Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 19, 2026

Planning Report 82726 66 Franklin Avenue West Orange NJrcd 9 2 26

Preserved file SHA-25603924b50710fcd57fa9e681f03814c15f15be5e316873230e91d756c6aa235bb

Indexed text · page 4

Show all pages
Page 4

John McDonough Associates • Land Use Planning • Landscape Architecture Page 3 of 8 Franklin Avenue in an area characterized by a mix of commercial and residential uses within the B-1 Retail Business Zone. Historically, the subject property has been used in this manner for several years, so the application does not introduce anything new to the streetscape or the neighborhood. Rather, the application replaces ad hoc, informal contractor storage with a formal, controlled site plan that includes defined parking areas, screening, landscaping, shielded lighting, stormwater management, and operational controls. Further, while the B-1 Zone permits parking areas for customer use, the principal use on the site does not typically necessitate customer parking. Rather, the nature of the business requires areas for storage of commercial vehicles. Accordingly, utilizing the otherwise permitted parking area for commercial vehicle storage is consistent with the functional needs of this particular permitted use in the zone. The proposed lot-coverage reduction from 85.2% (existing) to 83.4% demonstrates that the site plan actively improves the pre-existing condition rather than merely perpetuating noncompliance. Positive Criteria The statutory positive criteria are satisfied because the project will be a significant improvement over the existing condition. The project will clean up the existing development, resulting in a more aesthetic and organized condition. The project promotes the general welfare with a formalized site plan that replaces uncontrolled contractor storage with organized parking, screening, landscaping, and lighting. The disclosed fleet comprises five Ford F-550 trucks (approximately 15 feet long, 7 feet wide, GVW 19,500 lbs) and four enclosed landscaping trailers (7’x18’)—vehicles whose size and scale are generally comparable to large pickup trucks and not inconsistent with the character of a commercial corridor adjacent to an existing auto-body operation. Truck departures at approximately 7:30 a.m. and returns between 5:00 and 6:00 p.m. confine commercial activity to normal business hours. The project also promotes the planning goals for efficient land use and for a variety of land uses in appropriate locations. For the reasons set forth above, the proposal promotes fundamental purposes of zoning under N.J.S.A. 40:55D-2, especially purposes “a”, “g”, “h”,

Page 4

d for a variety of land uses in appropriate locations. For the reasons set forth above, the proposal promotes fundamental purposes of zoning under N.J.S.A. 40:55D-2, especially purposes “a”, “g”, “h”, “i”, and “m”. Specifically: purpose (a) (encouragement of appropriate land uses); purpose (g) (sufficient space for a variety of uses); purpose (h) (promotion of a desirable visual environment); purpose (i) (sound planning for orderly growth); and purpose (m) (efficient use of land). See Burbridge v. Mine Hill Twp., 117 N.J. 376 (1990) (all enumerated purposes of zoning constitute special reasons supporting a use variance). Negative Criteria The statutory negative criteria are satisfied because the relief can be granted without substantial detriment to the public. The following enforceable conditions of approval mitigate potential impacts: (1) operations confined to weekday daytime hours with no overnight commercial activity; (2) shielded, downward-directed lighting with a 10:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m. dimming schedule per §25-14.1; (3) continuous perimeter fencing and enhanced landscaping to maximize screening; (4) truck-movement controls limiting departures to approximately 7:30 a.m. and returns to 5:00–6:00 p.m., prohibiting on-street staging; (5) lot consolidation of the three parcels; and (6) stormwater

File revisions (1)