Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 30

Show all pages
Page 30

- Mr. Malanga asked specifically how cutting down trees along Eagle Rock Avenue would improve circulation. Mr. Moronski stated that the trees being removed would be replaced in accordance with the Township's tree replacement requirements and that the applicant was complying with those requirements. - Mr. Malanga asked whether it was correct that 313 trees were being removed to provide 36 additional parking spaces for a private country club. Mr. Moronski responded that the trees being removed would be replaced with more than 500 trees, as described in the earlier testimony. He emphasized that the application involved more than additional parking ‘spaces and included improvements providing benefits to the public as well as to the applicant. - | MrMalanga'repeated his question concerning whether 313 trees were being removed to provide 36 additional parking spaces. Mr. Moronski disagreed with that characterization and stated that the trée removal was not solely attributable to the additional parking spaces. + > Mr. Malangalasked how many trees would be removed solely for the additional 36 parking spaces: MrsMoronski stated that the testimony had extensively addressed the total number of trees being rerhoved and replaced as part of the overall project. He stated that he did:notibelieve separating the tree removal by the additional parking spaces was televant.because.the application included more than the parking expansion. ~0-Mr.:Malanga continued»dsking whether Mr. Moronski knew the specific number of trees being removed solely for the parking spaces. Mr. Moronski stated that he had provided ithe informatjon-available to him and referred to the testimony already presented regarding the overall project. ~) Mr. Malanga asked what documentary evidence Mr. Moronski or any member of Langan Engineering ‘had; demonstrated that Essex County was in favor of installing the proposed traffic signal. Mr. Schkolnick objected to the question. Mr. Moronski stated he was not involved in any of the meetings with the County +. Mr. Malanga.asked whether it is Mr. Morinski’s testimony that a private entity was \ bearing the expense of this project. Mr. Moronski stated that he did not say a private entity was bearing the expense of this project. Instead, a private entity is working with the County to help further this project -<Mr. Malanga asked who the private entity is.

Page 30

did not say a private entity was bearing the expense of this project. Instead, a private entity is working with the County to help further this project -<Mr. Malanga asked who the private entity is. Mr. Morinski stated the applicant is working with the County with regards to the improvements to their property - Mr. Malaniga asked whether there are any other entities involved in the expense of this .oyproject.:Mr. Morinski stated he is only involved in this application and does not know whether there are other entities involved in the expense BOARD RECOMMENDATIONS - Chairman Bagoff recommended that a condition be included requiring the applicant to maintain the proposed sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue. He specified that maintenance should include snow removal, repairs, and removal of any greenery or foliage that could obstruct the sidewalk and prevent pedestrians from safely using it. o Ms. McGovern stated that the proposed condition was consistent with case law, referencing Christmas v. City of Newark, which establishes a duty for commercial property owners to maintain their sidewalks. She confirmed that she would include sidewalk maintenance as a condition. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on October 7, 2026, without further notice at 7:30 P.M. 30

File revisions (1)