Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-25661cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9

Indexed text

Page 31

sses, the concerns you've raised. MR. LINSON: I have not seen that, and you know, if -- if a sidewalk is, is necessary, if the walls are necessary, it's just basically within that little area, I mean, we're supposed to be -- in the ordinance -- you know, let's just say this was a single building lot, this whole area. You know, we’re -- if1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 117 it's a single building lot, you're supposed to save 50 percent of the trees on that property. Within this area, what they're proposing to do is to remove 80 percent of the trees in that area, and only saving 20 percent, if they go with the bio- basins and -- and the -- the wall. MR. ALPER: Got it. Okay. I think that's all for me. Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. In answer to your question, Mr. Alper, the application goes to the forester, you have no comment. So -- and trees, remember, is out of Chapter 25, so whatever we discuss has to go to the forester for his opinion and discussion, just for the record. Mr. Wilkes, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. WILKES: No. No questions at this time. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Mr. Klein, do you have any questions for Mr. Rin -- Wilson -- Linson on his testimony? Sorry. MR. KLEIN: Well, I don't know if it's a question for Mr. Linson or just a comment that it sounds like there is a way to save a lot more trees if they do the bio-retention underneath the parking lot, instead of where they're doing it. I'm assuming it's cheaper to do it the way they're proposing it right1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 118 now. The sidewalk, that's kind of a dilemma. Like you said, we're going to rip down trees so people can walk, but they're not going to be walking there? I don't know what to do about the sidewalk. So, yeah. No. I don’t have any questions. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Thank you. We'll discuss that. Mr. Morgan, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. MORGAN: No questions at this time, Mr. Chairman. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Deputy Chief Noborine, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. NOBORINE: I do not, Mr. Chairman, thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Ms. Kapferer, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MS. KAPFERER: Thank you, Chairman. Yeah, just one

Page 31

MR. NOBORINE: I do not, Mr. Chairman, thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Ms. Kapferer, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MS. KAPFERER: Thank you, Chairman. Yeah, just one question. Thank you, Mr. Linson, for your testimony. Is there -- can you talk a bit about specimen trees, and whether -- I don't know if you're able to observe whether there would be any here, or just have knowledge of that from your experience in --

Page 32

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 119 in West Orange, but do you know if that's an issue here at all? MR. LINSON: What kind of trees are you -- I'm sorry. MS. KAPFERER: Specimen. Specimen trees? MR. LINSON: Oh, specimen trees. MS. KAPFERER: Yeah. MR. LINSON: Well, yeah. You -- West Orange does have specimen trees, and they have -- they have some state records. But, you know, basically the term specimen tree usually would be simply that a tree is experiencing, all of the favorable characteristics of a mature tree. So, it doesn't have to be the largest tree in New Jersey, but it just has to be in good condition, and, you know, we -- we had thought -- when I was working for the town, we had thought of compiling a list of, like, landmark trees throughout -- throughout the town, and, like, Llewellyn Park has some magnificent beech trees. It actually has a state record. American Hornbeam, on Bloomfield Way, that I found, and we registered it with the state. So, in this particular section, there are trees that are -- are large and -- and in good condition, that, you know, could -- could qualify as a1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 120 specimen tree, but, but are not necessarily, you know, the largest tree in West Orange. There's nothing -- nothing like that on the site. There were some, like, over at the public -- public service site, there were some spectacular trees over there that really were -- were candidates for the largest trees in -- of that species in -- in the town, but, I did not, you know, from my cursory, you know, walk up -- up Eagle Rock Avenue, looking into the property, you know, I saw some nice, large, mature trees, but, you know, nothing that, you know, that was -- Spectacular, you know, but -- but nice trees, that provided valuable screening. But -- but nothing that, you know, that -- that is going to break any -- any state records. MS. KAPFERER: All right. That -- that's it for me. Thank you so much. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Ms. Apte, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MS. APTE: No, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Mr. Valesi, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. VALESI: No questions. Thank you, Mr. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Do any members of the public have any questions for

