Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

Ltr in response to Tractenberg request for subpoena 10626

Preserved file SHA-256ca8dfb7fe22a903617b9b4f411f58388d1d29c5f1d36742d0107dd75c0b59ecf

Indexed text · page 1

Show all pages
Page 1

RS Law Offices of 75 Main Street, Suite 201 . . Rick@SchkolnickLaw.com Millburn, NJ 07044 Richard Schkolnick, LLC SchkolnickLaw.com 973-232-5061 October 6, 2026 VIA Email Only Dr. Robert Bagoff, Chairman Planning Board Township of West Orange 66 Main Street, Room 214 West Orange, NJ 07052 Re: Crestmont Country Club 750 Eagle Rock Avenue Block 174, Lot 1.01 Dear Dr. Bagoff: This Firm represents Crestmont Country Club, Inc. (“Crestmont”). We have the letter dated September 16, 2026 from Paul Tractenberg, Esq., requesting that you, as the presiding officer of the Planning Board, issue a broad subpoena for a wide series of documents. For the reasons that follow, Crestmont requests that this request be denied in its entirety. At the outset, we mention that Mr. Tractenberg has not cited any case law (or other guidance) for a legal standard to guide his request for such a broad subpoena in a land use proceeding. We could not locate any such case law or guidance either. We note two other relevant matters. First, Mr. Tractenberg lists his address as “96 Sullivan Drive.” We do not know if that address is a home or business, or whether Mr. Tractenberg resides or owns property within 200 feet of the subject parcel. Our internet search reveals that 96 Sullivan Drive is approximately one half mile (as the crow flies) from the subject site, and a longer driving distance. We trust that the Board will consider whether Mr. Tractenberg is an “interested party” living within 200 feet and the implications of allowing a person living (or working) a material distance from a proposed development site to have such a profound impact ona land use proceeding. See generally N.J.S.A. 40:55D-4 (defining “interested party”). This is not a situation in which a property owner is faced, for example, with a proposal for an all night fast food restaurant on an immediately adjacent property. The pending application before the Board is a proposal that does not put forth any new buildings or structures, located (we believe)

File revisions (1)