Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Nov 4, 2026

9 2 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e517e0133e501772133e3ec02fd3a94ed8399b86900e5b5caa6858d51f060903

Indexed text

Page 1

1 MINUTES TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE PLANNING BOARD MEETING September 2, 2026, 6:30 P.M. The Township of West Orange Planning Board held a special meeting on September 2, 2026, at 6:30 P.M. via virtual ZOOM videoconference. Chairman Bagoff called the meeting to order at approximately 6:30 P.M. He announced that notification of the meeting was given to the Township Clerk, and posted on the Township Bulletin Board, sent to the West Orange Chronicle and the Star Ledger, and posted on the Township’s website calendar. This meeting has been properly noticed to the public in accordance with the Open Public Meetings Act. No new matters will start after 10:30 P.M. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE • Chairman Bagoff requested all persons stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. ANNOUNCEMENTS ● The next Planner Board regular meeting will be held Wednesday, October 7, 2026 at 7:30 p.m. via Zoom. ● The next Planner Board special meeting will be held Wednesday, September 9, 2026 at 6:30 p.m. via Zoom. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Dr. Robert Bagoff; Mr. Ken Alper; Mr. Christopher Morgan, Sr.; Mayor Susan McCartney; Mr. Frank Noborine; Council President Susan Scarpa; Ms. Lori Kapferer; Mr. Jerry Guarino ABSENT: Mr. Lee Klein; Mr. William Wilkes; Mr. John Cardoza ALSO PRESENT: Diana P. McGovern, Esq., Planning Board Attorney; Jamilet Baquerizo Vite, Planning Board Secretary; Malvika Apte (Consultant Planner) Mr. Greg Valesi (Consultant Engineer) SWEARING IN ● The Township Professionals: Mr. Greg Valesi (Consultant Engineer) and Ms. Malvika Apte (Consultant Planner) were sworn under oath. MINUTES & RESOLUTIONS 6-3-26-WO-PB-Draft-Minutes Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mr. Guarino Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y

Page 2

2 Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): --- Noborine: Y Guarino: Y Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Klein: --- 6-10-26-WO-PB-Draft-Minutes Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mayor McCartney Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): --- Noborine: Y Guarino: Y Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Klein: --- 6-24-26-WO-PB-Draft-Minutes Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mr. Morgan Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): --- Noborine: Y Guarino: Y Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Klein: --- PB-25-09-Perez-Minor-Subdivision-Draft-Resolution Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mr. Guarino Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): --- Noborine: Y Guarino: Y Scarpa: --- Kapferer: --- Wilkes: ---- Klein: ---

Page 3

3 PB-25-12-262-270-Main-Street-Draft-Resolution Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mayor McCartney Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): --- Noborine: Y Guarino: --- Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Klein: --- EXECUTIVE SESSION - Chairman Bagoff read the resolution pursuant to the Open Public Meetings Act, N.J.S.A. 10:4-12, authorizing the exclusion of the public to discuss pending litigation involving the Builder’s Remedy proposal for Application PB24-06, 410 Main Street, Block 113, Lots 262, 264, and 308, and West Essex Highlands, Inc., Application PB24-01, Block 179, Lot 32. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the matters discussed would be made public upon the conclusion of litigation, that the Board would reconvene in open session following executive session, and that the resolution would take effect immediately. MASTER PLAN CONSISTENCY REVIEW ● Master-Plan-Consistency-Memo_76-80-Main-Street-Redevelopment-Plan 80-Main- Street-Redevelopment-Plan Ordinance-2977-26_80-Main-Street-RDP - Chairman Bagoff introduced the Master Plan Consistency Review for the 76–80 Main Street Redevelopment Plan, Ordinance 2977-26, and invited Ms. Apte to present her findings. - Ms. Apte presented the Master Plan Consistency Review for the redevelopment plan prepared by her office and dated May 14, 2026. - She explained that the property, located at 76–80 Main Street, immediately north of Town Hall, is identified as Block 88, Lot 17, consists of approximately 3.39 acres, and contains an existing five-story office building surrounded by parking. - Ms. Apte explained that suburban office buildings have faced increasing challenges over the years, particularly following COVID-19, due to remote work trends and rising tenancy costs. - She stated that the redevelopment plan is intended to revitalize the existing building by introducing additional commercial uses while maintaining its primary office function. - Ms. Apte stated that the Township Council conducted a township-wide Area in Need of Rehabilitation study in 2021 and subsequently designated the entire Township as an Area in Need of Rehabilitation. ○ The proposed redevelopment plan was prepared pursuant to that designation. - Ms. Apte outlined the three primary objectives of the redevelopment plan: ○ introducing additional permitted uses

