Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026
8 12 26 WO PB Draft Minutes
89b5155dfd6e8da1e2d6b434b7e2576700ca3fd8942c85eafcf06f348f3f3105Indexed text
12 - Chairman Bagoff stated that, if the applicant agrees, he would support the approach suggested by Ms. McGovern: return with the appropriate turning templates and the appropriate position of the new house. - Mr. Klein asked whether the variance for the front yard setback was noticed. Ms. McGovern stated that she believed it was included in the catch-all notice and indicated that she would review the notice again. - Mr. Trembulak stated that if the Board wanted the new house moved forward, which he believed everyone agreed was a good plan, that would require an additional variance. He stated that, because of the catch-all notice, he was not concerned about a notice issue. - Mr. Klein recalled Ms. Apti discussing that the new building had to look substantially different from the existing building, including differences in color and design, and asked who would verify compliance. Ms. McGovern stated that the zoning official would verify this and that the applicant had already testified that it would comply with the design condition. - Chairman Bagoff stated that, if the application were approved, the Board's experts, the building department, and the zoning official would review the plans and the proposed addition based upon the Board's direction. - Chairman Bagoff noted that the existing house had a pre-existing non-conforming condition and that, if the turning templates did not work, the applicant would have to address the issue. Mr. Klein expressed concern that the applicant could otherwise have a subdivided lot that could not be built on because parking could not be provided in the rear. - Mr. Trembulak stated that they could make the turning templates work and would do what was necessary, including shrinking the addition or the proposed new house. He agreed to provide turning templates. - Mr. Trembulak asked for direction from the Board regarding the location and front yard setback for the new house and the minimum driveway width for Lot 58.02. He stated that, if a variance were required, he asked that the Board grant it, after which the remaining issues could be handled by the professionals and building department during the building permit review. He stated that the review could confirm the required parking, sufficient turning templates, and related requirements. - Council President Scarpa stated that she felt there was not enough information
. He stated that the review could confirm the required parking, sufficient turning templates, and related requirements. - Council President Scarpa stated that she felt there was not enough information completed to make a decision at that time because there were too many variables that could change. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the Board was working through the variables and could set parameters for the experts, building department, and zoning official to use in making those decisions. Mr. Alper agreed that the Board could essentially set parameters. - Mr. Klein asked whether there was a minimum driveway width and questioned why an 8- foot driveway was being proposed. Chairman Bagoff noted that the applicant was seeking a variance for the minimum driveway width. - Mr. Klein stated that the driveway needed to be adequate because two sets of families would be sharing it and that it could not be a substandard width. - Mr. Trembulak stated that 14 feet seemed excessive for a driveway. Mr. Klein clarified that the 14 feet was not the driveway width. He stated that the driveway appeared to be approximately 10 feet wide, with approximately 2 feet on either side within the 14-foot area from the building to the property line. - Mr. Klein stated that Lot 58.01 appeared to have a 10-foot setback and a 10-foot driveway, while Lot 58.02 appeared to have a 10-foot setback and an 8-foot driveway. - Mr. Trembulak asked whether 10 feet would be acceptable for the driveway width. Mr. Klein stated yes
13 - Chairman Bagoff asked Ms. McGovern to review the conditions before the Board proceeded. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant would agree to abide by all suggestions and directives set forth in the CME reports dated December 16, 2025 and January 28, 2026, and the Board Planner's report dated June 26, 2026. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant would eliminate front yard parking and put the parking in the rear of the property for Lot 58.01, the new lot. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant would move the house up to match the house on the existing lot, with a 16.71-foot front yard setback, and would comply with all building requirements, including height and design requirements. She clarified that the setback requirement would be addressed separately and that the design condition included a difference in the front design. - Ms. McGovern stated that, based upon a turning template, the applicant would adjust the addition to Lot 58.02 and create a 10-foot driveway. - Ms. McGovern stated that both two-family houses would contain two-bedroom units, with all units being two-bedroom units. - Ms. McGovern stated that each apartment must contain 1,100 square feet of space. