Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-25661cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9

Indexed text

Page 28

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 103 removal plans? A Yes. You know, basically, for a number of towns, I enforce their existing ordinances, none of which -- well, actually, I think Chatham Township’s probably gives West Orange a run for the money in terms of -- of how intense it is. It’s a seven-page application and it -- it’s very comprehensive, but they don’t go down to a four-inch diameter tree, which -- which West Orange does. Q In -- in your experience as -- you know, reviewing these plans, do you have enough information in the plans that are being presented by the applicant here to be able to make informed decisions as to what the total impact is going to be on -- the environmental impact of the removal of all these trees will be? A I have a pretty good idea of how it would go. And I, you know, I'm questioning the math in -- in the replacement, the number of replacement trees, because I -- there's not enough information to, to check the calculations and the tables, and -- and I -- I don't know -- I don't know who collected that data. Q So -- so without that data, can you make an informed decision then on on the impacts of what this tree removal plan will be? A Well, the -- I mean, basically, by removing trees1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 104 on the steep slope, I mean, that is -- it's prohibited. So, it's sort of, you know, when -- when West Orange revised this ordinance, they preserved in time the trees on steep slopes. And, you know, to -- to, you know, just not -- not pay any attention to that is really a disservice -- disservice to -- to the township -- township committee, town council, who -- who drafted this ordinance and passed this ordinance. So it just -- it doesn't stand a reason to allow for all of the removal of the trees on the steep slope. And they can still have the parking lot and the exit driveway by only removing 82 trees instead of, you know, the total 313 trees. So don't -- so you would be saving, you know, 200 and some-odd trees by -- by not doing the wall and sidewalk. Q Are you familiar with the PSE&G site on -- on Mount Pleasant? A Yes, I am. Q And Prospect? And are you aware of what happened there with respect to their initial plans and what ended up happening there? A Yeah. They -- they were going to be removing a lot of trees

Page 28

Yes, I am. Q And Prospect? And are you aware of what happened there with respect to their initial plans and what ended up happening there? A Yeah. They -- they were going to be removing a lot of trees up by Prospect itself, and the purpose of that was for water retention, and I believe they ended up putting the water retention into subsurface tanks1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 105 instead of having to remove trees to create a detention basin. Q And were they able to save a lot of trees then in that regard? A Yeah, and there were -- there were some big trees up -- there still are some huge trees up there. They lost a lot of ash trees, but so did everybody else in New Jersey when Emerald Ash Borer was brought in, but, you know, all trees need some kind of maintenance, and all trees have a -- have a life span. And when you -- you can't make them safe, they -- you know, they have be removed. I -- sometimes I have to remind some of these tree huggers that a person's safety is more important than an unsafe tree. I we can't make a tree safe, it's gotta go. But when we remove a tree, it's an opportunity to replace it and sustain the forest, urban forest. Q And ultimately, do you believe that the goals of the tree ordinance, the West Orange tree ordinance, which you've identified, in your opinion being stringent, are achieved by this plan that you're seeing here, being presented in this application? A Well, this -- you know, this proposal really violates just about everything -- everything that was1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 106 designed to be preserved in -- in the -- in the ordinance. So it -- it just -- it violates so many things. When -- you know, understandably, you know, to create more parking spaces and to create an exit driveway that is an improvement to traffic flow and safety of people exiting out onto the road, that can be -- that's a good thing, but it should be done to minimize the trees being removed, not maximizing the trees by building a wall and putting in a sidewalk that few people are going to use and creating other -- other issues that affect the surrounding community. So, the -- those -- the trees right now provide a great screening and buffer to the -- to the course and, you know, I -- I drive by there on a weekly basis and I would miss

Page 28

the surrounding community. So, the -- those -- the trees right now provide a great screening and buffer to the -- to the course and, you know, I -- I drive by there on a weekly basis and I would miss them. MR. TURTELTAUB: Very good. I have nothing further for Mr. Linson. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Vice-Chairman Guarino, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? VICE CHAIR GUARINO: Yes -- yes, I do, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. CROSS EXAMINATION BY VICE CHAIR GUARINO: Q Mr. Linson, how are you, Sir?

