January 16, 2014

APPLICATION(S) 1. ZB-13-18/Schinman Block: 104; Lot: 10; Zone: R-1 45 Mountain Avenue Two “C” variances for the height of constructing an accessory structure to a primary residence. EXHIBITS A-1— Rendered site plan with photographs of existing conditions A-2 — Comparisons of height of old barn to proposed structure A-3 — Elevations with picture depicting materials to be used for the proposed structure A-4 — Rendering of the new structure A-5 — Sheet A101 of the basement plan prepared by Kenneth Nadler dated 12/23/13 A-6 — Sheet A102 of the first floor plan prepared by Kenneth Nadler dated 12/23/13 A-7 ~ Sheet A103 of the second floor plan prepared by Kenneth Nadler dated 12/23/13 A-8 — Planning report (6 pages) prepared by Peter G. Steck O-1 — Survey prepared by Casey and Keller dated 8/29/89 O-2 - Photo taken from Mountain Avenue of proposed site by objector Julie Day O-4, 5, 6 — Photos of the original barn on the proposed site, taken by objector Julie Day, which was demolished by applicant O-7 — Photo taken of the proposed site, by objector Julie Day, from her driveway Q-8 — Photo taken by objector Julie Day, from her driveway, of the fence around the outdoor tennis court on the applicant’s property. Mr. Neuer recused himself from hearing this application and left the dais. Robert Williams, Esq., attorney for the applicant approached the podium and detailed the application. He said that the applicant is requesting two “C” variances for the height of an accessory structure being constructed in the rear of the home that sits on approximately ten (10) acres in Llewellyn Park. Mr. Williams called his first witness. Kenneth R. Nadler approached the podium and was sworn under oath, Mr. Nadler detailed his educational and professional background as a licensed architect in the State of New Jersey. Chairwoman Gabry asked Mr. Nadler if he has testified before Boards before for similar projects; he replied yes. Chairwoman Gabry accepted Mr. Nadler as an expert in Architecture. Mr. Nadler presented a rendered site plan with photographs depicting the existing conditions. Chairwoman Gabry noted for the record that the photographs were pre-marked as Exhibit A-1 for identification only and asked Mr. Nadler if he took theses photos; he replied no. She asked Mr. Nadler who took the photos; he said that the client took the photos.