Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Oct 29, 2026

October 29, 2026, Special Meeting

Preserved file SHA-2563293549f5fcd4faec1ecfcfd64910c0ac796096af407369474af1bd92b0be1a5

Indexed text · page 5

Show all pages
Page 5

changed. So, like any other mid-block site on a divided roadway, vehicles will find their path to where they're going. Ms. Voort asked if in the Traffic Study was there any reference to the Guarino intersection. But yet there was reference to Rooney Circle. Mr. Taylor said that they counted traffic at Rooney Circle, to get a baseline as well as the site driveways. Because in his opinion it was the closest, signal to where the site is proposed. But the rationale behind looking at it goes back to the DOT's definition of a significant impact, and when the DOT sets forth this criteria of a significant impact for when adjacent intersections should be studied to determine if the site-generated traffic potentially has an impact. And that threshold is 100 new peak hour trips. So what they have determined is if it's less than 100 new peak hour trips, the intersection is not significantly impacted and is really not necessary to be studied. In the condition that for Guarino Drive, there are approximately, a maximum of 23 vehicles during any one of the peak hours through that intersection, which is a quarter of what's been established as a significant impact. So, the introduction of a car every few minutes is not going to have any significant impact on the adjacent intersection. Ms. Voort asked for clarification and confirmation that Rooney Circle is actually the entire road that runs around the shopping center. Mr. Taylor said yes. That it is the southern terminus of Rooney Circle, where it intersects Prospect, which is just opposite the catering facility. Kevin Malanga (Ridge Road) asked how many sites Mr. Taylor has provided analysis and testimony for Mavis. Mr. Taylor answered saying half a dozen over the last ten (10) years. Mr. Malanga followed up by asking for confirmation that he has distinguished between retail tire stores and automobile repair shops and the reason behind his distinction. Mr. Taylor said that typically it’s the level of automotive operations that are done at the facility in order to classify it into the correct ITE land use code. Mr. Malanga asked if it is advantageous to classify a use as a retail tire store versus an automobile repair shop? Mr. Taylor said that he has never compared them side by side and it is not an analysis that he does. Mr. Malanga asked if he is familiar with the types of work that is performed at a Mavis store. Mr.

Page 5

Mr. Taylor said that he has never compared them side by side and it is not an analysis that he does. Mr. Malanga asked if he is familiar with the types of work that is performed at a Mavis store. Mr. Taylor said yes. Mr. Malanga followed up by asking if Mr. Taylor has ever looked at the Mavis website. Mr. Taylor said yes, but not recently. Mr. Malanga followed up by asking about specific work performed (oil changes, car battery changes, brake services, and mufflers with exhaust repairs) Mr. Taylor said that he isn’t sure if he can go down this line of questioning. Mr. Malanga asked about the number of spaces being deficient by three (3) spaces. Mr. Taylor said its two (2) because an Electric Vehicle space the requirement is actually reduced by one (1) per the state statute so technically 24 spaces are required and only 22 are provided. Mr. Malanga asked for confirmation of the calculation of what 1.66 spaces per employee is based on. Mr. Taylor said that it is based on ITE parking generation 6" edition with seven (7) employees at this site. Mr. Taylor said yes that seven (7) employees would be the maximum. Barry Kirschenbaum (269 DeRose Court) asked for what general maintenance is. Mr. Taylor said that general automotive maintenance typically means light, repairs, oil changes, brake changes, and that sort of nature. Mr. Kirschenbaum asked in reference to the Traffic Study was that it was during best weather conditions and what happens during poor weather conditions. Mr. Taylor said during poor conditions, there is a reduction in the traffic along the roadways. The reason behind doing counts during best weather conditions is to show people with their normal traffic patterns. David Dockery (Legal Counsel for Eagle Ridge Community) asked about the proposed driveways will provide safe and efficient access to the roadway system. Mr. Taylor said yes. Mr. Dockery asked for confirmation that no crash history study was done. Mr. Taylor

File revisions (1)