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 1 Roadway Characteristics......................................................................................................... 2 Traffic Data Collection ............................................................................................................. 2 All-Way Stop Warrant Analysis ............................................................................................... 2 Summary of Results ................................................................................................................ 4 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................... 5 i
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey _____________________________________________________________________________________ Introduction Redwood Avenue The Township of West Orange has requested that a multi-way stop warrant analysis be performed for the intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue located in Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey. This report has been prepared to review applicable multi-way stop warrant criteria and to determine whether the installation of a multi-way stop is warranted based on current MUTCD guidelines. The study intersection can be seen in Figure 1 below. Redwood Elementary School Woodland Avenue Legend Study Intersection Figure 1: Study Intersection Map 1
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey _____________________________________________________________________________________ Roadway Characteristics Woodland Avenue is classified as an Urban Major Collector roadway with a general east-west orientation under the jurisdiction of the Township of West Orange. The roadway provides a two-lane undivided section. On-street parking is permitted along the south side of Woodland Avenue on the eastbound approach to the Woodland Avenue/Terrace Avenue intersection. West of the intersection, parking is restricted along both sides of Woodland Avenue. The speed limit is posted at 25 MPH within the study area, except for a school speed limit of 20 MPH from 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM and 3:00 PM to 5:00 PM on weekdays from Stevens Terrace to Terrace Avenue. The existing land uses along Woodland Avenue in this section consist of an elementary school, a senior residential facility, a childcare center, a place of worship, and residential homes. Redwood Avenue is classified as an Urban Local roadway with a general north-south orientation under the jurisdiction of the Township of West Orange. The roadway provides a two-lane undivided section with parking permitted along the east side of Redwood Avenue. The speed limit is posted at 25 MPH within the study area, except for a school speed limit of 20 MPH from 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM and 3:00 PM to 5:00 PM on weekdays from Ellis Street to Woodland Avenue The existing land uses along Redwood Avenue in this section consist of an elementary school and residential homes. Traffic Data Collection Turning Movement Counts (TMCs) were obtained on Thursday, September 24, 2026, between the hours of 6:00 AM to 6:00 PM at the following intersection: 1. Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue We note that the weather on the date of the data collection was fair and schools, including the nearby elementary school, were in regular session. Peak hours were observed to be from 8:00 AM to 9:00 AM and 4:00 PM to 5:00 PM, with a total of 411 vehicles and 14 pedestrian crossings recorded during the weekday morning peak hour and a total of 398 vehicles and 2 pedestrian crossings recorded during the weekday evening peak hour. All supporting traffic count data sheets can be found in Appendix B. All-Way Stop Warrant Analysis The
total of 398 vehicles and 2 pedestrian crossings recorded during the weekday evening peak hour. All supporting traffic count data sheets can be found in Appendix B. All-Way Stop Warrant Analysis The all-way stop warrant criteria identified in the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), 2023 Edition was reviewed to determine the applicability of all-way stop control at the intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue. The MUTCD states that the decision to establish all-way stop control at an unsignalized intersection should be based on an engineering study which includes an analysis of 2