Page 29

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 107 A I’m doing all right for an old guy. Q Very good. A It’s nice to see, Jerry. Q I have a quick -- I have a quick question, Sir. Did you take a look at the trees that were being required to be removed? A Did I see marks -- marks on the trees, did you say? Q Have you -- have you gone up to the property and taken a look? A I’ve not been on the property, but I’ve been by the property. You know, I -- I actually parked on Oval and -- and walked the length of the -- of the property. Q Okay. So in your expert, Sir, from your -- what you were able to view, could you give an idea of what condition the trees were in, say, for example, you know, were they in need of, you know, treatment? Were they in need of trimming, removal, and situations like that, Sir? I’m just trying to get an idea of what -- A Well, and that’s -- that’s a good question, Jerry, because, you know, when we -- when we strive to preserve trees, we need to know that they’re safe. And basically, it -- it’s -- to be a good steward of the property, there should be periodic inspection of the trees and -- you know, the -- the possibility of trees1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 108 falling into Eagle Rock Avenue. So if -- if there’s trees that have defects, you know, the -- the entire grove of trees should be inspected by a licensed tree expert and the golf course should take remedial efforts to -- to keep them in a safe and viable condition. Q Thank you very much, Mr. Linson. It was good seeing you, Sir. A Okay. Good to see you, too. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Mr. Guarino, did he answer your question? I’m sorry. I thought the question was did you look at the trees and you answered a different question. I just want to be sure I’m -- I’m hearing the same thing. Was your question answered, or did he give you an answer that wasn’t your question? VICE CHAIR GUARINO: He -- thank you, Mr. Chairman. (Indiscernible) go on the property, but I’m sure he has to ask permission to go on the property. But I was trying to get an idea of his expertise. Did he have an idea or could he make an assumption that -- are the trees in good condition? Are any of the trees that are being requested to be removed, you know, are not in good health, they’re in need of treatment, they’re in need of trimming, they’re

Page 29

at -- are the trees in good condition? Are any of the trees that are being requested to be removed, you know, are not in good health, they’re in need of treatment, they’re in need of trimming, they’re in need of being removal. That’s what I was asking, Mr. Chairman, and I1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 109 think -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: I didn’t hear the answer to that question. I heard something else. MR. TURTELTAUB: But he -- he also answered that he had parked on Oval and walked along the property along Eagle Rock. That was part of his testimony, too. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Right. I understand that, but that wasn’t the question. The question was can he say how many trees or were salvageable and were not salvageable? I’m just asking to find out for the record if the question is -- well, I looked at it and I -- I can’t tell you exactly how many, but I picked out, on the other hand, 82, and I came up with the number 82 and this is based on your engineering skills, figuring that the roadway can be made -- I’m just trying to figure out where these numbers come from because if you didn’t -- if you weren’t -- didn’t ask to or you didn’t count the trees but you come up with 82 from 300 and something, I’m trying to figure -- listen. I’d love to save the trees. I just want to know how the driveway, which you say can be constructed with only 82 trees, how that happened. I’m confused. MR. LINSON: Can I answer that ? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Absolutely.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 110 MR. LINSON: Okay. All right. What I did was, you know, in the plans that were provided for me, I went to Staples, I printed them out. I counted Xs. I counted Xs in the -- in the bio-basins. I -- I counted Xs within the -- within the parking lot. I -- I counted Xs within the driveway, and that’s where I came up with these numbers. So I didn’t go on the property. I didn’t have permission to go on the property. So all of my -- my opinions were based upon walking along Eagle Rock Avenue looking into the property, and examining the -- the landscape plans, and the tree removal plans, and the tabulation of trees that would be removed and compensating quantities that would have to be replaced. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay, and the second part is, you said the driveway could be created. Would that be in the place that they

Page 29

would be removed and compensating quantities that would have to be replaced. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay, and the second part is, you said the driveway could be created. Would that be in the place that they want to do it, or in a different place? MR. LINSON: Same place. Right there. I mean, they -- they, you know, they -- they have to cut into a steep slope, but it's -- but it's only the width of the driveway, and not -- and, you know, it doesn't require a wall and a sidewalk, which would -- would remove, you know, 200 -- I came up with a figure of 231 trees have to be removed to build the wall and -- and

Page 30

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 111 the sidewalk. So, that's a big difference between, you know, 313 to do the whole project, or 82. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: So -- so Vision Zero, which is in the master plan, is -- we save the trees, but Vision Zero, we're not going to have, which is in our master plan. So there's two -- there’s two competing things here in our master plan, where we want to have sidewalks, we want to have connectivity, but we're not going to take any trees down, so we have no connectivity and increased safety for pedestrians. Again, I'm trying to put all the things that all the experts are saying together. MR. LINSON: You have an awesome responsibility, to --to filter all of this out, and try to -- try to meet the -- the requirements of the tree removal plan, and that doesn't -- the tree removal ordinance, it doesn't -- it doesn't say you can't remove any trees, it just says, let's try to re -- let's try to minimize the amount of -- amount of trees, and -- and so, I'm suggesting, let -- let's -- let's build a parking lot, let's build the exit driveway out onto Eagle Rock Avenue, but let's not build a retaining wall on a sidewalk that's gonna require, you know, 231 trees to be removed, so -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 112 MR. LINSON: But that’s -- that's my opinion, that's my recommendation -- CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yeah. It’s a good opinion. MR. LINSON: -- to the board, but you know, you -- you have to filter it all out. What's -- what’s the best solution for West Orange? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Thank you. Mayor McCartney, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MAYOR McCARTNEY: I do, Chairman, thank you. I have always respected John Linson's expertise ever since he was our town forester, but he certainly does raise some questions here that I'd like to ask. But I want to go back, because I still don't think the question was answered about are the trees healthy or salvageable? John, you mentioned the emerald ash borer. We have -- what's -- the black scorch going on. Did you notice any of that? That trees that needed to come down, or is that not something you can readily observe? MR. LINSON: That would require an on-site -- you know, a visit and an inspection. And had the applicant provided a table that -- that was

