Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026
8 12 26 WO PB Draft Minutes
89b5155dfd6e8da1e2d6b434b7e2576700ca3fd8942c85eafcf06f348f3f3105Indexed text
7 ○ Mr. Guarino stated that he would like to see the parking moved to the rear because it would provide a nicer curb appearance and avoid seeing cars in front of the building. ○ Ms. McGovern asked whether Mr. Guarino was referring to all three spaces. Mr. Guarino confirmed that he was. - Ms. McGovern identified the other lot as Lot 58.02 and asked whether the four parking spaces proposed on that lot could all fit in the rear. Mr. Flynn stated that, without being an engineer, he did not want to say anything definitively, but it appeared that they could. He added that if four spaces did not work, only three spaces were required on that property. ○ Mr. Flynn stated that, if the Board wanted the parking moved to the rear as a condition of approval, the applicant could provide four spaces if they fit, and three spaces if four did not fit. ○ Mr. Trembulak stated, on behalf of the applicant, that the applicant could stipulate that the Board requirement eliminates the front-yard parking and placing the parking in the rear. He noted that only three parking spaces are required on Lot 58.02, so the additional fourth space could be eliminated if necessary. He also noted that the driveways on both properties could provide additional off-street parking. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether any of the other homes on Whittlesey Avenue have one parking space facing Whittlesey Avenue in the front. Mr. Flynn referred to his exhibit and stated that the proposed arrangement is somewhat different from what is seen in the neighborhood. He noted that, across the street, there are wider driveways where cars can park side by side, and that many properties have similar arrangements. He also pointed out that some properties have tandem parking. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether having one parking space in front while preserving green space in the backyard would be inconsistent with the neighborhood. Mr. Flynn stated having one or two spaces in front would not stand out. ○ Chairman Bagoff suggested that moving one parking space to the rear would result in one parking space in front of each of the units and would be more consistent with the neighborhood. He also suggested that trees, bushes, or other greenery could be provided in the front and rear. - Mayor McCartney asked whether tandem parking, front and back, could be placed in the rear to save some backyard space. Mr. Flynn stated that it
ther greenery could be provided in the front and rear. - Mayor McCartney asked whether tandem parking, front and back, could be placed in the rear to save some backyard space. Mr. Flynn stated that it appeared possible if that was the Board's preference and, provided the applicant agreed, could be done. - Mayor McCartney asked for more details concerning the proposed addition to the existing home, including the amount of livable space. Mayor McCartney noted that there is currently a two-story frame structure and asked whether it is a two-family home. Mr. Flynn initially confirmed that it was. ○ Mr. Trembulak corrected the testimony, stating that the existing house is a one- family dwelling and that the proposal is to convert it to a two-family dwelling. ○ Mayor McCartney stated that her remaining consideration was the parking in the rear, which she believed would be more compatible with the neighborhood, including tandem parking if it would work. - Mr. Alper asked whether, if the parking were moved to the rear, particularly on the lot on the right side of the map, the new structure could be moved closer to the street to use some of the 30-foot setback and provide more backyard area for the parking, while creating a cleaner front and potentially matching the approximately 16-foot setback on the left-hand lot. Mr. Flynn stated that he believed this would be possible. He noted that
8 the required front setback is 30 feet and that moving the building forward would technically require a variance. - Mr. Klein asked whether, if the building on Lot 58.01 were moved forward to approximately 16 feet from the street or right-of-way line and three parking spaces were placed in the rear, a turning template would be provided to ensure that vehicles could enter, make a K-turn, and exit facing forward. Mr. Trembulak stated that the applicant would agree to such a requirement and that it was reasonable. He noted that Mr. Flynn was not the person to provide the turning template. BOARD COMMENTS - Mr. Klein stated that, concerning Lot 58.02, in his professional opinion, none of the proposed parking spaces were maneuverable. He stated that there are only 10 feet behind a parking space and questioned how vehicles would make the necessary K-turns or loops to enter and exit. He stated that at least 22 feet is needed behind the spaces to make the swing. - Mr. Klein stated that all of the parking spaces should be placed in the rear and that turning templates should be prepared before determining the size of the proposed addition. - Mr. Flynn asked whether moving the rear parking spaces toward the right or north would provide enough room for the necessary vehicle movements. Mr. Klein stated that it probably would. - Mr. Klein also stated that an 8-foot driveway is somewhat narrow. He noted that there is approximately 10 feet between the edge of the addition and what he understood to be a fence between the neighbors, and suggested shrinking the addition somewhat to make the driveway wider. - Mr. Klein stated that, with mirrors and other considerations, the driveway should be approximately 10 feet wide, but that the turning templates would determine what is necessary. - Mr. Trembulak agreed that, based upon the turning templates, the size of the proposed addition might need to be reduced to provide adequate space for a wider driveway and the relocated parking. - Mr. Klein stated that he had no problem with three spaces facing north or east, depending on how vehicles need to maneuver. He stated that he definitely believed the two-family dwelling on Lot 58.01 should be pushed forward. - Mr. Klein concluded that the applicant should run turning templates, determine how to place the parking in the rear, move the building forward, and shrink the addition
8.01 should be pushed forward. - Mr. Klein concluded that the applicant should run turning templates, determine how to place the parking in the rear, move the building forward, and shrink the addition if necessary. PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS - Mr. Davis agreed that parking in the rear was a better planning alternative and that moving the building forward was also preferable. He stated that his concerns had been about maneuverability of the parking spaces and that he believed the turning templates would address those concerns. PROFESSIONAL QUESTIONS - Mr. Valesi asked whether the subdivision would be filed by plat or by deed. Mr. Trembulak stated that it would be filed by deed.
