Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text · page 8

Show all pages
Page 8

accommodate increased traffic, including traffic from the West Essex Highlands project should that project advance. Mr. Trachtenberg noted that the Planning Board had denied the West Essex Highlands application and that it appeared that there would be no additional traffic from that development in the near future. He asked whether that affected Mr. Pehnke's analysis. Mr. Pehnke stated that it did not. Mr. Trachtenberg asked whether, in Mr. Pehnke's judgment, the traffic signal was required whether or not the additional development occurred. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it was. Mr. Trachtenberg asked Mr. Pehnke to elaborate on his earlier statement that the signal at Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue could communicate with the proposed new signal. Mr. Pehnke explained that, when traffic signals are located along an arterial corridor, the goal is to coordinate them. He explained that this is currently done by installing GPS units, essentially clocks, that tie into satellites so that all signals or controllers operate at the exact same time. Mr. Pehnke stated that, once the signals are synchronized, their operations can be coordinated to maintain progressive flow along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Trachtenberg asked about his understanding that there was an engineering principle or traffic signal rule requiring signals to be at least 1,000 feet apart and asked whether he was stating that accurately. Mr. Pehnke stated that this was incorrect. Mr. Pehnke explained that traffic signals can be as close as a couple hundred feet apart and that there are examples of this throughout the area. Mr. Tractenberg asked whether, in Karl Pehnke’s professional opinion, having two traffic signals on Eagle Rock Avenue within approximately 800-820 feet would be an issue. Mr. Pehnke responded that it would not be an issue. He stated that the additional signal would improve traffic flow and safety in the area. Mr. Tractenberg asked whether, in Mr. Pehnke’s professional opinion, the major reason for signalizing the intersection is public safety rather than the convenience of the Country Club and its members. Mr. Pehnke responded that there are a multitude of reasons. Seth Weisleder, at 17 Howe Drive, asked what current operational problems exist with the existing driveway. Mr. Pehnke referred to his testimony from the previous meeting and explained that the existing driveway: o Comes down

Page 8

Drive, asked what current operational problems exist with the existing driveway. Mr. Pehnke referred to his testimony from the previous meeting and explained that the existing driveway: o Comes down onto Eagle Rock Avenue at an acute angle. © Has a final section that is relatively steep, approximately 78%, as it approaches Eagle Rock Avenue. o Enters Eagle Rock Avenue just to the west side of a bend in the road. o Has restricted sight lines due to existing tree lines and vegetation. © Makes it difficult for drivers to look left and back up Eagle Rock Avenue because of the acute angle. Mr. Weisleder asked how many crashes had occurred at the current driveway during the previous five years and whether this had been evaluated. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not done that analysis. Mr. Weisleder asked whether there was a documented safety problem today, beyond Mr. Pehnke’s testimony. Mr. Pehnke responded that they had not researched or evaluated the location based on particular accident data. Mr. Weisleder asked whether Essex County had requested that the driveway be moved. Mr. Pehnke explained that several years ago, before his involvement, the issue had arisen in connection with the West Essex Highland application, which is off Oval Road. Mr. Weisleder asked whether Pehnke’s analysis evaluates the future 2027 build, including the West Essex Highlands development. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it does.

File revisions (1)