Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

Ltr in response to Tractenberg request for subpoena 10626

Preserved file SHA-256ca8dfb7fe22a903617b9b4f411f58388d1d29c5f1d36742d0107dd75c0b59ecf

Indexed text · page 3

Show all pages
Page 3

Dr. Robert Bagoff October 6, 2026 Page 3 We note that Mr. Tractenberg also seeks a ‘privilege’ log of attorney-client communications that are not produced. He does not identify who would resolve disputes about Aittorney-client privilege or the desired privilege log. Simply stated, a land use proceeding is not litigation. Acceptance of Mr. Tractenberg’s request would add enormous cost, monumental delay and vast uncertainty (which no established mechanism to resolve what will undoubtedly be numerous “litigation type” disputes). 2. The W-9 and Escrow Funding Documents Mr. Tractenberg has again failed to explain how the W-9 and “escrow funding documents” are relevant to the land use issues at stake. Should he so desire, Mr. Tractenberg can argue to ihe Board that it should consider thw W-9 form or “escrow funding agreement” in its deliberations. However, we fail to see how information on the W-9 form or the identity of the payor of the escrow impacts the Board’s consideration of the land use issues at stake here. And Mr. Tractenberg has not presented any case law or other authority to support the proposition that such information is relevant to the standards set forth in the MLUL for site plan approval or ‘c’ variances. We note further that the W-9 is a sensitive tax document containing information and in today’s world of scams and fraud extreme caution must be taken prior to its release. 3. The Crestmont-Langan Agreements Again, Mr. Tractenberg has failed to explain why a contract between Crestmont and Langan (the engineering firm) is relevant to the land use proceedings before the Board. This request, we submit, appears to be another fishing expedition seeking information that is not germane to the Board’s factual and legal considerations. To the extent that Mr. Tractenberg desires to show bias of the witnesses by revealing who pays their invoices, paid, Mr. Tractenberg had an opportunity to cross examine the “Langan” witnesses. And he is free to argue that their opinions should not be valued by the Board because of such (presumed) bias. However, if this request is granted, we have little doubt of the “Pandora’s Box” that would be opened. Every Planning Board matter with an objector would be met with such a request and the Board, it seems, would not be left with any principled way to deny such a request. Of course, the civil engineering plans

Page 3

anning Board matter with an objector would be met with such a request and the Board, it seems, would not be left with any principled way to deny such a request. Of course, the civil engineering plans prepared by the “Langhan” witnesses and their expert testimony ARE relevant and there has already been hours (and hours) of testimony and cross examination, to an extent a neutral observer might consider ad nauseam. We submit that this request is a transparent effort to delay this matter.

File revisions (1)