Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 19, 2026

Planning Report 82726 66 Franklin Avenue West Orange NJrcd 9 2 26

Preserved file SHA-25603924b50710fcd57fa9e681f03814c15f15be5e316873230e91d756c6aa235bb

Indexed text · page 3

Show all pages
Page 3

John McDonough Associates • Land Use Planning • Landscape Architecture Page 2 of 8 be collected in a southeast inlet and conveyed through proposed 6-inch and 8-inch PVC pipes to an existing storm manhole in Franklin Avenue. Zoning Considerations The site is part of a B-1 cluster along Franklin Avenue. The zone boundary includes the lots adjacent to the site and behind the site. The zone boundary also extends across Franklin Avenue. The B-1 zone permits commercial use pursuant to §25-7.1. The parking of commercial vehicles as an accessory use is not expressly permitted in the B-1 zone, and as such the application seeks ‘D-1’ use relief. The application also requires the following ‘C’ bulk variance relief: • Maximum Window Sign Area. Window signs are permitted to occupy up to 25% of the total window area, whereas the application proposes 100%. • Minimum Distance Between Curbing and Fencing. Curbing is required to be at least five feet from fencing, whereas the application proposes curbing bordering the wood fence along the southern edge of the property. • Minimum Number of Loading Spaces. One loading space is required, whereas the application does not propose a loading space. Planning Justifications for Relief – ‘D-1’ Use Variance Land use planning operates within a legal framework. The land use law recognizes that zoning is not meant to be rigid and inflexible and gives land use boards authority to grant relief subject to defined statutory criteria. The statutory criteria for grant of use relief are established under N.J.S.A. 40:55D-70(d)(1) and Medici v. BPR Co., 107 N.J. 1 (1987). Under the enhanced standard articulated in Medici, the applicant must demonstrate “special reasons” justifying the use variance (positive criteria) and that the variance can be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantial impairment of the intent and purpose of the zone plan and zoning ordinance (negative criteria). The Court in Burbridge v. Mine Hill Township, 117 N.J. 376 (1990), confirmed that the special reasons supporting a use variance encompass all of the purposes of zoning enumerated in N.J.S.A. 40:55D-2, not merely the promotion of the general welfare. The subject application sustains the required elements of proof for the reasons set forth below. Site Suitability Given the practical realities of this specific property and its environs,

Page 3

ral welfare. The subject application sustains the required elements of proof for the reasons set forth below. Site Suitability Given the practical realities of this specific property and its environs, the subject property is particularly suited for the proposed landscaping contractor office, storage, and limited commercial- vehicle parking use. The proposed use is compatible with the surrounding context given that the property is located on a commercial corridor and immediately adjoins an existing auto-body shop to the north, which similarly involves vehicle storage and service activity. The property fronts

File revisions (1)