Page 4

4 ○ maintaining the existing office building ○ encouraging renovation and activation of ground-floor commercial spaces. - Ms. Apte explained that the redevelopment plan would continue to permit general, medical, and professional offices, as well as art galleries, art studios, and banks - Additional ground-floor uses would include fitness centers, massage establishments, microbreweries, wineries, retail establishments, experiential retail, workshops, and restaurants. - Accessory uses would include outdoor cafes and certain video or amusement arcades. - Ms. Apte stated that the proposed bulk standards reflect the property's existing development, including its five-story height and current building and lot coverage. - She explained that the plan does not seek to increase the building's existing scale but instead focuses on rehabilitation and introducing compatible uses. - Ms. Apte explained that the redevelopment plan also incorporates updated design standards addressing outdoor cafe seating, buffering, landscaping, signage, and parking. ○ She emphasized the importance of revitalizing the property because of its prominent location along Main Street, a significant corridor in West Orange. - Ms. Apte explained that, pursuant to the Local Redevelopment and Housing Law, the Planning Board is responsible for reviewing the redevelopment plan and determining whether it is consistent with the Township's Master Plan. ○ The Board's recommendation would then be transmitted to the Township Council, which has the authority to adopt the redevelopment plan by ordinance. - Ms. Apte stated that the redevelopment plan is substantially consistent with the Township's 2019 Master Plan Update. - She explained that the Master Plan recommends modifying permitted commercial uses to reflect changing retail markets, accommodating emerging businesses such as microbreweries and wineries, and encouraging varied nonresidential uses that complement one another and support economic development. - Ms. Apte concluded that the redevelopment plan would encourage greater activity, economic development, and commercial vibrancy by allowing a broader range of uses within the existing building. - She recommended that the Planning Board determine that the redevelopment plan is substantially consistent with the goals and objectives of the 2019 Master Plan. BOARD QUESTIONS - Mr. Guarino asked whether

Page 4

recommended that the Planning Board determine that the redevelopment plan is substantially consistent with the goals and objectives of the 2019 Master Plan. BOARD QUESTIONS - Mr. Guarino asked whether future plans would be submitted showing the proposed appearance of the property and its anticipated uses. Ms. Apte explained that, once adopted, the redevelopment plan would function as the governing ordinance for the property. Future applicants would be required to submit site plans for Planning Board approval and comply with the permitted uses and applicable standards established by the redevelopment plan. Any necessary deviations would require appropriate approvals. - Mr. Guarino noted that the building currently contains a bank on the first floor and asked whether that use would remain permitted. Ms. Apte confirmed that banks would continue to be permitted under the redevelopment plan. - Mr. Guarino asked whether the redevelopment plan would incorporate Complete Streets principles, pedestrian safety, and improved walkability. Ms. Apte confirmed that the design standards encourage these considerations and stated that pedestrian accessibility and related improvements would be addressed during future site plan reviews. - Mr. Alper expressed concern about allowing massage establishments, noting that redevelopment plan regulations would apply to the property regardless of future changes

