Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text · page 14

Show all pages
Page 14

Ms. Rudin clarified that Mr. Pehnke had mentioned 63 vehicles exiting during an hour in his study. Mr. Pehnke explained that he had discussed a variation in traffic and had provided specifics regarding right turns and left turns. In general, he stated that coming out of Oval Road, volumes are between approximately 90 and 120 vehicles per hour. Regarding the Country Club, on a typical day, volumes are very low in the morning. As the afternoon progresses, the Country Club sees approximately 40 to 60 vehicles per hour during the evening hours. Mr. Pehnke again emphasized that the volume varies by hour. Ms. Rudin asked whether the police, fire department, and EMS had reviewed the proposal. Mr. Pehnke stated that he could not speak to what the Town's professionals may have reviewed. Ms. Rudin asked whether adding the traffic light could affect emergency response times. Mr. Pehnke stated that it would not. Ms: Rudin asked what evidence demonstrates that the traffic signal is the “absolute best and least intrusive solution” to the problem. Mr. Pehnke stated that least intrusive is not a criteria. He explained that the goal is to solve multiple concerns at the intersection. These concerns include: o Volume operation o Substandard geometry © Some questionable sight lines © Operations. Ms. Rudin asked why the engineers did not look at getting traffic off of Eagle Rock Avenue and evaluate an exit at Laurel Avenue. Mr. Pehnke stated that Laurel is just as heavy a county road. He said there is therefore no advantage to trying to concentrate all of the traffic there. Ms. Rudin stated that there is a lot of land on Laurel and a lot of land that could potentially be exited from Laurel. She asked whether any other rerouting of internal traffic patterns had been considered. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application before the Board is the application being evaluated. He referred to testimony from the last meeting and from the Country Club manager. He explained that the application is also associated with the intent to improve the intersection of Oval Road. Ms. Rudin asked what the total cost of installation for the traffic light would be. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not calculated it. Ms. Rudin asked who would be responsible for paying for all of the improvements. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application carries the burden of the costs. Ms. Rudin asked who the application

Page 14

culated it. Ms. Rudin asked who would be responsible for paying for all of the improvements. Mr. Pehnke stated that the application carries the burden of the costs. Ms. Rudin asked who the application was being paid for by. Mr. Pehnke stated the applicant, Crestmont Country Club, and that Crestmont is coordinating with West Essex Highlands. Ms. Rudin asked whether there are annual maintenance and electricity costs associated with the traffic signal. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that there are such costs. Ms. Rudin asked who would bear those expenses. Mr. Pehnke explained that, generally, in a situation such as this, the County will enter into a developer's agreement with the property owners. The agreement would apportion those costs between the County and the property owner as they see fit. Ms. Rudin asked Mr. Pehnke whether he had said that Laurel Avenue is “just as bad as Eagle Rock.” Mr. Pehnke clarified that Laurel is also a heavily traveled county road. Ms. Rudin asked whether it would be safer to drive some of the traffic to Eagle Rock rather than pushing it onto Laurel or “circuiting it through Laurel.” Mr. Pehnke responded, not necessarily. Ms. Rudin asked what he meant by “not necessarily.” Mr. Pehnke explained that the impacts would have to be studied. He stated that this had not been done. He also stated 14

File revisions (1)