9 PUBLIC QUESTIONS - Kevin Malanga asked whether the applicant is presently the occupant of the house in question. Mr. Trembulak stated that his client lives there when he is in town and also spends time in Virginia, to the best of his understanding. He stated that when Mr. Perez is in New Jersey, he stays at the house. - Mr. Malanga asked whether the property is not currently Mr. Perez's primary residence. Mr. Trembulak stated that his understanding is that it is not currently his primary residence, but that Mr. Perez plans to relocate back to New Jersey, at which point the property would become his primary residence. - Mr. Malanga asked Mr. Flynn what planning goals sought to be advanced when the Township established the lot widths applicable to the street. Mr. Flynn stated that the reason behind dimensional variances is usually to ensure consistency among properties, so that one property is not excessively narrow or small compared with the rest. Mr. Flynn stated that, when considering the intent behind the requirement, including neighborhood consistency, adequate light, air, open space, and building separation, he believed all of those intents are met by the proposal. - Mr. Malanga asked whether those purposes were met by the establishment of the current lot width requirement. Mr. Flynn stated that he believed they were being met by the proposal. - Mr. Malanga clarified that he was asking what the Township sought to accomplish when it established the current lot widths. Mr. Flynn stated that one of the intents behind those requirements is consistency between properties so that something does not stand out in the context of the area, as well as concerns about building separation and density. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Flynn was seeking to subvert the intention of the zoning by establishing the lot width that the applicant is seeking to overcome. Mr. Flynn stated that, given the neighborhood, the consistency of the proposed lot width makes it appropriate for this particular property. - Mr. Malanga asked whether Mr. Flynn had calculated how many lots meet the current zoning-required width versus the number that do not. Mr. Trembulak asked what area Mr. Malanga was referring to. Mr. Malanga stated that he was referring to the neighborhood identified by Mr. Flynn. Mr. Flynn returned to his planning exhibit and stated that, when considering neighborhood
alanga was referring to. Mr. Malanga stated that he was referring to the neighborhood identified by Mr. Flynn. Mr. Flynn returned to his planning exhibit and stated that, when considering neighborhood compatibility, he starts with the block itself because those are the most immediately surrounding properties. He stated that he sometimes looks farther out, but in this case believed the point was clear by focusing on the particular block. ○ Mr. Flynn stated that, on the block, there are several properties developed with two-family dwellings that have 50-foot lot widths or smaller, as well as three- family properties on similarly sized lots. - Mr. Malanga stated that Mr. Flynn had not provided the Board with a numerical calculation comparing those properties to the total number of lots on the block. - Mr. Flynn asked whether Mr. Malanga was referring to the total number of lots in the town. Mr. Malanga clarified that he was referring to the one block because Mr. Flynn based his opinion on that block and asked what percentage complies and what percentage does not comply. Mr. Trembulak objected to the question and stated that the calculation could be made by counting the lots. ○ Mr. Flynn stated that he disagreed that such a calculation was necessarily required to determine whether something is consistent. He stated that when walking down a street, a person is not doing math in their head but is considering what is apparent. He stated that this was the intention behind the way he prepared his analysis.
