Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 10

Show all pages
Page 10

improvements and that those materials had been reviewed by the Township. He reiterated that his role was to respond to questions concerning civil engineering and site design rather than repeat the traffic engineer's testimony. Dr. Butensky asked for clarification on how the proposed driveway of approximately 8% grade couldn’t be dangerous during winter conditions. Mr. Cote explained that an 8% grade is acceptable under applicable standards and that certain standards could permit grades of up to 12%. Mr. Paul Tractenberg of 96 Sullivan Drive, referred to a March 17, 2026 letter from Mr. Schkolnick to the Planning Board Secretary and the Planning Board. He stated that the ; letter identified several items for which the applicant was seeking relief from Township ordinance requirements governing the R2 zone. Mr. Tractenberg first questioned the proposed retaining wall height, noting that the ordinance permits a'maximum height of 4 feet while the applicant proposes a retaining hwall:approximately 21.5.feet high, more than five times the permitted height. He asked Mr: \Gote:to.explain the justification for such a substantial deviation. Mr. Cote explained that the proposed retaining wall is located in conjunction with the stormwater simanagement basin required to attenuate runoff from the site. He stated that the wall height'is necessary to accommodate the stormwater management infrastructure while maintaining reasonable grades in the upper parking lot. Mri Tractenbergnext questioned the minimum setback from the top of steep slopes having grades between 10% and 30%. He stated that the ordinance requires a 50-foot setback whilethe applicant proposes a 10-foot setback. He asked whether this reduction wouldicreate any:safety concerns. Mr. Cote stated that he did not believe the proposed setback would create'a safety issue. He explained that the design was intended to minimiizeidisturbance to the property and avoid removing additional trees. He stated that providing the fulb setback would require further tree removal and that the applicant had : beenidirected to minimize impacts on existing trees while providing replacement plantings for disturbed areas. Mr. Tractenberg also questioned the applicant's request for a site plan waiver concerning ‘:tree removal on:slopes of 10% or greater. He stated that the application proposes temoving 191 trees located on

Page 10

ractenberg also questioned the applicant's request for a site plan waiver concerning ‘:tree removal on:slopes of 10% or greater. He stated that the application proposes temoving 191 trees located on slopes of 10% or greater. Mr. Cote confirmed that the number was accurate. Mr. Tractenberg asked whether Mr. Cote believed that the proposed tree removal was justified. Mr. Cote stated that the removals were associated with the positioning of the proposed improvements, the need to connect the site improvements to existing grades, and the installation of drainage structures necessary to mitigate stormwater runoff and improve drainage along Eagle Rock Avenue. He explained that the affected portions of the property are located near Eagle Rock Avenue and within areas having slopes of 10% or greater. Mr. Tractenberg next questioned the minimum setback from the top of steep slopes exceeding 30%. He stated that the ordinance requires a 100-foot setback while the applicant proposes a 10-foot setback. Mr. Cote confirmed that the proposed reduction was justified for the same reasons previously discussed, including minimizing disturbance and accommodating the proposed infrastructure and site improvements. Mr. Tractenberg questioned whether all of the requested ordinance deviations were being sought to add parking spaces and reconfigure the exit from a private country club. He referred to 36 additional parking spaces and stated that the existing parking lot was already hundreds of spaces short of the ordinance requirement. Mr. Cote confirmed that the requested deviations were associated with the parking and driveway improvements

File revisions (1)