Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text · page 15

Show all pages
Page 15

that there was no reason to do that because it was not the application before the Board that evening. Ms. Rudin asked why that study was not done. She stated that if the concern was that there is a lot of traffic coming out of the Country Club, which is a very large land mass, she questioned why another study was not done on another egress that could be constructed. Mr. Pehnke stated the application arises from a requirement of West Essex Highlands. He explained that the requirement comes from a settlement agreement with the Township. Under that settlement agreement, West Essex Highlands is required to pursue traffic signalization. Ms. Rudin asked whether Mr. Pehnke was testifying that the whole application was really not being driven by Crestmont Country Club. Mr. Pehnke stated that it was both, but that it was also being driven by another application, which the Board had recently rejected. Dr. Deborah Fruchtman-Butensky, at 11 Rapley Court, asked Mr. Pehnke whether he had ever done a traffic study to prove, “beyond the shadow of the doubt,” that traffic on Oval Road would actually be improved rather than impeded by having the proposed traffic light there. Mr. Pehnke responded that the traffic studies they had done and prepared show that the intersection would be substantially improved as part of the application. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether the study also demonstrated that the traffic signal would not cause traffic backup during school hours and in the morning, and asked how that was done as a hypothetical. Mr. Pehnke clarified that it was not done as a hypothetical. He explained that there are analysis procedures available to engineers that are used nationwide and are accepted by the transportation industry. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked whether there was also a traffic study done to assess how the light would affect traffic going into and out of Pleasantdale Chateau. Mr. Pehnke stated that this was included in the analysis. He said that people coming out of the Chateau would have the advantage of the traffic signal and reiterated that, in his opinion, ingress to the Chateau would not be impacted. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky stated there is no longer bus service going down and east-west on Eagle Rock Avenue because the DeCamp line is gone. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then questioned how many traffic accidents had occurred at the site referenced in the

Page 15

bus service going down and east-west on Eagle Rock Avenue because the DeCamp line is gone. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then questioned how many traffic accidents had occurred at the site referenced in the five-year study and whether there had been a two-year study. Mr. Pehnke stated that they did not have pedestrian accident data, but stated that the proposed improvement provides an opportunity for and a safe crossing location at an appropriate location along Eagle Rock Avenue that does not exist today. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked where the public could see the traffic studies that Mr. Pehnke was referring to. Mr. Pehnke stated that the study is in the record and is available for inspection. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky asked why a right-turn-only egress had never been evaluated so that the traffic light would not be needed. Mr. Pehnke deferred to the record from the last meeting, which he said laid the foundation for the overall objectives of the project. He explained that the project is not just about the driveway and ties into the improvements at Oval Road, making it a “bigger package.” Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky questioned how they could know that the project was an improvement and not a detriment. Mr. Pehnke responded that there are identifiable substandard conditions, which he had walked through during the last meeting. He stated that these conditions are readily observable by an engineer as well as the public. Dr. Fruchtman-Butensky then asked whether there was a difference between improvements for the Country Club people and improvements for residents who reside at the Grand and the Highlands. She specifically asked whether Mr. Pehnke had considered the impact to the residents alone, rather than statements about improving egress and 15

File revisions (1)