Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026
Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index
61cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9Indexed text
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 87 required to -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: 200 feet. 200 feet around the disturbed area. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Any tax lot -- any tax lot that is being disturbed, that’s the subject parcel of this application. They -- Mr. Steck and Mr. Turteltaub refer to Livingston Block 2300, Lot 7 and Roseland Lot 55, I didn’t get the block. We are not disturbing any -- any lands at all. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I -- I understand. I understand what you’re saying. MR. SCHKOLNICK: So this -- this is a novel concept of used as a unit when it’s a separate tax lot in another municipality. And I -- if they have a case law that says that, that I’m required, then we’ll see if it’s binding, but I highly doubt -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. MR. SCHKOLNICK: -- that they’re going to produce case law -- because they would have if they could have. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Well, I -- at this point, I want to err on the side of conservativeness, but I want to hear what Ms. McGovern has to say and we may just continue on the application, which -- MS. McGOVERN: Well, I’m -- I’m in the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 88 process of trying to find that describes specifically what the notice requirement is, to begin there, because -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: NJ 40: -- NJ 40:55D-12. It’s the property that’s the subject of the application. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. We’re going to -- we‘re going to hold that in abeyance while Ms. McGovern looks -- MS. McGOVERN: Yeah. I -- I don’t want to -- I’m -- this is an important question and I don’t want to rush this, so -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Right. MS. McGOVERN: I think we either proceed at -- as the -- the chairman indicated, to move this along at your own risk for fear that this whole thing has to be started over again. Oh, God. Or that we look at it and it appears to be okay in my opinion or our -- however it’s framed. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: We’re going to -- we’re going to move forward based on opinions. MS. McGOVERN: Okay. Okay. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: And -- and we will hold all things based on opinions, but go right ahead. We’ll -- let’s move forward, Mr. Turteltaub. We hear what Mr.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 89 Steck says and Ms. McGovern will be our final evaluator on this, eventually. MR. SCHKOLNICK: We -- and just so I can clarify where we go
8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 89 Steck says and Ms. McGovern will be our final evaluator on this, eventually. MR. SCHKOLNICK: We -- and just so I can clarify where we go from here because I also do have, for instance, to show the -- even though it -- even though it may cover three -- three municipalities, it is one property and in fact, I have a copy of mortgage and/or other documents that they have used where they cite the title for the property as being one, albeit in three different properties -- three different municipalities. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. You -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: So Chairman, the proper way -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. -- Mr. -- wait. Let -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: The proper way to handle this -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. Schkolnick, go right ahead. MS. McGOVERN: Okay. MR. SCHKOLNICK: The proper way, if mis -- if Mr. Turteltaub has legal support for this property concept as opposed to a tax lot concept, let him submit that to the board. Why hasn’t he already? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: It’s okay. It’s okay.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy 90 We’re here. Ms. McGovern? MS. McGOVERN: I’m looking at 40:55D-12 and it says in section (b), “Except as provided in paragraph 2 of subsection (h), notice of a hearing required public notice pursuant to section (a) of this section shall be given to the owners of all real property as shown on the current dax -- tax duplicate,” and here’s the key, “located in the state within 200 feet in all directions of the property which is the subject of the hearing.” MR. SCHKOLNICK: And we’re in -- the subject of this hearing is the tax lot in West Orange. It’s -- we would have to go to Livingston or go to Roseland at -- if we needed it. Say, for example, there was a road through Livingston or Roseland. We would have to go those towns and -- MS. McGOVERN: Okay. So -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: -- and the lists would be different. I just had this case because I was on the border of two towns and there were different lists for different towns. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: So what we’re going to do -- MR. SCHKOLNICK: So this -- MS. McGOVERN: I need to do --
