Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Dec 2, 2026

Crestmont_September_2_2026_Condensed_with_Keyword_Index

Preserved file SHA-25657c034a28d1c8a980a9438693f4fe6cb0ac77cfc3fa04a551290b5558b588db8

Indexed text

Page 23

ion1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Colloquy / Moronski - Direct 85 redundantly is not helping us. But thank you very much for your time. We appreciate it. So, to that end, Mr. Schkolnick, you’re up. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Are we done with this witness, Chairman? CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Yes. We’re done. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Okay. We’re going to call our next witness, our planning, Sean Moronski. MR. MORONSKI: Good evening. MS. McGOVERN: Mr. Moronski, please raise your right hand. I have to see you. I’m looking for you on -- okay. Sorry. S E A N M O R O N S K I, APPLICANT’S WITNESS, SWORN MS. McGOVERN: Thank you. DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. SCHKOLNICK: Q Mr. Moronski, could you provide your qualifications? A Yes. I -- Sean Moronski, Langan Engineering and Environmental Services, Parsippany, New Jersey. Masters of urban planning, New York University. New Jersey licensed professional planner since year 2000. My license is current and in good standing. Member of the American Institute of Certified Planners since 1999. I have been qualified before both boards in West Orange on several occasions throughout the years.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 86 Q Do you regularly testify before planning and zoning boards throughout the state? A I do. Q Do you regularly get recognized as an expert in professional -- A I have. Yes. Q -- planning? A Yes. MR. SCHKOLNICK: Chairman, I’d submit Mr. Moronski as an expert in professional planning. CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Do any members of the board have any questions? Seeing none, Mr. Moronski, we accept you as an expert in professional planning. Go right ahead, Sir. MR. SCHKOLNICK: We appreciate that. MR. MORONSKI: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. BY MR. SCHKOLNICK: Q Sean, if you’d go ahead, you obviously have reviewed the plans and the -- and the file and the reports and the review letters and -- and the site -- A Yes. Q -- and the variances that are at issue here. A Yes. I -- I have, and I’ve heard the testimony tonight and the testimony at the two previous meetings as well as the questions that have been offered by

Page 24

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 87 professionals, board members, and members of the public. You’ve heard the description of the site, the proposed improvements. My task is I'm going to be going through each of the requested variances, and how we meet the standards for relief, as outlined under the municipal land use law. Excuse me. We are requesting C, or bulk variances, and I will go, through each of them, one by one. The first one is from Chapter 25-12.1.B, which is the minimum distance from the parking area curb to a fencing, screening, or structure. You require a minimum of five feet. Less than five feet does exist, in terms of a setback in various places, and we're proposing three feet. We request this under the C-2 variance criteria, where the overall benefits of the application outweigh the concerns about the deviation. The benefit is to reconnect the parking field with the proposed driveway grading and the retaining wall. It outweighs what you'd consider to be a de minimis, a very minor impact regarding the setback of six of the parking spaces. And that has no -- that setback has no impact on neighboring buildings or uses. Typically, that type of, setback, there's concerns about how parking in those spaces that are within the setback could have an1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 88 impact on surrounding neighbors, lights, activity, that sort of thing. That's not the case that occurs there. The proposed setback allows for a guardrail and a fence that's on the east side of the proposed parking that's adjacent to the modular building, so it addresses concerns about, safety. And the protective measures for vehicular and pedestrian circulation include the guiderail and fence along the wall, which are less than five feet from the parking spaces. Then we have section 25-12.2.b.1, which is the minimum number of parking spaces. This is a permitted principal use of a golf clubhouse. It's considered a private club to determine the number of parking spaces. The standard is one space per 45 square feet of gross floor area. Which, when you add it up, we're required to have 700 spaces. Currently 256 parking spaces exist. That's an existing non-conforming condition. The applicant is proposing 292 spaces. That includes a count of four spaces as four electric vehicle