10 APPLICANT CONCLUSION - Mr. Trembulak stated that, as Mr. Flynn had shown through his exhibit and testimony, the proposal is not out of character with the neighborhood. He stated that the neighborhood is fairly dense, with many smaller lot sizes and a multitude of existing non- compliant two-family dwellings. - Mr. Trembulak stated that he counted approximately 24 two-family dwellings, including houses on the opposite side of Whittlesey Avenue, as shown on Mr. Flynn's exhibit. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the proposal is not inconsistent, but very much consistent with the neighborhood. He noted that the zoning permits 50-foot lots and two-family dwellings and stated that the proposal blends well with the existing conditions on the block. - Mr. Trembulak stated that Mr. Flynn provided planning testimony supporting the requested C2 variances. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the applicant is willing to address all of the Board's concerns and agreed with the Board's comments about relocating the parking to the rear of the buildings. He stated that the applicant would provide turning templates to show that the parking spaces can be accessed if necessary. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the driveway on one lot would be widened and that, if necessary, the size of the addition could be reduced to accommodate a widened driveway and relocated parking. - Mr. Trembulak reiterated that the applicant agrees to comply with all requirements identified in the Board Planner's memorandum. - Mr. Trembulak specifically stated that the applicant would comply with all building design requirements concerning exterior design and appearance so that the houses do not look the same. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the applicant would comply with building height requirements and the minimum square footage requirement of 1,100 square feet for each unit. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the applicant would comply with tree removal and tree replacement ordinance requirements and all other building code requirements, including separate entrances. - Mr. Trembulak stated that everything identified by the Planner would be acceptable as conditions of approval. - Mr. Trembulak respectfully requested that the Board approve the application with the variances and subject to the changes and conditions outlined. GENERAL DISCUSSION - Mr. Klein stated that the Board was voting on a subdivision while also relying on
rd approve the application with the variances and subject to the changes and conditions outlined. GENERAL DISCUSSION - Mr. Klein stated that the Board was voting on a subdivision while also relying on an image of changes that had not yet been shown in a final plan, including moving the building forward, fitting three parking spaces in the rear in some orientation, widening the driveway, and potentially shrinking the addition. He asked whether the Board should proceed based on those anticipated changes or require a hard copy or image before voting. Mr. Klein asked whether the Board would leave it to its experts to work out those changes separately. Chairman Bagoff stated that the property would have to be subdivided if the Board determined that the subdivision made sense. He noted that the applicant would then have to go to the Building Department because there was not an exact plan for either side and there were no turning templates to confirm that the proposed arrangement would work.
11 - Mr. Klein asked whether the Building Department would require turning templates if the applicant submitted a site plan. Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board had asked that turning templates be supplied to the Building Department and that this would be a condition of the application. ○ Mr. Trembulak confirmed that the applicant agreed to the condition. - Ms. McGovern stated that, based on Mr. Klein's comment, she understood that turning templates were needed for both houses, but that the primary concern was the existing house and addition, where an adjustment could be made to the addition on the new house if necessary to accomplish the turning template. She asked about the status of the other house. - Mr. Klein clarified that his concern was that the image shown on the right side of the latest plan would not look anything like the final plan presented to the Building Department. The parking would not be in the front, the building would be shifted forward, and the parking would be arranged in the rear. - Mr. Klein further stated that, for the other property, there would not be parking in the front, the addition would be a different shape or size, the parking would be in the rear, and the driveway would be at least approximately 10 feet wide. - Mr. Klein stated that he wanted to ensure that the Board was comfortable with its Building Department or Board professionals reviewing the revised plan before it went to the Building Department. - Chairman Bagoff stated that one of the problems is that the variances requested based on the current presentation are not necessarily the variances that will be required once all of the proposed changes are made. - Chairman Bagoff stated that he believed the best approach would be to subdivide the land and have the applicant return with the appropriate plan, including a turning template, so the Board can determine what variances are actually needed. - Ms. McGovern stated that the Board's proposal would require the applicant to re-notice and return with a Planner on the variances, even though the applicant had already provided the Planner's expert testimony. - Ms. McGovern stated that, if the Board wants to see the turning template, position of the house, size of the addition, size of the driveway, and placement of the parking spaces, those matters had already been covered through the Planner's expert testimony. - Ms.
g template, position of the house, size of the addition, size of the driveway, and placement of the parking spaces, those matters had already been covered through the Planner's expert testimony. - Ms. McGovern suggested that it would be more efficient for the applicant to submit the revised information and have the Board vote on it at the next meeting rather than require the applicant to go through the entire noticing process again, including newspaper publication and another application. - Ms. McGovern stated that requiring another application would also result in additional expense for the applicant. - Mr. Klein stated that he had thought the applicant could simply carry the matter until September and provide the requested information. He noted that he believed he had asked for turning templates at the prior hearing but apparently had not. - Mr. Klein stated that the building shown on the current plan might not be the size of the building the applicant ultimately wants and that the proposed addition might not be the final size or shape. He stated that the applicant would therefore need to come back with a real drawing. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board cannot grant variances for something that may not be the final proposal, particularly where additional variances may be required. He stated that this could otherwise require the applicant to return for another application.
File revisions (1)
- Oct 7, 2026
89b5155dfd6e370,634 bytes