Page 5

5 in ownership. He suggested that the language be reviewed and tightened to prevent potentially undesirable uses. - Mr. Alper also raised concerns regarding the definition of experiential retail, particularly indoor virtual simulations and group activities. He stated that new business concepts could potentially fall within the definition in ways that were not originally anticipated. He suggested considering additional safeguards or case-by-case review of certain uses. - Mr. Alper recommended that princess cafes be specifically included as an example of experiential retail, noting that there is demand for this type of establishment in the area. Ms. Apte explained that the redevelopment plan includes comprehensive definitions of the proposed uses and agreed to review the recommendation to include princess cafes. - Mr. Alper questioned whether the redevelopment plan should incorporate the existing Township ordinance definitions for all permitted uses, rather than relying on definitions that could change through future ordinance amendments. He suggested including the current definitions in the redevelopment plan to avoid unintentionally expanding or changing permitted uses in the future. Ms. Apte explained that uses already defined in the Township's zoning ordinance would generally rely on those existing definitions. Mr. Alper reiterated that incorporating the current definitions directly into the redevelopment plan could provide greater certainty and protect against unintended future changes. ○ Chairman Bagoff suggested that identifying specifically prohibited uses might be more practical than attempting to define every acceptable use. Chairman Bagoff also discussed recreational uses such as indoor pickleball, indoor golf, and video arcades. - Mr. Alper noted that the redevelopment plan's arcade provisions appeared to permit certain arcade activities only when associated with a restaurant, potentially allowing an establishment similar to Dave & Buster's while restricting standalone traditional arcades. - Mr. Alper asked whether the definition of medical offices would include urgent care facilities. Ms. Apte explained that the proposed definition includes facilities providing diagnostic, therapeutic, preventive, medical, dental, psychological, and related outpatient treatment. She clarified that such facilities would serve ambulatory patients and would not

Page 5

lities providing diagnostic, therapeutic, preventive, medical, dental, psychological, and related outpatient treatment. She clarified that such facilities would serve ambulatory patients and would not permit inpatient care or major surgical procedures. Based on that definition, urgent care facilities could potentially qualify as a permitted medical office use. ○ Mr. Alper suggested that the Board consider excluding urgent care facilities from the redevelopment plan. He explained that the purpose of introducing new commercial uses was to encourage visitors to patronize restaurants, retail establishments, and other businesses. He expressed concern that individuals visiting urgent care facilities due to illness or injury would be less likely to visit surrounding businesses. - Mr. Alper also questioned whether incorporating the Township's existing outdoor cafe licensing requirements would prohibit outdoor music or restrict establishments from opening windows or doors while indoor music was playing. He expressed concern that these restrictions could discourage the types of restaurant and entertainment uses the redevelopment plan was intended to attract. ○ Chairman Bagoff stated that an applicant seeking to provide outdoor music might need to request a variance. Mr. Alper emphasized that the Township should encourage desirable outdoor cafe and entertainment uses rather than impose unnecessary restrictions. - Mayor McCartney asked whether massage establishments could be prohibited under the redevelopment plan if they were permitted elsewhere in the Township. Ms. McGovern explained that the redevelopment plan could establish site-specific permitted and prohibited uses, regardless of the uses allowed in other zoning districts.

