Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-25661cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9

Indexed text

Page 20

rive, Essex Fells. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead, Sir. MR. HADU: A question about the traffic light. If there’s going to be a sidewalk on the side of Eagle Rock where Crestmont is, is there any room to1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 73 put a sidewalk on the Essex Fells County Club side? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: That’s not part of the application, Sir, so it -- we can’t tell -- we haven’t talk about that. There’s no application before us. MR. HADU: Well, if you’re going to put a light there, what’s going to be on the other side of the -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: We’re not putting a light anywhere. This is the county. All we’re talking about is the Crestmont Country Club side, Sir. MR. HADU: Well, what happens if you approve it? Then what happens to the other side of the street? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: This is the -- up to the county. That’s the county planning board, Sir. MR. HADU: So you’re going to approve something without knowing what’s going to happen on the other side of the street? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: There’s no application before us on the other side of the street, Sir. MR. HADU: So with a bus stop -- what side would a bus stop be on? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: There’s no bus stop proposed and -- MR. HADU: I’m not asking you the questions. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Oh. I’m sorry. Who would1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Public Questions 74 you like to ask the question of, Sir? Mr. Moronski? MR. HADU: Yes, please. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Oh. Mr. Moronski, you’re up. MR. HADU: Can’t I ask you the -- why did you answer his questions? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I answered the question because he doesn’t -- MR. HADU: I didn’t ask you the questions. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Well, you asked an administrative question, Sir. There’s no application before us. We can’t opine on that, neither can he. That’s administrative. I’m sorry you misunderstood. Mr. Moronski, please answer his question about the bus stop. MR. MORONSKI: Okay. As I had noted earlier, I’m not aware of any proposal but as I previously noted, our -- my -- our client would, you know, if there’s interested, would work with the township if -- if it was something that was desired at this location. But as of today, I am not -- I’m not aware of any plans for a bus stop at that location. MR. HADU: Good -- my question about the bus stop to you would be would it be

Page 20

that was desired at this location. But as of today, I am not -- I’m not aware of any plans for a bus stop at that location. MR. HADU: Good -- my question about the bus stop to you would be would it be on the east side or the west side of the street, because --

Page 21

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 75 MR. MORONSKI: I can on -- I can only speak to the application where my client is -- has control over the land. And ultimately, where buses -- where bus stops are going to be would be up to the respective operator. MR. HADU: My question would be for the safety of, like, just for instance, if someone worked at Crestmont Country Club and they were coming up Eagle Rock Avenue, they’d be on the other side of the road. I was just wondering how they would get across the street. If there no sidewalks on that side of the street, how they would cross to get to the Crestmont street. So basically, the -- if they were coming in on a bus, they’d have to come from Roseland to get off onto the Crestmont side of the street. They couldn’t come up from Pleasant Valley Way, there would be no way for them to cross the street. MR. MORONSKI: I don’t know, because one, we don’t control that side of the street and number two, this is a hypothetical situation because as of today, there is no bus stop planned on either side of the street. And this application, we can only address our -- our side of Eagle Rock Avenue. MR. HADU: Okay. Thank you.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 76 MR. MORONSKI: Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Both people with their hands up have already spoken. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Sorry. I said before, you get one shot at the experts tonight, there are so many things to do. But thank you very much for asking. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Seeing no other hands. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: One more time. Do any other members of the public have any questions for Mr. Moronski on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. Seeing none. Thank you, Mr. Moronski. MR. MORONSKI: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: We’re going to take a 10- minute break. (Board takes brief recess.) CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: There you are. Mr. Schkolnick, I have a question for you. This is only an exit. Is that correct? It is not an entrance.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy

Page 21

AGOFF: There you are. Mr. Schkolnick, I have a question for you. This is only an exit. Is that correct? It is not an entrance.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 77 MR. SCHKOLNICK: Correct. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I just want that clear so before Mr. Sly was talking about it, there’s no possibility of somebody crossing the road from the left side from going -- from going westerly to go into Crestmont because this is only an exit. Is that correct? MR. SCHKOLNICK: The way I understand it as the lawyer. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Well, I looked at the -- I looked at the plans. It looks like this is only an exit. MR. SCHKOLNICK: That -- that, I believe is accurate. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Because I think his questions in my mind were a little unclear was why would people do that, and they wouldn’t do that because it’s only an exit. Okay. That makes it a little clearer in my head. Okay. Mr. Schkolnick, you have the floor. MR. SCHKOLNICK: We rest our case, Sir. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: No more witnesses. Do you want to sum up? MS. McGOVERN: No. We have -- I think the objectors have --1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy / Steck - Direct 78 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Okay. Mr. Turteltaub? MR. TURTELTAUB: Good evening and again, thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the board for your time tonight. I intend to call Peter Steck tonight, initially for an issue that has come up in our review of the application. It is only going to be brief testimony by Mr. Steck and then I’m going to reserve him for his planning testimony after we have John Linson, who will be testifying with regards to the steep slopes and the removal of the trees. So if I could first have Mr. Steck elevated as -- to a panelist. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Absolutely. ZOOM OPERATOR: Okay. He’ll be in in just a second. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Sure. ZOOM OPERATOR: There we go. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. Steck, welcome. MR. STECK: Thank you. MR. TURTELTAUB: Good evening, Mr. Steck. For -- if you could, for the benefit of the public and for the board, I’d like to qualify him as an expert in planning. Could you please give the board a brief summary of your credentials, Sir?