Page 30

o come down, or is that not something you can readily observe? MR. LINSON: That would require an on-site -- you know, a visit and an inspection. And had the applicant provided a table that -- that was prepared by a New Jersey licensed tree expert, as the ordinance requires, we would have seen another -- we would have1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 113 seen each tree listed in all 313 trees, the diameter, the species, and whether it was a viable tree or a non-viable tree. Non-viable trees are replaced on a one-to-one basis. Viable trees are replaced on a basis based upon the diameter of the tree. For example, a 12-inch diameter tree has to be replaced on a one-to- one basis. A 24-inch diameter tree is a two-to-one basis, you know, and so on. That's what the ordinance states. And so we -- we would like to be able to see the math that went into coming up with that -- the replacement numbers. They -- they elected to put in four-inch diameter trees instead of -- for the most part, and -- which -- which is good and bad. The smaller trees have a -- have a higher -- more survivability than the larger trees. They -- because you're -- you're when you transplant them, you're -- you're moving a greater percentage of -- of root system, a four-inch diameter. Basically, when you -- a two-inch caliper tree has a two-foot diameter ball. A four-inch diameter tree has a four-footr0 diameter ball, but it's just -- it's -- you know, the smaller trees you find survive better than -- than the larger transplanted trees.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 114 MAYOR McCARTNEY: So the question that I had, though, that I was waiting for that answer, but the question that I really had is that you basically said that the project can move forward if -- and save trees, if we relocate -- if the applicant relocates the bio- basins. Is that what I heard? MR. LINSON: Yes. MAYOR McCARTNEY: Yes. MR. LINSON: Yeah. Yeah. I mean it worked over on the public service property. There's two different basins. One has 15 trees that need to come down, the other has 45. So a total of 60 trees have to be removed just for the bio-basins. So it's almost like the same question that -- that when somebody wants to put solar panels on the roof, but they have to cut trees down, what's greener, the tree that's there or the

Page 30

or the bio-basins. So it's almost like the same question that -- that when somebody wants to put solar panels on the roof, but they have to cut trees down, what's greener, the tree that's there or the solar panel? MAYOR McCARTNEY: Yeah. It’s always a dilemma. MR. LINSON: You know -- MAYOR McCARTNEY: It’s always a dilemma; yes. Mm-hmm. MR. LINSON: Yeah. So. MAYOR McCARTNEY: Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman.

Page 31

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 115 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay. Thank you, Council President Scarpa. Do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? COUNCILWOMAN SCARPA: No, I think he summed it up very well. Thank you. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you. Mr. Alper, do you have any questions for Mr. Linson on his testimony? MR. ALPER: I think so. Sort of a process question, I guess. At -- Mr. -- and maybe from your experience when you were the town forester, maybe you know, maybe someone else knows, maybe the planning director, is there a point in the application process when the planning board, or maybe the SPRAB, should be hearing this sort of suggestion earlier on? Like, is the town forest part of SPRAB? Were you? Is the current one? MR. LINSON: Actually, Walt Kipp is -- is very capable. I don't know that he -- he is actually supposed to provide a report to the board, based upon an informal visit with the applicant on the site. I don't know that that happened or not. I did not see a report from Walt Kipp, but -- but that’s -- that -- you're correct. Mr. Alper. There -- there was supposed to be something from the -- the town forester that -- that was attached to this report, some sort of1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Cross 116 commentary. MR. ALPER: Okay. I mean, it strikes me as something probably for, you know, a different discussion about, you know, process and -- and where this should be, just because I think it requires some expertise to look at the tree ordinance and see if it's being complied with or being violated. And it would be good to have those opinions from the, you know, the same way that we get the opinions from the planner on the planning and the engineering on the engineering. Maybe the trees should be, you know, treated the same way so we have a better sense. I think… I guess my other question is, have you seen -- there was a letter from, I think, Langan Engineering from back in March that was supporting the tree removal plan. And I'm wondering if you've seen that, and if you have, you know, comments as to whether it addresses, or how well it addresses, the concerns you've raised. MR. LINSON: I have not seen that, and you know, if -- if a sidewalk is, is necessary, if the walls are necessary, it's just basically within that little area, I mean,

File revisions (1)