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy / Linson - Direct 91 MR. SCHKOLNICK: Just used as a -- MS. McGOVERN: -- more in-depth research. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. MS. McGOVERN: I -- I think -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yes. MS. McGOVERN: -- we need to -- to look at the case law. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yeah. Mr. Schkolnick, Mr. Turteltaub, Ms. McGovern is going to look at the case, not right now and get back to us and where the board is going to move forward with the rest of the testimony, but the applicant understands they move ahead at their own peril. MR. TURTELTAUB: I thank the board for listening to this and at this time, I’d like to reserve further testimony of Mr. Steck until after Mr. Linson, who I’d like to have promoted to a panelist. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Go right ahead. MR. TURTELTAUB: Mr. Linson, if you could raise your hand to make sure they can find you? ZOOM OPERATOR: I found him. Just give me one second. MR. TURTELTAUB: Okay. Thank you. ZOOM OPERATOR: There we go. You’re -- You’re in, Mr. Linson.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 92 MR. LINSON: All right. I -- I think I’m there. Can you hear me? (Zoom operator works out technical difficulties.) MS. McGOVERN: Please raise your right hand. Could you please raise your right hand? MR. LINSON: Okay. J O H N L I N S O N, OBJECTOR’S WITNESS, SWORN MS. McGOVERN: Please put your name on the record and then Mr. Turteltaub, you can continue. MR. TURTELTAUB: Mr. Linson, just -- just your name for the record. MR. LINSON: It’s John Linson, L-I-N-S-O-N. MS. McGOVERN: Thank you. DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TURTELTAUB: Q And Mr. Linson, by whom are you employed? A By whom am I what? Q Employed. A Oh. Employed. I’m -- I’m self-employed. I’m a consultant. Q And what do you consult in? A I’m a tree expert. I have been a New Jersey licensed tree expert for 50 years. Q And as a tree expert, what -- do you have any specific training to be a tree expert? A Well, I have a four-year college degree in1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 93 forestry and I passed the New Jersey certified tree expert exam in 1976, and they have converted that over to be called a licensed tree expert. So, I -- I’ve worked in municipal arboriculture for 48 years of the 50 years that I’ve been a licensed tree expert. I -- I worked for
they have converted that over to be called a licensed tree expert. So, I -- I’ve worked in municipal arboriculture for 48 years of the 50 years that I’ve been a licensed tree expert. I -- I worked for Millburn Township for 25 years and retired, started my own consulting business. I worked as a consultant for West Orange for 14 years. I’m still actively -- I’ve worked for -- as a consultant for 45 municipalities in three counties. Q And is your current license with the state of New Jersey valid? A Yes. Number 198. Q 198. Very good. MR. TURTELTAUB: I’d like to introduce Mr. Linson as a tree expert. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Unless any member of the board has any questions, Mr. Linson, we accept you as a tree expert in the state of New Jersey. Go right ahead, Sir. BY MR. TURTELTAUB: Q Mr. Linson, are you familiar with the property known as the Crestmont Country Club? A I’m familiar with the property. I’m not familiar1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 94 with the owners. Q Okay. With the property. We’re here to talk about the property. A I’m familiar with the property, but not the owners. Q And we’re here for a site plan application. Have you had a chance to review the plans that are being proposed here for -- for Crestmont Country Club? A Yes. I’ve looked at the proposed tree removals and the proposed planting plans. Q Okay. And did you form any opinions with respect to what you reviewed? A Yes. You know, West Orange has probably the strictest tree protection ordinance in the state of New Jersey and as I read through the purpose and intent of the -- of the ordinance in the very beginning, it seems that this application conflicts with a number of the purposes and -- and intent of the tree preservation ordinance itself. Q What -- what in particular did you find that it violates? A Well, if I can read from -- from the ordinance itself, 28-2(c), “The purpose of this article is to protect and foster the existence and health of trees growing within the township’s borders, to preserve the