Page 32

ank you. Mr. Valesi, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. VALESI: No questions. Thank you, Mr. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Do any members of the public have any questions for Mr. Linson on his1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 121 testimony? Please raise your hand. Please have the best questions because you get one shot at this. You get three minutes. MS. McGOVERN: Do you want to ask Mr. Schkolnick. If he wanted -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Oh. I'm sorry. Mr. Schkolnick. I’m sorry, I bypassed you. Mr. Schkolnick, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. SCHKOLNICK: Thank you. Ju -- just two or three. CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. SCHKOLNICK: Q Mr. Linson, you’re -- you're not a licensed civil engineer, are you? A No. Q You're not presenting yourself to the board as an expert in stormwater design, are you? Q I am not. Q Okay. A Or traffic. Q Have you -- okay. Have you evaluated NJ DEP regulations as to whether underground storage tanks are viable in this particular situation? A Not my area. Q Excuse me?1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 122 A It's a suggestion. Q Can you say that again? A It's not my area of expertise. Q It's not -- so stormwater design and whether underground tanks are actually viable is not your area, that's your testimony? A My area of expertise is saving trees and planting trees. Q We appreciate that. Do you know if the NJDP regulations allow underground storage tanks when infiltration is not available? Do you have any knowledge of those regulations one way or the other? A No, I have no percolation rates and things like that. That's not me. That's somebody else. Q Okay. So, just assuming my client would like to save as many trees as possible, you don't, as we sit here tonight, have any expert knowledge of whether an underground storage tank is viable in this situation under NJDEP regulations? A My -- my comment was just -- Q Yes or no, Sir? Yes or no? A I have no knowledge of that. Q All right. Thank you for your time, Sir. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you, Mr. Schkolnick.

Page 33

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 123 Do any members of the public have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. You’ll have three minutes, and you can only ask three minutes, one time. ZOOM OPERATOR: Paul, please state your name and address for the record. Paul, please un-mute. Mr. Tractenberg? MR. TRACTENBERG: Paul Tractenberg, 96 Sullivan Drive. Mr. Linson, thanks so much for your coherent and responsive testimony. I have a couple of questions returning to the tree ordinance. Are you aware that the applicant has proposed to remove 191 trees from steep slopes of 10 percent or greater? MR. LINSON: Where did you get the 191 from? MR. TRACTENBERG: From Mr. Schkolnick's letter from I think March of this year. MR. LINSON: Oh. I hadn't seen -- I haven't seen that letter. MR. TRACTENBERG: If I can read you the sentence, he says, “Applicant also requests a site plan waiver from Section 28-4.4 -- b.4, removal of trees of slopes of 10 percent or greater, 191 trees proposed to be removed.” I'm assuming from what you said earlier, but I hope you can either confirm or correct, that you read1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 124 the tree prohibition section of the tree ordinance as barring the removal of any trees that meet the prescription there, one of which is, as you reported earlier, slopes of 10 percent or greater. MR. LINSON: Yes. MR. TRACTENBERG: So, if I understand, that would mean that unless there are trees that are not, able to survive, that those 191 trees ought not to be removed, consistent with the prohibition. Is -- am I reading you correctly? MR. LINSON: Well, basically, as I said, you know, the -- the table that they provided was -- was insufficient. We actually want to see the diameter and the species and whether they're viable or non-viable. And that information wasn't provided. So assuming they’re -- they were all viable trees, you know, that would be, you know, I mean, it's -- that would be an excessive, amount of removals, to, you know, for what they want. They -- they want to create -- is it 14 parking spaces and the exit driveway? You know, it doesn't require, you know, 313 trees to be removed. MR. TRACTENBERG: So, my -- my question's more focused and narrow. It is to the extent the

Page 33

s it 14 parking spaces and the exit driveway? You know, it doesn't require, you know, 313 trees to be removed. MR. TRACTENBERG: So, my -- my question's more focused and narrow. It is to the extent the 191 trees they propose to remove from slopes of 10 percent or greater are all viable, do I understand you read the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 125 ordinance as prohibiting the removal of all -- MR. LINSON: Yeah. I -- I just see -- see that as -- as being totally pro -- prohibited and -- from the -- from the ordinance. There's -- there's no -- there can really be no -- no waiver of that requirement. MR. TRACTENBERG: Now, one related question. Section 28-6 of the tree ordinance, I'll read you a sentence and then ask you if you could tell me whether you've seen anything that satisfies this requirement. It says in connection with a development application, an applicant shall file a written report by a qualified tree expert explaining how, why the prohibitions set forth in the section we've been talking about are not violated. Did you see anything, representing that kind of written report showing that -- MR. LINSON: No. I -- I -- I actually underlined that in my copy of the ordinance. I -- I have -- I suspect that -- that -- that the -- all of the analysis of the trees on the site were done by a landscape architect, because I don't see any reference to -- a qualified tree expert by definition in the ordinance has to be a New Jersey licensed tree expert registered with the Board of Tree Experts, and I do not1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 126 see any reference to that on -- on any of the plans that were provided to me. MR. TRACTENBERG: Mr. Linson, thank you for the answers. I appreciate them, and I have no further questions. MR. LINSON: Okay. ZOOM OPERATOR: You're muted, Chairman. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: -- read my lips. Do any members of the public have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? Please raise your hand and be identified. ZOOM OPERATOR: Joe P., please state your name and address for the record. MR. PANNULLO: Joseph Pannullo, Holton Lane, Essex Fells. Mr. Linson, nice to meet you. A couple of questions on a few things you said. Describing, I think it was 171 trees removed to make sidewalks and walls, do you know the -- the diameter of