Page 22

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Steck - Direct 79 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. Turteltaub, Mr. Steck -- MR. TURTELTAUB: Yes. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: -- is well-known to the planning board and the township of West Orange. He has testified before us numerous times. His reputation is exemplary and I just have one question. Is your license in -- in good standing in the state of New Jersey at this time, Sir? MR. STECK: It is. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you so much. Go right ahead, Mr. Turteltaub. DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TURTELTAUB: Q Mr. Steck, tonight you’ve been hearing testimony with regards to the application of the Crestmont Country Club, an application to modify their driveways and parking areas. Correct? A That’s correct. Q Okay. And in doing your review, did you review the property as a whole that’s involved in this application? A I did. Q Okay. And can you give the board the benefit A Okay. If you read the plans, read the application form, the applicant has identified the property as1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Steck - Direct 80 Block 1.01 -- excuse me, Lot 1.01 in Block 174, which property is entirely in the Township of West Orange. If you look at the applicant's exhibits, as well as any aerial photo, you will note that the golf course itself extends, in my opinion, both into Livingston and to Roseland. Two of the fairways extend into Livingston and occupy, in Livingston, Lot 7, in Block 2,300. There is also a portion of the -- of a fairway and a pond that extends into Roseland, which is Lot 1 in Block 55. These are integral parts of the golf course and in my opinion, they are integral to the subject property. The reason that's significant is when the applicant requested from both Livingston and Roseland when they requested a property -- a list of property owners within 200 feet, they did not make that request from either, in Livingston, Lot 7 in Block 2300, nor did they make the request in Roseland from Lot 1 in Block 55. In my opinion, since they are integral parts of the golf course, they -- golfers golf on parts of those properties, they are part and parcel of the applicant's property and the 200-foot line that indicates who is required to get public notice extends further into both Livingston and Roseland than was identified by the applicant, because the applicant did not, in

Page 22

erty and the 200-foot line that indicates who is required to get public notice extends further into both Livingston and Roseland than was identified by the applicant, because the applicant did not, in requesting1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Steck - Direct 81 a certified list -- not identify the extension of the golf course into both of those municipalities. So there are a number of property owners, both in Livingston and Roseland that did not get public notice of this application. In my opinion, that is a jurisdictional issue, and I'll let the attorneys argue about it. Q I'll -- I'll raise the issue formally, but yes. A But -- but the answer is there are -- if -- I looked at the affida -- the lists that were on the municipal website, the requests for, you know, 200-foot notice lists, and it's clear that these additional properties were not given notice. And in my opinion, that is a significant issue, because the property and the active golf course does extend into these two properties, and it's used as a unit. And the fact that the applicant is artificially confining the notice determination to just the West Orange property, in my opinion, is incorrect. Q Mr. Steck, did you have an exhibit that -- or did you have a drawing that you showed where these parcels are? A Yes, I --if -- if -- let's see if I can share my screen. Let's see if I can do this. Okay. Is that a1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Steck - Direct 82 map on the screen? Q Yes. A Okay. So, on the -- the dark black lines are the municipal property lines. And so the -- SECRETARY VITE: Sorry. Mr. Steck, are we presenting this as an exhibit? MR. TURTELTAUB: Yes. I'm sorry. We can -- we can do that as 01. SECRETARY VITE: How -- how we name it -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yeah. Can you -- can you describe it, the date that it was -- MR. TURTELTAUB: Yes. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: -- made, who made it, and so on and so forth. MR. TURTELTAUB: Okay. THE WITNESS: This is a 2020 satellite photo from the NJ DEP geo website where they superimpose lot lines and lot and block numbers on the aerial photograph. I have enhanced it by, in black, showing municipal property lines; in orange, by highlighting the dimensions of the two lots in Livingston and Roseland where the golf course extends and I have approximated in blue the new limits of the 200-foot notice

