Minutes · Sep 2, 2026
September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7Indexed text · page 23
Show all pagesthat the benefits would extend beyond West Orange to Roseland, Essex Fells, the surrounding community Mr. Schkolnick asked whether Purpose F of the Municipal Land Use Law, which encourages appropriate and efficient expenditure of public funds, factored into Mr. Moronski's analysis, since a private entity would be undertaking improvements involving a traffic signal. Mr. Moronski confirmed that it did. He stated that the public-private coordination between the applicant and the County represented a more efficient way of providing improvements that would benefit the property and the surrounding area. MriSchkolnick:asked/whether the settlement agreement previously discussed by Ms. Cancellaro, iricluding the possibility of eminent domain, affected Mr. Moronski's planning analysis. Mr. Moronski stated that the applicant's cooperation with the County, Township, and other involved :parties was a positive factor. He explained that this cooperation furthered public improyements and was consistent with Purpose M of the Municipal Land Use Law. Mr: Schkolnick again asked whether Mr. Moronski saw any negative impacts on surrounding properties. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not and reiterated that the > application would not cause a substantial detriment to the public good or substantial impairment of the zone plan or zoning ordinance. Mr. Schkolnick/asked how Mr. Penke's testimony regarding safety improvements factored into Mr. Moronski's planning analysis. Mri Moronski stated that the safety, circulation, drainage, and physical improvements, both on-site arid along Eagle Rock Avenue, worked together. He stated that, from a planning perspective, the improvements satisfied the applicable Municipal Land Use Law criteria. BOARD QUESTIONS Mr. Gitarind asked.whether Essex County had provided any additional proposals or requests durin{ its discussions with the applicant and, if so, how the applicant had responded: Mr. Moronski:stated that he had not been directly involved in the discussions with:the:County.'He explained that Mr. Penke had been involved in those discussions and that his own:knowledge was based on the submitted application, testimony, and discussions with his professional colleagues. Mr. Guarino askéd whether the proposed pedestrian walkways, lighting, sidewalks, and crosswalks had been sufficiently evaluated to create a safe, walkable area for
s with his professional colleagues. Mr. Guarino askéd whether the proposed pedestrian walkways, lighting, sidewalks, and crosswalks had been sufficiently evaluated to create a safe, walkable area for individuals using Crestmont Country Club and its facilities. Mr. Moronski stated that the proposed sidewalk and lighting provided a good foundation for pedestrian access at that location. Mr. Guarino asked whether traffic calming measures, such as speed bumps, were proposed within the country club property. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not know of any specific traffic calming measures proposed on-site. Mayor McCartney stated that she generally agreed with Mr. Moronski's testimony concerning negative community impacts but had additional questions related to the Heyer Gruel report. Mayor McCartney referred to page 6 of 10 of the report and asked for a clearer explanation of the proposed modular block retaining wall, which would reach nearly 21.5 feet in height. She questioned whether the wall could be tiered. Mr. Moronski stated that the 21.5-foot height occurred in a relatively small portion of the more than 1,300 linear feet of retaining walls proposed. He described the condition as unique because of the 23
File revisions (1)
- Nov 6, 2026
c1f7e551165725,244,207 bytes