Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 11

Show all pages
Page 11

Mr. Kevin Malanga of Ridge Road asked Mr. Cote whether a complete and accurate survey of trees proposed for removal was required for the project. Mr. Cote confirmed that a tree survey had already been completed and that the trees proposed for removal were identified on the submitted plans. Mr. Malanga asked whether the applicant had agreed to construct a sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue eastward to the end of the Crestmont Country Club property. Mr. Cote confirmed that this was correct. Mr. Malanga asked whether a tree removal survey had been prepared for the proposed sidewalk and whether those trees were included in the applicant's tree removal calculations: Mr: Gote explained that the sidewalk would be constructed within the area of disturbance already included in the original design and that all affected trees had already been accounted for. He confirmed that the sidewalk would not require the removal of any additional trees. Mr. Malanga asketl whether the proposed sidewalk would comply with the Americans withDisabilities Act. Mr! Cote stated that the sidewalk would comply with the Public Right-of-Way Accessibility Guidelines (PROWAG), which establish accessibility requirements for pedestrian facilities within public roadways. Mr«Malanga asked whither the applicant had surveyed the property to confirm that the sidewalk could:be constructed in compliance with those requirements. Mr. Cote confirmed yes Mr. Malanga asked whether that determination had been made before the Board requested: the sidewalk at the previous hearing. Mr. Cote explained that the sidewalk had not originally been anticipated, but the grades and clear areas established through the original survey and site designiwere sufficient to incorporate it without requiring changes to the proposed grading. Mr, Malanga asked whether the applicant understood that it would be responsible for maintaining the sidewalk, including snow removal. Mr. Cote stated that it was his understanding that the applicant would be responsible. ©. Mr. S¢hkolnick clarified that the sidewalk maintenance responsibilities had not yet been finalized. oy «Mr. Cote explained that Eagle Rock Avenue is a County road and that inainfenance responsibilities would ultimately depend on the agreements reached with the County. Mr, Malanga again asked whether the applicant would be responsible for snow removal and

Page 11

y road and that inainfenance responsibilities would ultimately depend on the agreements reached with the County. Mr, Malanga again asked whether the applicant would be responsible for snow removal and sidewalk:maintenance. Mr. Cote reiterated that he understood the applicant would be responsible, although he could not provide a definitive answer until the agreements with the County were completed. He stated that he did not anticipate a reason why the applicant would not be responsible. Mr. Malanga asked Mr. Cote whether any retaining walls would need to be constructed for the proposed sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote explained that a retaining wall was already included as part of the original roadway widening and that no additional retaining walls would be required for the sidewalk. Mr. Victor Misarti of Mayfair Drive, referred to two site plan review letters available on the Planning Board agenda. He first referenced an April 2026 review letter from Planning Board Engineer Ryan McNeil, which included comments regarding design, stormwater management, landscaping, and additional information required from the applicant. Mr. Misarti asked whether the applicant intended to revise and resubmit the site plans to address those comments, noting that he had not seen revised plans submitted since the review. Mr. Cote confirmed that the applicant had agreed to address the questions and comments contained in the review letters and that a resubmission would be required.

File revisions (1)