Page 33

Essex Fells. Mr. Linson, nice to meet you. A couple of questions on a few things you said. Describing, I think it was 171 trees removed to make sidewalks and walls, do you know the -- the diameter of the old growth trees? Are they healthy trees? Any idea of ballpark percentage? Are they savable? Why take them out? MR. LINSON: Well, what you're saying -- you know, basically a number of those trees are actually within the county right of way and the county, Essex County, would have to approve that, as they would also

Page 34

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 127 have to approve other aspects of this application. But no, the -- for the most part, those are all healthy trees because they’re very conspicuous. When you drive past the site, you can see, they all have leaves on them and I didn’t see a single dead tree conspicuous to the -- from the road. MR. PANNULLO: Fair enough. So, for the number of trees that would be removed and then replaced, what’s your experience, if any, with regard to -- we’re on the top of the second Watchung Ridge here. I know there are steep slopes. They vary in degree, some more, some less than 10 percent. You mentioned within 100 feet of a ridge line. Do you have any experience in the viability of the trees that will be replanted when there are -- you take out X, you replace it with Y, you’re changing the water table, I think you made a statement about, the landscaping, the ground. We’re planting trees into shallow bedrock and volcanic basalt. Where -- how do those trees -- you may plant 597 or whatever. How many of those will actually take? MR. LINSON: Well, when -- if -- if the preparation has been proper, preparing the soil, you know, basically -- you know, we want quality soil. We don’t want just clay. You know, we want a high organic1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 128 matter. We want -- we don’t -- we want the water to move through there, there should be a good sand content, but up to -- up to a 10 percent loss -- you know, 90 percent survivability is -- is permissible in a landscape replacement. But in this case, you know, we’re -- we’re bean counters. And -- and if it says you’re going to replace 200 trees and, you know, only 180 survive, you -- you’ve got to replace those 20. So it’s --it’s 100 percent -- we’re looking for 100 percent survival on what ever is planted. And -- and basically, the planning board, if they’re -- when they approve a plan, that plan goes with the property. As long -- you know, any -- any application when the -- when the planning board approves screening between -- between commercial and residential use, if -- if a tree dies in that hedge, you know, between the properties, they have to replace it. And that’s continued on forever. So -- so whatever landscape plan -- as long as there’s a golf course there,

Page 34

-- if a tree dies in that hedge, you know, between the properties, they have to replace it. And that’s continued on forever. So -- so whatever landscape plan -- as long as there’s a golf course there, you know, they have to replace these trees. If they -- if they -- so survival is -- is very critical and irrigation, particularly in the first two years, is -- is critical. So, you know, it’s -- it’s -- the replacement -- the species they chose and everything, almost all of1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 129 them were native. So I -- I have no -- I don’t find any fault with -- with the -- the landscape plan. I just -- my fault is with the removal plan. I don’t want to have to replace them; I want to keep the ones we have already. MR. PANNULLO: Well, all -- all plans actually fail in theory in application, and my question becomes who is actually keeping an eye on or overseeing not putting clay, proper soil, proper maintenance, proper irrigation? Is that the town forester’s job? Who’s assigned that -- MR. LINSON: Well, one thing, I -- I review landscape plans for other municipalities, and particularly Roseland right now, I’ve been reviewing the -- the removal of the pres -- Prudential business campus on Becker’s Farm and replacement of -- with townhouses. And one thing I’m recommending to that planning board is that the applicant provides a landscape architect to oversee the installation of the plant material, and that would be from selecting the trees in the nursery before they’re dug to having a preconstruction meeting with the -- with the landscape contractor, examination of the planting beds and the back-fill material, and really, on-site supervision throughout the whole process. And that can be part of1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Public Question 130 the resolution from the planning board, guaranteeing that at least the installation goes in. And then, going forward with -- with survival, the -- you know, basically, we need -- West Orange has a great code enforcement department, so basically, the zoning officer, they have inspectors going out there, they notice stuff. And then you have Walt Kipp, your -- your forester, so. And there’s also a number of very, very gifted and talented and dedicated local residents who -- who drive around seeing issues that

Page 34

tice stuff. And then you have Walt Kipp, your -- your forester, so. And there’s also a number of very, very gifted and talented and dedicated local residents who -- who drive around seeing issues that need to be addressed and -- and they -- they bring it to the appropriate people to follow up on. So I’m confident that the -- you know, the landscaping that is installed would be -- would be supervised, but I would -- I would recommend to the planning board that they -- they include a resolution having the applicant provide on- side supervision by a New Jersey licensed landscape architect in regard to the selection of the material and approval of material before it goes in the ground and -- and the supervision of the installation. MR. PANNULLO: Unlike Roseland, West Orange has a full-time forester. Any reason that forester, Walter Kipp, wouldn’t have a role in making sure these things are complied with?

File revisions (1)