Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text · page 20

Show all pages
Page 20

Crestmont. Mr. Pehnke stated that testimony regarding this issue had been placed into the record the previous month concerning the obligations under a settlement agreement with the Township for West Essex Highlands and the Country Club’s involvement in working with it. Ms. Klein asked whether the plan, as it stood at that moment, was consistent with Safe Streets and Vision Zero. Mr. Pehnke stated that the plan incorporates all the “toolbox- type” improvements that would be consistent with Safe Streets and Vision Zero. Ms. Klein asked whether there was a written determination from the County stating that the traffic signal was warranted or whether the conclusion was based only on conversations. Mr. Pehnke stated that there is an application with the County and that the applicant had a pre-application meeting with the County. He stated that the County had indicated its concurrence that it believed this was an appropriate location for traffic control and should be controlled, and that the applicant fully expected the County to approve the application. Mr. Paul Tractenberg asked Mr. Pehnke whether, if the County were to deny the traffic signal, that would mean the project would be abandoned by the Country Club or whether there would be something the Country Club could choose to salvage. Mr. Pehnke responded that he could not speak to what the Country Club may or may not do based on that hypothetical. Ms. Luisa Casar, at 59 Davy Road, asked Mr. Pehnke whether he was aware of a massive apartment/townhouse development currently being built on Harrison Avenue in Roseland, New Jersey. Ms. Casar explained that the development is split into two primary residential phases and one future designated development. She stated that the proximity of the development to Eagle Rock Avenue is a concern because it will “undoubtedly contribute adversely” to an already high traffic volume. Ms. Casar asked whether Mr. Pehnke had taken this development into consideration because of its size. Mr. Pehnke stated that the development is taken into consideration through the growth factors that the County and State require engineers to use to accommodate regional growth patterns. Ms. Casar asked what those factors were. Mr. Pchnke explained that growth factors are published by the Department of Transportation on a yearly basis and are used to project traffic forward. Ms. Casar asked

Page 20

ar asked what those factors were. Mr. Pchnke explained that growth factors are published by the Department of Transportation on a yearly basis and are used to project traffic forward. Ms. Casar asked for an example. Mr. Pehnke stated that, for example, on arterial roads in Essex County, he believed the current growth factor was an anticipated 1.75% per year. He stated that this number is updated every year based upon traffic count data. Ms. Casar clarified that Eagle Rock Avenue is a County road, not a highway. Mr. Pehnke agreed. Ms. Casar stated that she wanted to understand how the development would impact Oval Road. Ms. Casar stated that she believed the development needed to be taken into consideration because the traffic pattern is already “incredible,” especially during rush hour, and that adding the traffic light and congestion would further exacerbate the problem. Mr. Pehnke disagreed and stated that it would actually be the opposite. He explained that growth of traffic along Eagle Rock Avenue would make it more and more difficult for residents on Oval Road and the Crestmont Country Club to exit onto Eagle Rock Avenue. Ms. Jennifer Sharret asked whether there would be digging or other work on the other side of the roadway, right above Edgemont. Mr. Pehnke stated that he was not sure he understood what she meant by digging. 20

File revisions (1)