Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026
Ltr in response to Tractenberg request for subpoena 10626
ca8dfb7fe22a903617b9b4f411f58388d1d29c5f1d36742d0107dd75c0b59ecfIndexed text · page 2
Show all pagesDr. Robert Bagoff October 6, 2026 Page 2 a half mile from Mr. Tractenberg’s residence. Yet, the implications of granting the request are profound. Second, we trust that the Board understands that issuance of a subpoena for documents in a land use proceeding in exceedingly rare and that issuance of a subpoena in this matter will, without doubt, result in a significant delay to this application. Approval of the request will also invite similar requests in every contested matter that comes before this Board, exponentially raising costs on applicants and their professionals. The Board will, we can reasonably predict, be engulfed with subpoena requests similar to the one made by Mr. Tractenberg’s and its decision here will undoubtedly be cited as authority. We treat each request in the order set forth in Mr. Tractenberg’s letter. 1. The 2025 WEHI -Crestmont Agreement Mr. Tractenberg fails to explain how the 2025 WEHI/Crestmont agreement is related to the land _use issues at stake in this matter. He does not say how this agreement impacts the statutory criteria for c” variances or site plan approval. His request, we suggest, is a fishing expedition. This matter is a routine request for site plan approval with ‘c’ variances, filed by Crestmont as property owner in good faith and in accord with its rights as a property owner and the MLUL. Ms. Cancellaro, Crestmont’s General Manager and Chief Operating Officer testified about this agreement and its origins. Mr. Tractenberg had an opportunity to cross examine her. Her testimony was complete months ago. Mr. Tractenberg cites no authority the proposition in his letter (page 4, bottom) that whether Crestmont “independently conceived, commissioned, and financed” the proposal before the Board is actually relevant to the Board’s evaluation of this matter. Ms. Cancellaro testified about Crestmont’s legitimate business reasons for this application, including the proposed parking lot expansion and safety improvements that would accrue from the closing of the existing exit driveway and reconfiguration to create a new 4-way intersection. She testified that she was approached by WEHI, and that she was presented with documentation (which is a public record) wherein the Township of West Orange committed to exercising eminent domain in order to construct the traffic signal at issue. She testified further that Crestmont made a
ion (which is a public record) wherein the Township of West Orange committed to exercising eminent domain in order to construct the traffic signal at issue. She testified further that Crestmont made a reasonable business decision to negotiate with WEHI in order to further its own interests and avoid the logistical “mess” that would undoubtedly take place if Crestmont did not amicably resolve the maiter. Mr. Tractenberg is certainly free to make arguments impugning Ms. Cancellaro’s credibility or Cresimont’s motives. But, he should not be permitted to take advantage of the Board’s subpoena power to delay this case, add monumental costs to the proceedings, and go on a fishing expedition.
File revisions (1)
- Oct 8, 2026
ca8dfb7fe22a130,489 bytes