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey _____________________________________________________________________________________ factors related to the existing operation and safety at the intersection, the potential to improve these conditions, and the applicable factors contained in the all-way stop control warrants. The following section discusses whether each warrant is satisfied at the subject intersection. Furthermore, the overall results of the warrant analyses are shown summarized in Table 3 below. Additionally, an excerpt from the MUTCD defining the criteria for each warrant and supporting Warrant D exhibit can be found in Appendix A. Warrant A, Crash Experience – The New Jersey Department of Transportation’s Numetrics based crash database was consulted to review the existing crash history at the intersection. The crash history from January 1, 2019 to August 1, 2026 is shown in Table 1 below: DATE 6/6/22 8/30/22 5/3/26 STREET Woodland Avenue Woodland Avenue Woodland Avenue CROSS STREET Redwood Avenue Redwood Avenue Redwood Avenue TYPE Fixed Object Opposite Direction Side Swipe Backing CIRCUMSTANCE Driver Inattention Improper Turning Driver Inattention As shown in Table 1, three reported crashes occurred at the study intersection during the review period. The first and third crashes, on June 6, 2022, and May 3, 2026, was attributed to driver inattention. The second crash, on August 30, 2022, was due to improper turning. None of the crashes were susceptible to correction through the installation of all-way stop control. In addition, the intersection does not meet the crash frequency thresholds specified in MUTCD Section 2B.13 for All-Way Stop Control Warrant A. Therefore, Warrant A is not met. Warrant B, Sight Distance – During a field visit to the intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue, it was observed that drivers on the eastbound approach of Terrace Avenue experience limited sight distance at the stop bars, restricting their ability to detect conflicting traffic. While NJDOT designates the driver decision point as 14.5 feet behind the edge of the traveled way which accounts for shoulders and parking lanes, the existing travel lanes on Woodland Avenue are not clearly delineated. As a result, through traffic was observed traveling closer along
e traveled way which accounts for shoulders and parking lanes, the existing travel lanes on Woodland Avenue are not clearly delineated. As a result, through traffic was observed traveling closer along the curb line rather than the roadway centerline. Consequently, the effective decision point had to be taken 14.5 feet behind the curb line extension, where available sight distance was inadequate at the eastbound approach looking left due to roadway geometry. As shown in Table 2 below, the available sight distances at the subject intersection exceeded the minimum stopping sight distance except for the eastbound approach looking left. Therefore, Warrant B is met. 3
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey 4 _____________________________________________________________________________________ Table 2: Sight Distance Comparison Side Street Available Sight Distance * Looking Left Looking Right Approach Redwood Avenue at Woodland Avenue Eastbound ~80' >200' Westbound >200' >200' Minimum Stopping Sight Distance ** 200' * Observed during September 22, 2026 field visit. ** Obtained from NJDOT Roadway Design Manual Chapter 4.2, Table 4-1 with a 30 MPH design speed. Warrant C, Transition to Signal Control or Transition to Yield Control at a Circular Intersection – Neither a signal nor roundabout is planned at the subject intersection. Therefore, Warrant C is not applicable. Warrant D, 8-Hour Volumes (Vehicles, Pedestrians, & Bicycles) – Traffic volumes along the major road exceed the 300 vehicles/hour criteria for 10 hours of the counted day, while traffic volumes along the minor (stop-controlled) road exceed the 200 vehicles/hour criteria for 0 hours of the counted day. This equates to a total of 0 hours where both the major and minor road volume criteria are met, which is below the 8-hour warrant threshold. Therefore, Warrant D is not met. Warrant E, Other Factors – An engineering evaluation of the study intersection did not identify any other factors that would warrant the installation of all-way stop control. Therefore, Warrant E is not met. Summary of Results As shown in Table 3 below, multi-way stop-control is warranted at the study intersection based on the applicable MUTCD criteria. Table 3: Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Summary MUTCD Warrant A B C D E Description Crash Experience Sight Distance Transition to Signal Control or Transition to Yield Control at a Circular Intersection 8-Hour Volumes (Vehicles, Pedsestrians & Bicycles) Other Factors Multi-Way Stop Control Warranted? Met Not Met X X N/A X X YES
Multi-Way Stop Warrant Analysis Intersection of Woodland Avenue and Redwood Avenue Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey _____________________________________________________________________________________ Conclusion Based on the engineering study, MUTCD All-Way Stop Control Warrant B was found to be satisfied due to restricted sight distance on the eastbound Redwood Avenue approach. Because the sight distance limitation cannot be readily corrected through minor improvements and the intersection is located adjacent to Redwood Elementary School, installation of all-way stop control is recommended at the study intersection. A concept plan depicting the proposed stop bar locations is provided in Appendix C. 5
Appendix A Exhibits
File revisions (1)
- Nov 21, 2026
a3412be1b8c48,132,480 bytes