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 95 maximum possible number of trees in the development of a site or lot, to protect specimen trees, to encourage innovative design and grading to promote the protection of existing trees and to prevent indiscriminate, uncontrolled, and excessive removal and cutting of trees as well as land use activities inconsistent with accepted arboricultural practices. And it goes on and on a little bit more than that, but in the ordinance, it specifically -- I’m going through the ordinance and turning the pages, as you can see. There are specific prohibitions in this ordinance. 28-4(b), number four: cut down or remove any tree on a slope with a grade of 10 percent or greater on a slope where vegetation is presently stabilizing soils. So, we have that -- Q Is -- is that -- is that true in this situation? A The construction of the sidewalk and the retaining wall is -- is an intrusion into the steep slopes. And this -- it’s a prohibition, so. Se -- number seven, remove trees within 100 feet of a ridge line. I think that -- that applies. Number nine, remove trees if tree removal will negatively alter existing drainage patterns and stormwater runoff. Well, that’s true.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 96 Number 10, remove tree if it will result in soil erosion. Well, the existing trees along Eagle Rock Avenue are stabilizing that -- those slopes, so in order to construct a wall and a sidewalk, you have -- physically have to remove the stumps of -- of all of those trees. Number 11, remove trees if it would increase the amount of stormwater runoff and/or negatively affect stormwater runoff patterns on any lots, whether con -- contiguous or not. Number 12, remove trees if it would constitute a significant change in the screening between existing or proposed structures on roads and/or adjacent lots. Number 13, I’m -- again, prohibitions. Remove trees where it would alter topography of the area where such trees are located and will create conditions which may be injurious to the trees or other trees located nearby. And I’ll refer to this later, but in that whole area, there’s only -- or where there’s 313 trees being removed, there’s only about 60 trees that would be saved. And by changing the grading and everything, it’s questionable whether those 60
at whole area, there’s only -- or where there’s 313 trees being removed, there’s only about 60 trees that would be saved. And by changing the grading and everything, it’s questionable whether those 60 trees that are surrounded by -- by improvements would actually survive.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 97 So -- and 14, remove trees where it would impair suitable habitats and migratory zones for endangered or threatened species or animals. And -- so those are -- those are specific prohibitions in the ordinance which I see this -- see a conflict with this application. And basically, you’re supposed to -- if you -- if you look at just the specific area where all the activity is -- is going to take place, 313 trees to come down. Well, only -- only 82 of those actually involve the parking area and the construction of the -- of the exit driveway onto Eagle Rock Avenue. Sixty of the tree -- tree removals have to do with the bio barriers, the retention basins. So if we could eliminate the bio basins and -- and put rete -- retention tanks within the parking lot area or within the roadway, we could right off the bat save 60 trees. And then -- so doing the math, I’m subtracting 80 and 60 from the 313. That means that 171 trees have to be removed to construct the wall and the sidewalk. So -- a sidewalk that is questionable of whether it’s really necessary or not. So -- at any rate, so that’s sort of what I’m -- what I’m seeing with this application, that -- that it’s -- it’s quite contrary to -- to the purposes and1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 98 intent of our -- of the tree preservation ordinance, which again, I say it’s -- it’s one of the strictest in the state and it just seems that there’s so many departures from that that it -- it’s questionable. You know, it seems to me, you -- you can still build a parking lot and you can still have the exit driveway by only removing 82 trees, not 313 trees. Also, I question the math in calculating the replacements. Now, the -- the gathering of information was supposed to be done by a licensed tree expert. I think it was done by a landscape architect, which is contrary to the -- to the ordinance. It has to be done by a New Jersey licensed tree expert. And all those Xs you see on the -- to be removed, well there should be a number
ndscape architect, which is contrary to the -- to the ordinance. It has to be done by a New Jersey licensed tree expert. And all those Xs you see on the -- to be removed, well there should be a number next to all of those Xs that refers back to a table that says this is the diameter of this tree, it’s 12 inches in diameter, it’s a red maple. And there should be a column that says is it -- is it a viable tree or is it a non-viable tree? And that’s very important in doing the calculations. So the table they’ve presented cannot really be -- be scrutinized by somebody who is familiar with the process of -- of identifying trees and -- and tabulating these tables. I’ve done a couple of them for other applications in -- in West Orange and, you