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant would comply with the design regulations and would remove the shed at the rear of the property, as had been discussed at the first hearing. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant would submit a grading and drainage plan for the new Lot 58.01 to the Office of the Municipal Engineer for review and approval at the time of obtaining building permits. - Chairman Bagoff asked about the C2 variances. Ms. McGovern stated that there was a front yard variance for the new Lot 58.01. - Chairman Bagoff noted that the new addition on the existing lot would need a front yard setback variance. - Ms. McGovern stated that Lot 58.02 was already pre-existing at a 16.82-foot front yard setback. She stated that Lot 58.01, as currently shown, would be moved up and would therefore need a front yard variance. - Ms. McGovern stated that the newly created lot also needed a side yard setback variance because the side yard to the property line was approximately 2.5 feet. She noted that there was enough space for the driveway, but the applicant would have to create a 10-foot driveway on Lot 58.02. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant also needed a variance for 5,000
he noted that there was enough space for the driveway, but the applicant would have to create a 10-foot driveway on Lot 58.02. - Ms. McGovern stated that the applicant also needed a variance for 5,000 square feet of lot area because a two-family house required 7,500 square feet, and a variance for lot width because a two-family house required 75 feet while the proposed lot width was 50 feet. - Ms. McGovern asked whether the rear yard setback was measured from the last parking space to the rear or whether the parking spaces could be included within the rear yard setback. Mr. Davis stated that the rear yard setback was measured to the principal building, not the rear of the property. Ms. McGovern confirmed that parking spaces could therefore be located within the rear yard area without affecting the rear yard setback. - Mr. Klein asked whether the pavement for the parking spaces could extend all the way to the rear property line. Mr. Davis stated that, as far as he understood, it could, noting that many existing properties shown in the aerial were completely paved to the rear. - Chairman Bagoff noted that the applicant had requested an RSIS waiver for parking stall size, but that this might change. - Ms. McGovern asked whether the RSIS waiver was still necessary with the parking being placed in the rear.
14 - Mr. Trembulak stated that the applicant could agree to comply with the required parking space dimensions or otherwise return for relief. - Mayor McCartney asked whether revised plans would be submitted to the building department if the Board agreed to all of the conditions. Chairman Bagoff stated that revised plans would have to be submitted. He explained that the revised plans would go directly to the zoning official in the building department and the Board's experts for compliance review. - Chairman Bagoff then made a motion to approve PB25-09, Perez, 68 Whittlesley Avenue, Block 129, Lot 58, Zone RT, with all of the previously mentioned conditions and requirements. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the application did not deviate from the goals of the Master Plan. He stated that, based on Mr. Flynn's testimony, it was infill housing, was consistent with the neighborhood, and was a better use of the space, which was also part of the improvements to the Master Plan. - Motion: Chairman Bagoff - Second: Mr. Noborine Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): Y Noborine: Y Guarino: Y Scarpa: A Kapferer: ---- Wilkes: --- Klein: Y ● PB-25-12 262 & 270 Main Street Realty LLC 262 & 270 Main Street Block: 114 Lot: 50 & 55 Zone: B-1 The applicant proposes to construct a two-story supermarket building consisting of 13,934 square feet on the first floor and 5,810 square feet on the second floor, for a total of 19,744 square feet. PRESENTATION - Ms. Amanda Wolfe, of Norris McLaughlin, appeared on behalf of the applicant and the owner of 262 and 270 Main Street. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the application began on May 6, returned on June 3 for additional testimony, and included a PowerPoint presentation by the architect, Jorge. She stated that the application was also scheduled for July 1 but was not heard, and the applicant was now returning on August 12. - Ms. Wolfe stated that, in the interim, the applicant had made progress and received a report from the Downtown Alliance. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant had also communicated with the forester, who submitted a revised memo confirming that the landscaping plan was acceptable.
