Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 13

Show all pages
Page 13

Ms. Bennett asked whether additional runoff volume, velocity, or concentration would ultimately reach neighboring residential properties. Mr. Cote explained that current stormwater design standards focus on controlling the rate of discharge rather than the total volume. He acknowledged that the additional impervious surface would increase runoff volume but stated that the proposed detention systems would reduce discharge rates in accordance with NJDEP and Township requirements. Ms. Bennett asked whether the stormwater analysis accounted for current rainfall conditions and increasingly intense future storm events or relied solely on historical design assumptions. Mr, Cote confirmed that the analysis included both current and future ‘storm events, as reflected in the runoff calculations he had previously provided. Ms. Bennett askediwhere stormwater would go if the proposed detention system exceeded its design capacity. Mr. Cote explained that both basins would have outfall spillways directing excess water onto Eagle Rock Avenue. He stated that, during storms exceeding the'system's capacity, the water would flow to the same locations where runoff curtently flows, without changing the existing discharge points. Ms- Bennett asked: whether the need for the proposed improvements, or the conditions creating that need; had been anticipated when Crestmont Country Club received its 2023 and 2024 approvals:.Mr: Cote stated that he could not address that question because he had not been involved in those applications. Ms. Benneit‘asked. whether Mr. Cote had reviewed the previous applications. Mr. Cote stated that he ‘was'familiat with the improvements involving pickleball facilities and a ‘building near the parking tot, but those applications had been prepared by a different engineer. Ms, Bennett asked whether any of the improvements currently before the Planning Board had‘been discussed, contemplated, or required as part of the 2023 Planning Board approval or the:2024 Zoning Board approval. Mr. Cote stated that he did not know and was not aware of whether those improvements had been considered during the earlier applications. Ms. Bennett:asked whether ay conditions had changed since those approvals that would make the current improvements necessary. Mr. Cote stated that this was more of an operational question than an engineering question and that he could not

Page 13

s had changed since those approvals that would make the current improvements necessary. Mr. Cote stated that this was more of an operational question than an engineering question and that he could not answer it. Ms‘Bennett asked whether the current application was intended to correct an unforeseen consequence of previously approved development or uses. Mr. Cote stated that he was not aware of any such consequence. MrsLawrence Cohen of:20 Lincoln Avenue asked Mr. Cote for his professional opinion regarding the existing country club driveway, which had been used for many years. He questioned whether the original driveway location had been a reasonable decision, given the visibility to the left and right and its long history of use. Mr. Cote stated that he could not comment on the reasoning behind the original driveway design because he was not familiar with its history. However, he stated that the existing driveway's alignment was not appropriate for vehicles exiting the property Mr. Cohen asked whether the original driveway might have been selected because of its sightlines, seclusion, and privacy for the country club. Mr. Cote reiterated that he did not know the reasons behind the original design. Mr. Cohen also questioned the steepness of the existing driveway, and Mr. Cote stated that the grade varied along its length. Mr. Seth Weisleder of 17 Howell Drive, asked Mr. Cote to explain the existing stormwater runoff problem along Eagle Rock Avenue and how the proposed application would address it. Mr. Cote explained that stormwater currently runs from the property onto Eagle Rock Avenue without being controlled by a detention system. He stated that 13

File revisions (1)