Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

7 1 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-2562e4c7c42a270498c0c3576e47d85bc4d985dc27f3a8f765c33c1de4f25d6b446

Indexed text · page 21

Show all pages
Page 21

21 - Ms. Sharret clarified that she was asking whether areas near Edgemont, Beachwood, or Sherwood, including areas with trees, would be cleared to make room for the traffic light. Mr. Pehnke stated that they would not. - Ms. Sharret asked whether the project therefore consisted only of physically installing the traffic light, with nothing else being done to the surrounding area. Mr. Pehnke clarified that there would be widening into the Crestmont Country Club frontage to provide the turn lanes and the required geometry of the intersection. He stated that this impacts the Crestmont Country Club property only. - Ms. Sharret asked whether trees would be removed as part of that work. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that trees would be felled and stated that this was part of the application. - Ms. Sharret asked how many trees would be felled. Mr. Pehnke deferred to his partner, who was handling the site plan application and would be testifying next. PUBLIC COMMENTS - Lawrence Cohen, at 20 Lincoln Ave., asked Chairman Bagoff to consider rescinding the condition requiring a sidewalk going toward Laurel Avenue. ○ Mr. Cohen stated that he is a hiker and knows the area by walking on foot. ○ He said he rarely sees anyone walking in that area and noted that Crestmont Country Club workers would make a right turn and travel east on Eagle Rock toward the bus stop at Pleasant Valley Way and Eagle Rock. ○ He argued that the other direction where the sidewalk was requested is a rural or suburban area that goes toward the highway, and that “nobody’s walking there.” ○ Mr. Cohen characterized the sidewalk as potentially “urbanizing” a suburban area that does not need one and called it a waste. ○ He then discussed the concern about traffic lights and suggested that if the light at Laurel and the proposed light at Oval were synchronized, the signals should not interfere with traffic flow. ○ Mr. Cohen stated that he appreciated the opportunity for people to cross the road with a light. ○ Based on his experience walking across Eagle Rock from the south side to the north side, he described the crossing as “a difficult crossing.” ○ He stated that pedestrian crossings would be beneficial for Crestmont Country Club workers and anyone else who would need to cross the road. - Mr. Sly stated that Pleasantdale Chateau has operated for approximately 30 years without complaints or issues involving

Page 21

estmont Country Club workers and anyone else who would need to cross the road. - Mr. Sly stated that Pleasantdale Chateau has operated for approximately 30 years without complaints or issues involving people exiting via Oval Road. ○ He explained that most of Pleasantdale Chateau’s business is as an event facility and that the bulk of its business occurs at 5 p.m. or after, when traffic volume is high. ○ He reiterated concerns about the volume of traffic on Eagle Rock Avenue. ○ Mr. Sly expressed concern that because the driveway is within approximately 100 feet of the stop bar, it would not take many cars to cause traffic to back up into the driveway. ○ He stated that this could potentially inconvenience Pleasantdale Chateau’s guests and create additional difficulty in accommodating guests, including with valet operations. PRESENTATION

File revisions (1)