Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026
Crestmont_West_Orange_2026 10 07_CONDENSED_4up_with_Keyword_Index
61cfd83a303fdf20767e3213f4a34d59b1293ca7419bacfa1d496fdad6cb74f9Indexed text · page 26
Show all pages1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 95 maximum possible number of trees in the development of a site or lot, to protect specimen trees, to encourage innovative design and grading to promote the protection of existing trees and to prevent indiscriminate, uncontrolled, and excessive removal and cutting of trees as well as land use activities inconsistent with accepted arboricultural practices. And it goes on and on a little bit more than that, but in the ordinance, it specifically -- I’m going through the ordinance and turning the pages, as you can see. There are specific prohibitions in this ordinance. 28-4(b), number four: cut down or remove any tree on a slope with a grade of 10 percent or greater on a slope where vegetation is presently stabilizing soils. So, we have that -- Q Is -- is that -- is that true in this situation? A The construction of the sidewalk and the retaining wall is -- is an intrusion into the steep slopes. And this -- it’s a prohibition, so. Se -- number seven, remove trees within 100 feet of a ridge line. I think that -- that applies. Number nine, remove trees if tree removal will negatively alter existing drainage patterns and stormwater runoff. Well, that’s true.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 96 Number 10, remove tree if it will result in soil erosion. Well, the existing trees along Eagle Rock Avenue are stabilizing that -- those slopes, so in order to construct a wall and a sidewalk, you have -- physically have to remove the stumps of -- of all of those trees. Number 11, remove trees if it would increase the amount of stormwater runoff and/or negatively affect stormwater runoff patterns on any lots, whether con -- contiguous or not. Number 12, remove trees if it would constitute a significant change in the screening between existing or proposed structures on roads and/or adjacent lots. Number 13, I’m -- again, prohibitions. Remove trees where it would alter topography of the area where such trees are located and will create conditions which may be injurious to the trees or other trees located nearby. And I’ll refer to this later, but in that whole area, there’s only -- or where there’s 313 trees being removed, there’s only about 60 trees that would be saved. And by changing the grading and everything, it’s questionable whether those 60
at whole area, there’s only -- or where there’s 313 trees being removed, there’s only about 60 trees that would be saved. And by changing the grading and everything, it’s questionable whether those 60 trees that are surrounded by -- by improvements would actually survive.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 97 So -- and 14, remove trees where it would impair suitable habitats and migratory zones for endangered or threatened species or animals. And -- so those are -- those are specific prohibitions in the ordinance which I see this -- see a conflict with this application. And basically, you’re supposed to -- if you -- if you look at just the specific area where all the activity is -- is going to take place, 313 trees to come down. Well, only -- only 82 of those actually involve the parking area and the construction of the -- of the exit driveway onto Eagle Rock Avenue. Sixty of the tree -- tree removals have to do with the bio barriers, the retention basins. So if we could eliminate the bio basins and -- and put rete -- retention tanks within the parking lot area or within the roadway, we could right off the bat save 60 trees. And then -- so doing the math, I’m subtracting 80 and 60 from the 313. That means that 171 trees have to be removed to construct the wall and the sidewalk. So -- a sidewalk that is questionable of whether it’s really necessary or not. So -- at any rate, so that’s sort of what I’m -- what I’m seeing with this application, that -- that it’s -- it’s quite contrary to -- to the purposes and1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Linson - Direct 98 intent of our -- of the tree preservation ordinance, which again, I say it’s -- it’s one of the strictest in the state and it just seems that there’s so many departures from that that it -- it’s questionable. You know, it seems to me, you -- you can still build a parking lot and you can still have the exit driveway by only removing 82 trees, not 313 trees. Also, I question the math in calculating the replacements. Now, the -- the gathering of information was supposed to be done by a licensed tree expert. I think it was done by a landscape architect, which is contrary to the -- to the ordinance. It has to be done by a New Jersey licensed tree expert. And all those Xs you see on the -- to be removed, well there should be a number
ndscape architect, which is contrary to the -- to the ordinance. It has to be done by a New Jersey licensed tree expert. And all those Xs you see on the -- to be removed, well there should be a number next to all of those Xs that refers back to a table that says this is the diameter of this tree, it’s 12 inches in diameter, it’s a red maple. And there should be a column that says is it -- is it a viable tree or is it a non-viable tree? And that’s very important in doing the calculations. So the table they’ve presented cannot really be -- be scrutinized by somebody who is familiar with the process of -- of identifying trees and -- and tabulating these tables. I’ve done a couple of them for other applications in -- in West Orange and, you
File revisions (1)
- Nov 20, 2026
61cfd83a303f413,643 bytes