Page 6

6 ○ Ms. Apte confirmed that the redevelopment plan would apply only to the subject property and that existing zoning regulations would continue to govern other properties throughout the Township. BOARD COMMENTS - Council President Scarpa expressed agreement with Mr. Alper's concerns regarding the proposed uses and supported excluding massage parlors and urgent care facilities. She clarified that she supported outdoor cafes and did not want those establishments excluded. - Ms. McGovern confirmed that the proposed outdoor cafe recommendation was intended to allow music with appropriate restrictions, potentially including decibel limitations. Chairman Bagoff agreed that the recommendations should be included for consideration. - Ms. McGovern summarized the proposed modifications as including princess cafes as a permitted use, excluding urgent care facilities and massage parlors, and allowing outdoor cafe music subject to appropriate limitations. - Chairman Bagoff recommended that pawn shops also be expressly prohibited. Ms. Apte noted that pawn shops were not included among the proposed permitted uses. Council President Scarpa supported specifically identifying them as prohibited. - Mr. Guarino requested further clarification regarding the proposed exclusion of urgent care facilities. He questioned why the Board would prohibit a potentially beneficial healthcare use, particularly given the property's location and the needs of nearby residents. ○ Mr. Alper explained that his concern was primarily related to the redevelopment plan's economic development objectives. He distinguished urgent care facilities from traditional medical offices, stating that individuals visiting a medical office for routine appointments might also visit nearby businesses, while individuals seeking urgent medical treatment would be less likely to do so. - Mr. Guarino stated that residents living near the property could benefit from having an accessible urgent care facility in the downtown area. He noted that other urgent care options were located farther away, including along Eagle Rock Avenue near Prospect Avenue. He emphasized that redevelopment should consider the needs and well-being of surrounding residents in addition to economic development objectives. - Mayor McCartney observed that the discussion reflected two different considerations: encouraging commercial uses that support one

Page 6

urrounding residents in addition to economic development objectives. - Mayor McCartney observed that the discussion reflected two different considerations: encouraging commercial uses that support one another within the building and addressing the broader healthcare needs of the community. ○ She stated that Mr. Alper appeared to be focused on the retail and commercial objectives of the redevelopment plan, while Mr. Guarino was considering the benefits to the surrounding community. - Mr. Alper reiterated that his recommendation was intended to maintain a stronger retail focus. Mr. Guarino acknowledged the explanation APPLICATIONS ● PB-26-03 Crestmont Country Club 750 Eagle Rock Avenue Block: 174 Lot: 1.01 Zone: R-2 The applicant is proposing the installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Eagle Rock Avenue and Oval Road. Modifications to the existing driveway and parking area are also being proposed.

Page 7

7 PRESENTATION - Mr. Richard Schkolnick, Esq., appearing on behalf of the applicant, explained that the application is for site plan approval with several C variances. - He stated that the property is located in the R2 zone, the existing use is permitted, and no new buildings are proposed. - The application includes 32 new parking spaces and a new exit for Crestmont Country Club that would align with Oval Road, creating a four-way intersection along Eagle Rock Avenue. - Mr. Schkolnick stated that the proposed improvements include widening Eagle Rock Avenue, new grading, stormwater management, significant landscaping improvements, and a traffic signal intended to create a safer intersection. - He also confirmed that the applicant had agreed during the previous hearing to install a sidewalk along Eagle Rock Avenue and had no objections to the review letters prepared by the Board's professionals. - Mr. Schkolnick provided a recap of the previous hearings, beginning with June 3, 2026. ○ He stated that Ms. Dana Cancellaro, General Manager and Chief Operating Officer of Crestmont Country Club, testified regarding the need for additional parking for club members and the challenges associated with the existing driveway, including its slope and difficult left-hand turns. ○ She also discussed the club's desire for safety improvements and the potential for eminent domain, explaining that the proposal represented a reasonable, practical, and cooperative approach to addressing complex issues involving the Township and potential condemnation of the club's property. ○ Mr. Schkolnick stated that the Board previously heard testimony from Mr. John Cote, P.E., the applicant's civil engineer, who presented an aerial photograph and discussed the site improvements ○ Mr. Carl Penke, the applicant's traffic expert, who addressed the geometry of the proposed four-way intersection, difficult turning movements, private investment in the traffic signal, widening of Eagle Rock Avenue, left-hand turns, crosswalks, ramps, sidewalks, and existing grading challenges. Mr. Penke also discussed previous efforts involving the County Planning Board to improve this section of Eagle Rock Avenue. ○ Mr. Schkolnick explained that the July 1, 2026 hearing included extensive cross- examination of Mr. Penke, followed by approximately 20 minutes of testimony from Mr. Cote regarding the civil engineering

File revisions (1)