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 99 know, I -- I -- I’m skeptical about the math that -- that went into this and -- and I’m skeptical into who collected the data, if it was an engineer or a surveyor, a landscape architect, it doesn’t comply with the statute of being a licensed tree expert that’s embodied into your ordinance. So that -- that pretty much summarizes what I had to say about the application. It just seems that if -- if we’re striving to minimize the impact on the trees in West Orange, well, we -- we can construct the added driveway -- driveway exit and -- and parking spaces by only taking down 82 trees instead of 313 trees if we can -- we can put storm -- stormwater collection into tanks within those disturbed areas. You know, the -- the trees on the steep slope are -- they do provide great screening, wildlife habitat. About a year ago, I was driving up Eagle Rock Avenue and going towards Roseland and I -- I saw this -- this big bird flying up the -- right over the road. It was a bald eagle. And it -- and it turned and went into Essex -- Essex Fells County Club. But there is a lot of wildlife in the area and by -- by removing 313 trees, it -- and replacing them with -- I mean, there’s a movement to replace with -- and the -- and the landscape list is heavily balanced on --1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 100 on putting natives back in, which is a good thing. But -- but still, you know, the trees that are there provide terrific canopy coverage and that’s one of the purposes of having a tree protection ordinance, is we want to protect our -- our canopy coverage. It’s -- it’s a hedge against global warming and -- and climate change and removing 100-foot trees that have been there for 100 years, replacing them, you know, with -- with two-inch caliper, four-inch caliper trees that are 20 feet tall, it doesn’t -- it doesn’t provide the same -- same benefit as what -- what we have already. Q So, in working with tree ordinances over the years, let’s -- let’s talk about the habitat. Does -- does the loss of habitat for different species that live in these trees provide a benefit or a detriment to the area? A Well, you know, they do, you know, provide -- I mean, 280 is right -- right around the corner, and the filtration of carbon -- carbon dioxide, the
trees provide a benefit or a detriment to the area? A Well, you know, they do, you know, provide -- I mean, 280 is right -- right around the corner, and the filtration of carbon -- carbon dioxide, the process of turning it into oxygen, which we all appreciate, those trees provide a great benefit, and also, you know, habitat for -- for birds and -- and mammals. So it -- you know, the replacement -- and then all the new trees you have to plant, you have to put protection that they don’t get devoured by -- by the deer that are present1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 101 on the -- on the property, so -- so we have a balance right now. Not to say all those trees in -- in the existing buffer don’t need some work. They’ve never been maintained. There are some trees in there that are -- that are not viable and -- and should be removed, or pruned to correct defects that -- that could be potential safety hazards. But still, they’re -- the trees are there -- that are there are much more beneficial to the environment than -- than anything that we could -- we could re-plant. Q The -- the applicant proposes re-planting a certain number of trees. Do those trees provide the same type of habitat for the wildlife that’s there today? A Well, you know, basically, what we -- a big consideration of re-planting with native trees is -- is, you know, the -- the insects and the birds that are attracted to the -- to the trees and they obtain sustenance off of the trees, the fruit, the insects that are attracted to them, and the habitat that is provided for squirrels in cavities of trees and raccoons and, you know, and deer browsing on under -- undergrowth. So not to say that the replacement trees won’t1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 102 provide any benefit, but they will not provide an equivalent benefit for many, many years, until -- until there’s some kind of a balance. And -- and basically, we have -- we have existing under-story that would not be replaced by the -- by landscaping, so. And, you know, just disturbance of the soil, drainage patterns. You know, I -- I really question whether the -- the trees that would be “preserved” within this area really would survive, based upon the amount of disturbance that’s -- that’s surrounding them. And -- and, you know, they do cite on there,
r the -- the trees that would be “preserved” within this area really would survive, based upon the amount of disturbance that’s -- that’s surrounding them. And -- and, you know, they do cite on there, you know, we’re going to protect the trees and everything, but, you know, once you change a water table on a tree that’s 100 years old, they’re -- they’re not going to be happy. So -- and then just to acclimate the -- the new landscaping, you -- you need to do a complete watering for at least two seasons until -- until the trees get acclimated. And, you know, most likely, a trickle irrigation system, a permanent trickle irrigation system installed for the new trees would not be a bad idea. Q With respect to the tree ordinance itself, when you -- when you were working for the town, or when you work for towns, do you review tree plans -- tree
File revisions (1)
- Nov 20, 2026
61cfd83a303f413,643 bytes