15 - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant reached out to the Community House, the school adjacent to the property, to determine whether it had any concerns about the project. She stated that she could not provide hearsay testimony but indicated that the school had no objections to the project. - The engineer, Jordan Cecini, entered on the record; he was sworn under oath. His credentials were accepted by the board and he testified to the following: - Mr. Cecini stated that the plans he was presenting were the current plans submitted to the Board, with a last revised date of May 26, 2026. Ms. Wolfe confirmed that this was the plan set previously introduced as Exhibit A2. - Mr. Cecini stated that he was engaged to perform the engineering design for the drawings, focusing primarily on drainage, parking, lighting, and associated site plan requirements. He stated that he worked closely with the architect, Jorge Masto Priestro, in developing the plan. - Mr. Cecini began with the drainage design and referred to Sheet C1.07. - Mr. Cecini stated that, because this was a major development, the project had to control total suspended solids (TSS) as well as additional runoff under the new New Jersey requirements. - Mr. Cecini described two separate drainage designs. Because a large amount of rainwater would be collected from the roof, one stormwater detention basin would outflow into the storm sewer in a controlled manner. - Mr. Cecini stated that a pervious pavement system would collect direct runoff from the parking stalls along the edge of the property. A swale would collect the runoff and direct it into an aquaponic filter that would remove total suspended solids before the water entered the basin. - Mr. Cecini stated that the piping was designed for overflows if the project exceeded the design storm and that the system complied with the stormwater design criteria. - Ms. Wolfe asked Mr. Cecini to discuss the existing drainage conditions and whether the proposed system would be an improvement. - Mr. Cecini stated that the proposed system would definitely be an improvement. He stated that no inlets collecting runoff from the existing site were indicated on the survey and that he did not recall seeing any during his site visit. - Mr. Cecini stated that the existing site was 100% impervious coverage and that all runoff was going into the stormwater system. - Mr. Cecini
that he did not recall seeing any during his site visit. - Mr. Cecini stated that the existing site was 100% impervious coverage and that all runoff was going into the stormwater system. - Mr. Cecini stated that the new design would reduce runoff and collect a good portion of it into the stormwater collection system, including runoff from the roof area. - Mr. Cecini stated that the project would also remove total suspended solids from the roadway and parking lot, including oil residues and dirt from vehicles. - Mr. Cecini described the proposed green infrastructure, including pervious pavers. He stated that a portion of the parking lot would be converted from asphalt to pavers with gaps that allow water to pass through into a gravel basin, where the water would be stored within the gravel. - Mr. Cecini stated that the pervious pavement system was designed in compliance with the New Jersey Best Practices Manual and its recommendations for green infrastructure. - Ms. Wolfe asked about the proposed rain gardens. Mr. Cecini stated that the rain gardens would be located in the swale and would collect water flowing from the asphalt down the driveway. A structure within the rain gardens would collect the water and direct it into the stormwater system. - Mr. Cecini stated that the lighting plan met the ordinance criteria, with 0.5 foot-candles that did not protrude outside the area.