Page 22

property lines; in orange, by highlighting the dimensions of the two lots in Livingston and Roseland where the golf course extends and I have approximated in blue the new limits of the 200-foot notice line. So, just to graphically talk about this, on

Page 23

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Steck - Direct 83 the right-hand side is the -- is a portion of Lot 1.01 in West Orange. Again, the only lot that is identified by the applicant as the subject property. As you can see in the lower part of this exhibit -- and this is an infrared photo, so the trees tend to disappear, but you see the grass shows up in kind of a solid red color in the fairways. You can see that there is a hole and two fairways that extend onto Lot 7 in Block 2,300 in Livingston, and you can see that there is a fairway that extends onto Lot 1 in lot -- Block 55 in Roseland. So in my opinion, because these are used as part of the golf course, they are part of the subject property. And in blue, I’ve approximated a 200-foot limit and I’ve listed -- I -- in bold black the additional lots that in my opinion should have been given notice. So, for example, in Block 54, there are a number of lots on the far side of Laurel. In Block 49, there are additional lots and in Livingston, there are five lots which in my -- in my review of the record were not given notice, five or six lots, not given notice. And in -- in -- and that’s a -- in my opinion, a -- a major deficiency because of the requirements of the Municipal Land Use Law in order for the board to have jurisdiction.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 84 Q Thank you very much, Mr. Steck. MR. TURTELTAUB: At this point, I would like to defer any additional testimony for Mr. Steck until after Mr. Linson but first would like to raise an objection as to jurisdiction on the issue of notice. Based on Mr. -- and again, I don’t know if the board would like to question Mr. -- Mr. Steck on this, but in looking at the application itself, there are -- there are three parcels that make up the Crestmont Country Club, and those being the ones that were cited by Mr. Steck. And what I’d like to do is I’m going to share if I could with the board the 200-foot lists that were requested from Livingston and from -- from Roseland, neither of which indicate that the properties -- you know, the only property that’s listed is the West Orange property in terms of what was being sought in terms of the -- of the 200-foot list. And if I may share my screen with you, we have here the request -- the certified list of owners, township of Livingston. It’s just

Page 23

rms of what was being sought in terms of the -- of the 200-foot list. And if I may share my screen with you, we have here the request -- the certified list of owners, township of Livingston. It’s just block 174, Lot 1.01 in West Orange. That’s the only lot that was within the 200-foot list that was requested. And that’s what the response was for. So it did not capture the full 200 feet within Livingston Township, nor was1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 85 publication made in the Livingston official newspaper. It was -- it was -- and there’s no certification to that in this -- in this regard. If I may, I’m going to bring up Roseland right now. And again, these are all within the files that are on -- on the board’s website because this is where I got these from. We now have Mr. Esposito, the assessors list that was provided, which again, only lists Bloc 174, Lot 1.10 as being the property from which the 200-foot list was being obtained. And again -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: Chairman, I will -- Chairman, to save time, I’ll stipulate that the 200- foot list request was made from the properties that have disturbance and where activity is being made. I do object to Mr. Steck’s expertise. This is strictly a legal issue. I don’t know why it’s a planning issue, but I think it should be decided at some later time. Mr. Turteltaub could write a letter, I’ll respond. We’ll cite any case law for this proposition that the golf course is used as a unit because there’s some fairways thousands of feet away and different -- on a different tax lot, these are different tax lots in Livingston and Roseland where no disturbance is taking place.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 86 So if -- if Mr. Turteltaub or Mr. Steck have legal authority for their proposition, I invite them to provide it. I don’t think we should be spending time here. We’ve had three hearings already where the board has accepted jurisdiction. They accepted jurisdiction, which includes notice, in June. And so I don’t think we should be spending time. Mr. Turteltaub can submit a letter and we could decide it an appropriate time. It’s a strict legal issue, and I suggest this is -- you know, if they have authority for it, that’s fine, but I don’t think we should be using valuable time to discuss a legal issue about notice when the board’s

Page 23

ct legal issue, and I suggest this is -- you know, if they have authority for it, that’s fine, but I don’t think we should be using valuable time to discuss a legal issue about notice when the board’s accepted jurisdiction June -- five months ago. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Well, Mr. Schkolnick, it’s a very interesting issue. This has happened before in West Orange and I’m going to ask Ms. McGovern -- so we can do two things, which is one, the applicant moves forward at its own peril based on a letter from Mr. Turteltaub and we look at exactly how notice should be done. I will tell you that for applications that we’ve had, we -- it was the representation that notice was for the entire property. Now you’re telling us that notice was for the disturbed areas. I -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: Tax lot 200 -- I’m at -- I’m

File revisions (1)