Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026
Ltr in response to Tractenberg request for subpoena 10626
ca8dfb7fe22a903617b9b4f411f58388d1d29c5f1d36742d0107dd75c0b59ecfIndexed text · page 4
Show all pagesDr. Robert Bagoff October 6, 2026 Page 4 4. Langan Billing and Payment Records Mr. Tractenberg has not explained how Langan’s billing records are relevant to the land use issues at stake in this matter. If this request is granted, we have little doubt of the “Pandora’s Box” that would be opened. Every Planning Board application with an objector would be met with such a request and the Board, it seems, would not be left with any principled way to deny it. 5. WEHI/Garden Homes/Langan Agreement Related to Crestmont This request seems, in substantial part, to be a repeat of Request # 4. Mr. Tractenberg has not explained how ‘agreements,” “proposals,” “invoices” that may exist between WEHI and Langan are relevant to the land use issues before this Board. Again, approval of this request will likely create a precedent which will cause land use proceedings to spin out of control. Mr. Tractenberg has had a reasonable opportunity to cross examine the “Langan witnesses” as to any bias they may have, including but not limited to identification of the entity paying its invoices. 6. Related Communications This request is an incredibly broad request that seeks to turn a relatively simple land use proceeding into a contested litigation -- essentially with full blown discovery. It is overbroad, vexatious and appears designed to cause delay and enormous expense. The request is made months after the initial hearing in this matter in June. Mr. Tractenberg has not cited any land use matters in New Jersey where such a broad request has been granted. Respectfully, this request must be rejected. This is not litigation. It is a land use _ proceeding. The expert reports and witness testimony are, of course relevant. Mr. Tractenberg has had an opportunity to cross examine the witnesses and he certainly will have an opportunity to present opposition experts and reports if he so desires. And the Board can weigh the evidence in accord with the MLUL.
File revisions (1)
- Oct 8, 2026
ca8dfb7fe22a130,489 bytes