Packet · Oct 27, 2026
Township Council Meeting — Packet
b34f73d179d0e68ca53811a404f8effa9042c0be32a673e92b686bd42f2cb3f9Indexed text
Proposal, Cultural Resources Township of West Orange Pleasantdale Streetscape Improvements August 20, 2026 Page 3 Intensive-level Historic Architectural Survey The Intensive-level historic architectural survey will determine if previously identified cultural resources and any unidentified significant buildings, historic districts, and structures of greater than 50 years in age are present within the APE-Architecture and will be impacted by the project. Preliminary background research suggests there are approximately 11 previously unidentified and/or unevaluated historic resources within a probable APE-Architecture, consisting primarily of early to mid-twentieth century dwellings and commercial properties. These resources include Block 176.05, Lot 10; Block 176.03, Lots 16 and 17; Block 152.22, Lots 142.01, 142.02, 142.03, and 142.05; Block 154.06, Lots 13, 14, 15, and 18. RGA does not anticipate that all 11 resources will require Intensive-level survey. Important considerations will be if the architectural resource possesses the requisite historical significance and integrity for listing in the NRHP and whether the proposed undertaking has the potential to impact the resource’s ability to meet the NRHP Criteria. Project effects will be assessed on all identified historic properties. Estimated duration: 3 months. Prepare CR Survey Report (3310) RGA will prepare a Cultural Resources Survey Report covering historic architecture. The report will describe the survey and identification/evaluation of resources associated with the project and will follow current guidelines prepared by the NJDOT and the NJHPO. The report will summarize the results of Activity 3305 and will provide the basis for consultation with the NJHPO. Estimated duration: 2 months from completion of all fieldwork. Review CR Survey Report (3315) To be completed by the NJDOT. Estimated duration: 2 weeks. Address NJDOT Comments on CR Survey Report (3320) RGA will incorporate comments received from the NJDOT into a final Cultural Resources Survey report to be submitted to the NJHPO. Estimated duration: 2 weeks. Approve CR Survey Report (3325) To be completed by the NJDOT. Estimated duration: To be determined based on report complexity. ASSUMPTIONS/EXCLUSIONS This proposal assumes that the contractor and/or NJDOT will facilitate entry onto private properties, if necessary, to enable the completion of
mined based on report complexity. ASSUMPTIONS/EXCLUSIONS This proposal assumes that the contractor and/or NJDOT will facilitate entry onto private properties, if necessary, to enable the completion of the Section 106 initiation letter and fieldwork.
Proposal, Cultural Resources Township of West Orange Pleasantdale Streetscape Improvements August 20, 2026 Page 4 Survey tasks can only commence once mapping depicting the LOD is provided. RGA assumes that the project team will additionally provide the LOD as a GIS shapefile or CAD layer file. In the event project plans change after RGA has commenced survey tasks, a supplemental scope will be necessary. Phase IA/IB archaeological survey (i.e., shovel test pits, artifact processing and analysis) is not included. Such work, if required by the NJHPO, will require the submission of supplemental scope of work and cost. As the work does not extend within the boundaries of an NJR-listed historic property, RGA assumes that compliance with the New Jersey Register of Historic Places Act (NJRHPA) and the completion of an Application for Project Authorization (APA) will not be required for this project. Should the NJHPO require the drafting of an APA, a separate scope and cost can be provided for this task. Road and/or shoulder closure permits are not anticipated and not included in this scope. Assistance with drafting an MOA and/or Section 4(f) document (Activity Codes 3335 and 3410) and with the preparation and submission of Adverse Effect Documentation to the FHWA and Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (Activity Code 3350) is not included and would require a supplemental scope. Consultation with Native American tribes and other consulting parties will be performed by the NJDOT-BEPR. Should the NJHPO require intensive-level survey of additional historic resources, then a supplemental scope and cost would be needed. Mitigation work, if required, will take place during the Final Design (FD) phase. Archaeological monitoring, if required, would take place during the Construction (CON) phase.
