Minutes · Sep 2, 2026
September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7Indexed text · page 28
Show all pagesMs. Apte explained that these variances were being considered together because they arose from the topography of the property. She referred to Mr. Cote's colorized steep slope analysis exhibit as providing a visual representation of the existing site conditions. Ms. Apte referred to her earlier question about whether the applicant had selected the best design to reduce disturbance and minimize the variances required because of the topography. Ms. Apte explained that, under the Municipal Land Use Law, the Board must consider the positive criteria for a Cl hardship variance, including whether the property has an exceptional condition such as narrowness, unusual topography, or another physical feature creating the hardship. » Ms; Apte explained that the Board must also consider the negative criteria, including whether the variances could be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without stbstantially impairing the intent and purpose of the zone plan and zoning ordinance. Ms) A\ipte:emphasized the word "substantial" and stated that the Board needed to evaluate ‘whether the applicant!had demonstrated that the proposed site design minimized the ss Necessary variances’ andsassociated impacts while addressing the topographic hardship. Ms: Apte stated that the applicant was seeking the steep slope relief based on those site conditions and the design alternatives considered. Ms. Apte next addressed the parking variance. She stated that the ordinance requires almost/700 parking spacés for the existing use, while the property currently has 256 spaces and the applicant proposes increasing the total to 292 spaces. 1oMs. Apte explained that the additional parking would improve the existing ‘nonconforming condition ‘but would not eliminate the parking variance because the total would remain substantially below the ordinance requirement. Ms: Apte stated'that another requested variance concerned the distance between the >, parking area and the fence: She explained that, according to Mr. Moronski's testimony, this ‘condition was related to the proposed layout and the physical conditions of the property. »uMs:.' Apte also identified:the retaining wall height variance and stated that Mr. Moronski had testified that the wall height was driven by the property's topography and therefore supported by the C1 hardship criteria. Ms. Apte explained that
ll height variance and stated that Mr. Moronski had testified that the wall height was driven by the property's topography and therefore supported by the C1 hardship criteria. Ms. Apte explained that much of the applicant's testimony concerned the hardships created by the property's physical conditions and the need for variances to accommodate the proposed improvements. Ms. Apte stated that the’ parking space variance and the variance involving the distance between the parking area and the fence were being requested under the C2 criteria. Ms. Apte explained that, for a C2 variance, the Board must consider whether the benefits of granting the variance outweigh the detriments. Ms. Apte stated that the applicant had testified that it did not need approximately 700 parking spaces for its operations but did need additional spaces. She explained that the proposed increase would reduce the extent of the existing parking variance without fully meeting the ordinance requirement. Ms. Apte stated that, regarding the distance between the parking area and the fence, the applicant had testified that there would be no negative impact on neighboring properties and that the benefits of the proposed layout would outweigh any detriment resulting from the reduced setback. Ms. Apte concluded that the Board needed to determine whether the applicant had met its burden of proof by demonstrating the hardships supporting the C1 variances and showing that the benefits of the C2 variances outweighed any substantial detriments. 28
File revisions (1)
- Nov 6, 2026
c1f7e551165725,244,207 bytes