Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 5

Show all pages
Page 5

in ownership. He suggested that the language be reviewed and tightened to prevent potentially undesirable uses. Mr. Alper also raised concerns regarding the definition of experiential retail, particularly indoor virtual simulations and group activities. He stated that new business concepts could potentially fall within the definition in ways that were not originally anticipated. He suggested considering additional safeguards or case-by-case review of certain uses. Mr. Alper recommended that princess cafes be specifically included as an example of experiential retail, noting that there is demand for this type of establishment in the area. Ms..Apte explained that the redevelopment plan includes comprehensive definitions of the! proposed uses and agreed to review the recommendation to include princess cafes. Mr. Alper questioned whether the redevelopment plan should incorporate the existing ‘'Township ordinance definitions for all permitted uses, rather than relying on definitions that couldichange throughfuture ordinance amendments. He suggested including the current definitions in the redevelopment plan to avoid unintentionally expanding or \changing permitted uses in the future. Ms. Apte explained that uses already defined in the Township's!zoning ordinance would generally rely on those existing definitions. Mr. Alpet reiterated that incorporating the current definitions directly into the redevelopment plan could provide greater certainty and protect against unintended future changes. ¢y »Chairman Bagoff-suggested that identifying specifically prohibited uses might be » more practical than attempting to define every acceptable use. Chairman Bagoff also discussed recreational uses such as indoor pickleball, indoor golf, and video arcades. Mr: .Alper-noted that the redevelopment plan's arcade provisions appeared to permit certain atcade ‘Activities. only when associated with a restaurant, potentially allowing an -establishment similar!to Dave & Buster's while restricting standalone traditional arcades. Mr: Alper asked whether the definition of medical offices would include urgent care ou facilities. Ms\iApte explained that the proposed definition includes facilities providing i diagnostic, therapeutic; ‘preventive, medical, dental, psychological, and related outpatient tredtment,She clarified that'such facilities would serve ambulatory patients and would not

Page 5

ies providing i diagnostic, therapeutic; ‘preventive, medical, dental, psychological, and related outpatient tredtment,She clarified that'such facilities would serve ambulatory patients and would not permit inpatient care or major surgical procedures. Based on that definition, urgent care facilities could potentially qualify as a permitted medical office use. o Mr. Alper suggested that the Board consider excluding urgent care facilities from the rédevelopment plan. He explained that the purpose of introducing new commercial uses was to encourage visitors to patronize restaurants, retail 1 establishments, and other businesses. He expressed concern that individuals visiting urgent care facilities due to illness or injury would be less likely to visit surrounding businesses. Mr. Alper also questioned whether incorporating the Township's existing outdoor cafe licensing requirements would prohibit outdoor music or restrict establishments from opening windows or doors while indoor music was playing. He expressed concern that these restrictions could discourage the types of restaurant and entertainment uses the redevelopment plan was intended to attract. o Chairman Bagoff stated that an applicant seeking to provide outdoor music might need to request a variance. Mr. Alper emphasized that the Township should encourage desirable outdoor cafe and entertainment uses rather than impose unnecessary restrictions. Mayor McCartney asked whether massage establishments could be prohibited under the redevelopment plan if they were permitted elsewhere in the Township. Ms. McGovern explained that the redevelopment plan could establish site-specific permitted and prohibited uses, regardless of the uses allowed in other zoning districts.

File revisions (1)