Richard Grubb & Associates, Inc./RGA, Inc. Cost Proposal Cultural Resources Survey (Intensive-level Historic Architectural Survey) Pleasantdale Streetscape Project Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey Labor Costs Rate* Personnel by Title Vice President (PIX) Prin. Sr. Archaeol. I (PVIII) Prin. Sr. Arch. Historian II (PVII) Sr. Archaeol. I (PVI) Sr. Arch. Historian II (PV) Archaeologist I (PIV) Archaeologist II (PIII) Architect. Historian I (PIV) Lab Manager (PIV) Drafter I (ET-III) GIS Technician Technical Editor (PV) Field Technician (PII) Total Hours by Task Total Labor by Task Expense Costs Expense Aerial Photographs Postage Photoduplication $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Activity 3300 Activity 3305 Activity 3310 Activity 3320 65.00 1 60.50 4 53.45 2 8 16 41.50 36.47 4 16 24 2 36.47 4 29.33 32.86 24 200 224 8 32.86 32.45 6 24 4 36.47 36.47 4 16 4 25.08 48 224 305 18 $1,769.88 $7,583.12 $10,518.44 $611.50 Amount $50.00 $25.00 $50.00 $125.00 *Rates based on August 7, 2026 Certified Payroll **FAR Audited and NJDOT Approved Overhead Rate August 20, 2026 Total Hours 1 4 26 0 46 4 0 456 0 34 0 24 0 595 Total Labor $65.00 $242.00 $1,389.70 $0.00 $1,677.62 $145.88 $0.00 $14,984.16 $0.00 $1,103.30 $0.00 $875.28 $0.00 $20,482.94 Direct Labor Total $20,482.94 Overhead** 146.88% Fee 19.5% $30,085.34 $3,994.17 Labor Total Expense Total $54,562.46 $125.00 Total Project Cost Not-To Exceed $54,687.46
FIXED FEE CALCULATION PROJECT: Pleasantdale Streetscape Improvements, Township of West Orange CONSULTANT: Richard Grubb & Associates, Inc. / RGA, Inc. AGREEMENT OR CAM NO. PREPARED BY: DATE: Allee Davis/Paul McEachen, RGA, Inc. 8/20/2026 EVALUATE PROJECT SPECIFICS: Directions: Prime Consultant will use Total Project Design Cost (or Task Order Design Cost) for the SIZE criteria Each Subconsultant will assign points for SIZE, COMPLEXITY, DURATION, & DEGREE OF RISK based on its specific project tasks. POINTS RATING SMALL - Total Fee (Project Design Cost) < $1,250,000 15 15 LARGE - Total Fee (Project Design Cost) > $1,250,000 20 SIMPLE - Limited Scope of Work; Deck Patching, Resurfacing, Restoration, Concept Development, Studies, Surveys, Landscape, Inspections 10 STANDARD - Moderate Scope; Rehabilitation, New, or Reconstruction 15 COMPLEX - Multi-disciplined, Highly Specialized, or Major Unusual 20 STANDARD - Appropriate Schedule 15 AGGRESSIVE - Designers Schedule Reduced > 10 % 20 LEVEL 1 - Low Risk of Claims; Limited Scope of Work, Deck Patching, Resurfacing, Restoration, Concept Development, Studies, Surveys, Landscape, Inspections 20 LEVEL 2 - Average Risk of Claims; Standard Complexity or Level 1 with High Public Exposure 30 LEVEL 3 - High Risk of Claims; Hazardous, Experimental, or Bonus/Penalty Clauses 40 SPECIFICS CRITERIA SIZE: COMPLEXITY: DURATION: DEGREE OF RISK: TOTAL RATING = 15 15 20 65 CALCULATE FEE: PROJECT SPECIFICS FACTOR (Total Rating /100) = 0.65 FEE FACTOR ( Project Specifics Factor x 0.30) = 0.195 DIRECT LABOR COSTS $ 20,482.94 TOTAL FEE (Direct Labor Costs x Fee Factor) = $ 3,994.17 Fixed Fee Calculation Page 1 Revised 08/12/2015
Firm Name: Agreement #: CAM/CAA or Task Order #: Date: Richard Grubb & Associates, Inc (RGA, Inc.) August 7, 2026 Certified Payroll Employee Name ASCE Grade Title Actual Rate as of Selection Posting Date Consultant/ Subconsultant Name P/F Average of each ASCE grade Richard Grubb PIX Director $65.00 F $65.00 Paul McEachen PVIII Principal Senior Archaeologist $60.50 F $60.50 Allee Davis PVII Principal Senior Architectural Historian $52.50 F Lynn Alpert PVII Principal Senior Architectural Historian $52.50 F Chelsea Mansky (Troppauer) PVII Principal Senior Architectural Historian $47.50 F Susan Bamann PVII Principal Senior Archaeologist $57.00 F Michael Gall PVII Principal Senior Archaeologist $57.75 F Sean McHugh PVI Senior Archaeologist $45.00 F Ilene Grossman-Bailey PVI Senior Archaeologist $38.00 P Teresa Bulger PV Senior Historian $39.15 F Virginia Overberger PV Senior Architectural Historian $36.00 P Kristen Herrick PV Senior Architectural Historian $37.50 F Lauren Dunkle PIV Senior Architectural Historian $36.00 F Anastasia Azenaro-Moore PV Senior Architectural Historian $36.55 F Amanda Stamper PV Senior Archaeologist $36.00 F David Strohmeier PV Archaeologist $35.00 F Allen Poyner PV Senior GIS Specialist $35.00 F Cathy Smyrski PV Technical Editor $37.00 F Danielle Cathcart PIV Laboratory Manager $34.50 F Tara Erdriech PIV Laboratory Manager $29.35 P Olivier Vansassenbrouck PIV Geophysical Archaeologist $30.70 F Allison Gall PIV Archaeologist $35.85 F Richard Adamczyk PIV Archaeologist $34.00 F Matt Craig PIV Archaeologist $34.00 F Nicole Herzog PIV Archaeologist $34.00 F Sarah Rosso PIV Architectural Historian $34.00 F Matt Goldberg PIV Architectural Historian $31.75 F Emma Durham PIV Technical Editor $30.40 F Jenn Beggs PIII Architectural Historian $29.00 F David Zaveloff PIII Architectural Historian $28.85 F Allie Marchesani PIII Architectural Historian $26.00 F Lauren Huber PIII Architectural Historian $25.00 F Julia Hayman PIII Architectural