16 - Mr. Cecini noted that the plans were somewhat old and that there had been comments from the planner. He stated that the architect was proposing lighting for the structure and that the applicant intended to provide the lighting as a condition to demonstrate compliance with the 0.5 foot-candle requirement. - Mr. Cecini then addressed parking, which he identified as the variance being sought. - Mr. Cecini stated that when the drawings were originally submitted, the applicant had assumed that the warehouse/storage space on the second floor could be excluded from the parking calculation because it was not intended for customers and was primarily for storing materials needed for the supermarket. - Mr. Cecini stated that the Planner requested that the second-floor space be included in the parking calculation. - Mr. Cecini stated that he therefore ran the parking calculation two different ways. Under the B1 calculation, including the second-floor storage area, the total square footage less 1,000 square feet, divided by 300, resulted in 56.92 spaces, which rounded up to 57 spaces. - Mr. Cecini stated that because the project proposed four EV spaces, the applicant received the benefit of adding four spaces to the design, bringing the required number down to 53 spaces. - Mr. Cecini stated that the plan currently provided 58 spaces, but there was no way to fit the additional five spaces within the proposed area. - Mr. Cecini stated that the second calculation considered how necessary the additional five spaces were by looking at the ordinances governing other parts of the city. - Under the second calculation, the 13,934-square-foot retail space divided by 300 resulted in 46.44 spaces. - The 3,144-square-foot storage space divided by the warehouse requirement of 600 resulted in 5.24 spaces, for a total of 52 spaces. After subtracting the four EV spaces, the calculation resulted in 48 stalls. - Mr. Cecini stated that, based on the two different calculations, a parking variance was required, but in his opinion the design should meet the requirement for the intended use of the property. - Mr. Cecini stated that there had also been discussion regarding turnarounds but that he would leave that issue to the traffic engineer because he had not performed a turnaround analysis. - Mr. Cecini stated that, in general, he considered the application a solid application that met
t he would leave that issue to the traffic engineer because he had not performed a turnaround analysis. - Mr. Cecini stated that, in general, he considered the application a solid application that met the stormwater and lighting requirements and that the parking variance was related to the different type of building proposed compared with prior CVS, Walmart, and Walgreens uses at the site. - Ms. Wolfe asked whether Mr. Cecini would address landscaping. Mr. Cecini stated that it would be more appropriate for Jorge to address landscaping because the architect had the better presentation and 3D outputs. - Mr. Cecini stated that the landscaping was being coordinated with the architect and had been taken into consideration in the drainage design. - Ms. Wolfe asked whether the utilities remained the same. Mr. Cecini stated that they did. - Ms. Wolfe asked where the refuse area and dumpster would be located. Mr. Cecini stated that he believed the refuse area would be inside the building and that the architect had addressed it during his prior presentation. BOARD QUESTIONS
17 - Chairman Bagoff asked whether there would be a bench for seniors to sit on while waiting for the jitney. Mr. Cecini stated that he believed there was a location for the bench and recalled that, after the prior meeting, the team had discussed it with the architect. He stated that the architect had a place for the bench and that it would not interfere with parking or other requirements. - Mr. Guarino asked Mr. Cecini about the water retention facility in front by the street and asked how many gallons it retained. Mr. Cecini reviewed the stormwater report and testified that the project has a runoff volume of approximately 7,800, with the exact number to be confirmed upon further review of his report. - Mr. Guarino asked whether, after the stormwater system reaches its maximum retention, the water would flow into the Township’s stormwater system. Mr. Cecini confirmed that it would. - Mr. Guarino asked whether the proposed drainage system would include new infrastructure or connections between the property and the Township facility. Mr. Cecini confirmed that the project intends to connect to existing or proposed manholes in the street. - Mr Guarino asked about the delivery trailer and the reference in the first presentation to parking the delivery trailer on Main Street. He stated that he had a significant concern with that arrangement. Mr. Cecini stated that he understood the concern and explained that he had performed turning-radius work, but that the traffic engineer would be the most appropriate person to address the reasoning for the proposed delivery arrangement. ○ Mr. Cecini stated that, within the site, it would not make sense to place the delivery trailer there because it would be very difficult to turn around and would require the truck to back in or back out. - Council president Scarpa asked if she could hear more about how the delivery truck issue would be mitigated. Mr. Cecini stated that someone who specializes in the matter was taking a very close look at it and that it would be appropriate for the traffic engineer to address it. - Mr. Klein asked whether sight triangles had been placed on the site plan for the site driveways, showing the distance that could be seen when exiting the driveway. Mr. Cecini initially referred to the directional arrows, but Mr. Klein clarified that he was asking about sight triangles. ○ Mr. Klein stated that he did
File revisions (1)
- Oct 7, 2026
89b5155dfd6e370,634 bytes