Supporting Documentation · Nov 19, 2026
Planning Report 82726 66 Franklin Avenue West Orange NJrcd 9 2 26
03924b50710fcd57fa9e681f03814c15f15be5e316873230e91d756c6aa235bbIndexed text · page 6
Show all pagesJohn McDonough Associates • Land Use Planning • Landscape Architecture Page 5 of 8 during business hours. Truck-turn exhibits confirm on-site maneuvering without backing into Franklin Avenue. Driveway Width (20 ft; 24 ft required): Pre-existing condition. Truck-turn exhibits demonstrate safe ingress/egress. Buffer Strip (approx. 5.1 ft; 20 ft required per §25-11.3b): Physical constraints prevent full compliance. Applicant proposes to maximize screening through continuous planting, solid fencing, and maintained landscaping, supplemented by the lighting dimming schedule and restricted hours. Prior Application History Application ZB-21-01 was denied by the Board (resolution memorialized April 20, 2023). That application sought preliminary and final site plan approval with a D-1 use variance and bulk variances to expand the existing building, add a residential use on a second floor, and use a portion of the lot for commercial vehicle parking. The present application is materially distinguished from ZB-21-01: (1) no residential component is proposed; (2) no building expansion is proposed; (3) the scope is narrowed to a landscaping contractor office/storage operation with limited commercial-vehicle parking; and (4) the site plan incorporates compliance improvements including formalized parking, reduced lot coverage, enhanced screening, lighting controls, and stormwater management. These changed circumstances and the materially different proposal overcome any potential preclusion under the changed-circumstances doctrine. Conclusion The application represents a substantial investment to improve property in West Orange. The overall site upgrade will enhance the image and identity of the site, the area, and the town. The formalization of the existing contractor-storage condition into a controlled landscaping office/storage operation with limited commercial-vehicle parking, subject to enforceable conditions, will protect the public welfare and advance the purposes of the B-1 zone. The application is consistent with good planning practices for orderly community growth and development. The statutory criteria for grant of all the relief sought are met, and approval is warranted. Approval should be conditioned upon, among other appropriate terms: lot consolidation of the three parcels; the lighting dimming schedule (10:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m.); elimination of light spillage
nted. Approval should be conditioned upon, among other appropriate terms: lot consolidation of the three parcels; the lighting dimming schedule (10:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m.); elimination of light spillage onto Franklin Avenue per §25-14.1; hours-of-operation restrictions; prohibition of overnight commercial activity and on-street staging; maintenance of the screening/landscaping buffer; and any further conditions the Board deems necessary.
File revisions (1)
- Oct 31, 2026
03924b50710f983,586 bytes