Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 19, 2026

Planning Report 82726 66 Franklin Avenue West Orange NJrcd 9 2 26

Preserved file SHA-25603924b50710fcd57fa9e681f03814c15f15be5e316873230e91d756c6aa235bb

Indexed text · page 5

Show all pages
Page 5

John McDonough Associates • Land Use Planning • Landscape Architecture Page 4 of 8 management via the proposed southeast inlet and pipe system. The use is clearly associated with a commercial operation within the B-1 zone’s commercial corridor, and the site’s adjacency to an auto-body shop further demonstrates compatibility. The statutory negative criteria are further satisfied because relief can be granted without substantial impairment to the zone plan. The project advances the Master Plan objective for economic development and a stable ratable base. The B-1 district’s commercial-corridor purpose is advanced by formalizing a limited office/storage operation on an already-developed parcel, reducing lot coverage, improving circulation and screening, and eliminating the existing uncontrolled contractor-storage condition. The Board can preserve the ordinance’s objectives through conditions addressing hours, lighting, buffering, parking, stormwater, and lot consolidation. Planning Justifications for Relief – ‘C-2’ Bulk Variances The ‘C’ variances can be granted under N.J.S.A. 40:55D-70(c)(2), whereby the benefits of the application as a whole substantially outweigh any detriments. The positive criteria associated with the use variance carry forth to the ‘C’ variances since they are necessary to effectuate this overall beneficial project. In terms of the negative criteria relative to the ‘C’ variances, none of the relief being sought will result in a substantially detrimental impact to the public or the zone. Each deviation is addressed individually below: Lot Coverage (83.4% proposed; 75% permitted): The proposed lot coverage represents a reduction from the existing 85.2% condition. The improvement, combined with formalized stormwater management and landscaping, advances the ordinance’s purpose. Mitigation: stormwater collection via the proposed southeast inlet and pipe system. Side-Yard Setback (2.6 ft existing; 6 ft required): Pre-existing non-conformity documented by survey; no expansion proposed in side-yard area. Rear-Yard Setback (5.2 ft existing; 30 ft required): Pre-existing non-conformity; existing building footprint preserved without expansion. Enhanced screening along rear property line mitigates impacts. Window Sign Area (100% proposed; 25% permitted): The proposed window coverage serves a security/privacy function. Limited building frontage

Page 5

hanced screening along rear property line mitigates impacts. Window Sign Area (100% proposed; 25% permitted): The proposed window coverage serves a security/privacy function. Limited building frontage minimizes streetscape impact. Curbing Distance from Fencing (0 ft; 5 ft required per §25-12.1B): Site-specific alternative necessitated by the lot’s physical constraints. Curbing defines the parking area and provides positive drainage control. The lot is used primarily by the business itself. Loading Spaces (0 provided; 1 required): The oversized truck stalls (9’x30’ and 10’x30’) function as a combined parking/loading arrangement. Loading occurs within designated stalls

File revisions (1)