loff PIII Architectural Historian $28.85 F Allie Marchesani PIII Architectural Historian $26.00 F Lauren Huber PIII Architectural Historian $25.00 F Julia Hayman PIII Architectural Historian $25.00 F Jonathan Dernbach PIII Archaeologist $30.75 F Jonathan Hanna PIII Archaeologist $31.00 F Theresa Tripoli PIII Archaeologist $28.00 F Gillian Scholz PIII Archaeologist $27.00 F Abigail Kennedy PIII Archaeologist $27.50 F Adrienne Jarczewski PIII Archaeologist $29.15 F Michele Troutman PIII Archaeologist $29.00 F Ted Gold PIII Archaeologist $31.00 F $53.45 $41.50 $36.47 $32.86 $28.95
Alexander Seng PIII Roy Walton PIII Archaeologist $24.70 F Paul George PIII Archaeologist $44.25 F Jeanette Koczwara PII Research Assistant $25.50 F Cheryl Schlagenhaft PII Field Director $25.00 F Andrew Van Buskirk PII Field Director $26.00 F Giovanni Palumbo PII Field Director $24.00 F Emily Healey PII Field Director $23.00 F Edward McFadden PII Field Director $27.05 F Patricia McEachen ET-III Drafter - I $32.45 F P/F PART OR FULL TIME Archaeologist $27.00 NOTES: THE ASCE GRADE MUST AGREE WITH THE TITLE CONCURRENCE SHEET KEPT ON FILE IN THE BUREAU OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES THE CONSULTANT'S SIGNATORY HEREBY CERTIFIES THAT IT HAS NOT EMPLOYED OR RETAINED ANY COMPANY OR PERSON, OTHER THAN A BONA FIDE EMPLOYEE WORKING FOR THE CONSULTANT, ON A FULL OR PART TIME BASIS, THAT THEY HAVE USED THE DOT FORM, AND THE HOURLY WAGE RATE SHEET CERTIFICATION: PRINCIPAL OF THE FIRM F $25.09 $32.45
Colliers Engineering & Design
TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE NJDOT Transportation Alternatives Set-Aside Program 2025 Pleasantdale Streetscape Project - Pleasant Valley Way (from 250 Feet South of Greenwood Avenue to Kenz Terrace) Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey August 11, 2026 PRELIMINARY ENGINEERING Colliers Engineering & Design (Colliers) will provide public involvement services as a subconsultant to Malick & Scherer, PC (M&S) during the Preliminary Engineering (PE) phase of the Pleasantdale Streetscape Project in the Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey. The project is being advanced under the NJDOT Transportation Alternatives (TA) Set-Aside Design Assistance Program. M&S will serve as the prime consultant and will provide overall project management and coordination of Colliers' services with the Township of West Orange, NJDOT Local Aid, Essex County, and the other project disciplines. Colliers' Preliminary Engineering services will include the following: Activity 3865 – Hold Public Information Center Colliers will organize, coordinate, and facilitate one (1) Public Information Center (PIC) during Preliminary Engineering in accordance with applicable NJDOT public involvement requirements and in coordination with M&S, the Township, and NJDOT. Colliers will coordinate with M&S and the Township regarding the date, location, format, and content of the PIC. The Township will provide the meeting venue. Colliers' services will include: • Coordination and preparation for one (1) PIC. • Preparation of public-facing presentation materials, meeting handouts, sign-in sheets, and meeting advertisements using technical design information and exhibits provided by M&S, and in coordination with the Township and NJDOT. • Presentation and facilitation support during the PIC. • Documentation of comments received from the public, elected officials, stakeholders, businesses, and adjacent property owners. • Preparation of meeting minutes and a summary of public comments. • Coordination with M&S regarding responses to comments and potential refinements to the Preliminary Engineering design resulting from public input. M&S will provide Colliers with the applicable preliminary design information, technical exhibits, environmental information, traffic information, and other technical project information necessary for preparation of the meeting materials. Colliers will be
File revisions (3)
- Oct 29, 2026
b34f73d179d07,514,922 bytes - Oct 25, 2026
fb28c7f156b27,514,933 bytes - Oct 24, 2026
bab8ed2d60c97,514,578 bytes