Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Sep 2, 2026

September 2, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256c1f7e5511657d93034ad90221a54ba2efb11fc0bf13267113440e8e4f5b73af7

Indexed text · page 7

Show all pages
Page 7

PRESENTATION Mr. Richard Schkolnick, Esq., appearing on behalf of the applicant, explained that the application is for site plan approval with several C variances. He stated that the property is located in the R2 zone, the existing use is permitted, and no new buildings are proposed. The application includes 32/new parking spaces and a new exit for Crestmont Country Club thatiwoulé-align with Oval Road, creating a four-way intersection along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Schkolnick stated that the proposed improvements include widening Eagle Rock Aveniie, new grading, stormwater management, significant landscaping improvements, and a traffic signal intended to create a safer intersection. +He also confirmed that the applicant had agreed during the previous hearing to install a sidewwalkalong: Eagle Rock Avenue and had no objections to the review letters prepared by the Board's professionals. . MreSchkolnick provided arecap of the previous hearings, beginning with June 3, 2026. -ondHé stated that Ms. Dana Cancellaro, General Manager and Chief Operating Officer. of Crestmont Country Club, testified regarding the need for additional parking foriclub members and the challenges associated with the existing driveway, including its slope and difficult left-hand turns. © Sheralso:discussed the.club's desire for safety improvements and the potential for eminent ddmaimyexplaining that the proposal represented a reasonable, practical, uc ivand/cooperative approach to addressing complex issues involving the Township and potential condemnation of the club's property. ©. ‘Mr: Schkolnick stated that the Board previously heard testimony from Mr. John | Cote, P.E.) the applicant's civil engineer, who presented an aerial photograph and discussed the site improvements © Mr. Carl Penke; the applicant's traffic expert, who addressed the geometry of the proposed four-way intersection, difficult turning movements, private investment in the traffic signal, widening of Eagle Rock Avenue, left-hand turns, crosswalks, ramps, sidewalks, and existing grading challenges. Mr. Penke also discussed previous efforts involving the County Planning Board to improve this section of Eagle Rock Avenue. 0 ‘Mr. Schkolnick explained that the July 1, 2026 hearing included extensive cross- ‘oly 20 examination of Mr: Penke, followed by approximately 20 minutes of testimony from Mr. Cote

Page 7

le Rock Avenue. 0 ‘Mr. Schkolnick explained that the July 1, 2026 hearing included extensive cross- ‘oly 20 examination of Mr: Penke, followed by approximately 20 minutes of testimony from Mr. Cote regarding the civil engineering plans. o He stated that the current hearing would continue with cross-examination of Mr. Cote, followed by testimony from the applicant's planner as the final witness. BOARD QUESTIONS Ms. Kapferer referred to the April 24, 2026 Artheon review letter, which included comments concerning the geotechnical report and the depth to seasonal high groundwater. She asked whether additional testing had been performed, noting a potential conflict between the seasonal high groundwater elevation and the bottom of the proposed stormwater basin. Mr. Cote explained that testing had been performed at or near both proposed basins to evaluate seasonal high groundwater conditions. He also stated that the site contained Class D soils, which do not permit adequate infiltration.

File revisions (1)