Page 24

o have 700 spaces. Currently 256 parking spaces exist. That's an existing non-conforming condition. The applicant is proposing 292 spaces. That includes a count of four spaces as four electric vehicle spaces are counted as two spaces, so it's 292 physical -- physical spaces involved. And this would also be a C-2 variance. The driveway, the reconfiguration provides an opportunity for existing parking at the -- additional parking at1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 89 the upper level. It's closer to the main facility to help support activity at Crestmont. And we are reducing the amount of relief, you know, that we need. I mean, 36 space -- it's a significant number of spaces. The 700 spaces is an excessive number of spaces. It's not something that the, club needs, nor would it desire, given, the nature, the nature of the site. And through the testimony, as we've noted, we're looking to minimize disturbances to the extent practical. So, from a C2 point of view, that the proposed spaces, yes, it improves our nonconforming existing condition, and it's an overall enhancement. With regards to, the maximum retaining wall height, four feet is the maximum, as we've heard. We're talking about over 1300 linear feet of wall. The maximum height, as was noted in Mr. Cote's testimony, is 21.5 feet. That's coincident with the basin, and the idea is to maintain the parking lot level. And this variance can be granted under the C1 criteria, specifically the C1B, which is due to the exceptional topographic condition on the site. The proposed wall heights that exceed four feet are a function of overcoming the topographic conditions on the site. You know, in order to theoretically meet1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 90 these conditions, or even come closer, you'd have to have a greater number of walls, it's a greater number of distur -- a greater amount of disturbance, potential for removing further trees. What's being proposed, the idea of striking a balance -- as you know, planning is about making choices in terms of minimizing the potential impacts from the disturbance while addressing drainage concerns, address -- which, not just on the site, but obviously that are related to the road improvements that are involved here to minimize the amount of trees that would be

Page 24

while addressing drainage concerns, address -- which, not just on the site, but obviously that are related to the road improvements that are involved here to minimize the amount of trees that would be replaced. The site grade at the new signalized intersection at Eagle Rock is elevation 538. The proposed parking, existing and proposed parking fields range from 565 to 557, so they are higher, about 20 to 30 feet higher, 20 to 25 feet higher, so the need for the higher walls to minimize the disturbance is certainly helpful in terms of minimizing development. The retaining walls help to create the new egress driveway and the proposed T-intersection. It's a significant safety improvement from the existing condition. We also need variances related to the topographic and the steep slope requirements. I'll go through what the specific variances are, because the relief, our

Page 25

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 91 justification is all tied together. We've had the minimum setback of the proposed improvements to the top of the steep slope. From 10 to 30 percent is 50 feet. The relocated driveway and the parking spaces are within 10 feet of the top of those steep slopes. Also, the minimum setback of the proposed improvements to the top of the steep slope greater than 30 percent is 100 feet. That relocated driveway and parking spaces are also within 10 feet of those steep slopes. And we're -- your ordinance does not permit disturbance of slopes greater than 25 percent. We're proposing about 10.9 percent of slopes greater than 25 percent. It's about, .38 acres, 16,400 square feet. This is over -- over more than 150,000 square feet of slopes that are greater than 25 percent. And then the maximum driveway slope, you already have slopes up to 10.5 percent that exist near Laurel Avenue, which are to remain. And we're proposing 8.5 percent slope, Mr. Cote had noticed. And these are due to, as a C-1(b) variance due to the exceptional topographic conditions on the site, to minimize the disturbance due to the existing topography, the grading activities result in slope disturbance. So the idea is to integrate the work into the1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 92 landscape while minimizing the disturbance to reduce the number of trees removed to the extent feasible. And also the minimum setback of the proposed improvements to the top of the steep slope is 50 feet, also proposing 10 feet. That relocated driveway and the parking spaces are within 10 feet, and that's for the same reasons that I noted with regards to the C- 1(b) variance. The requested relief would advance several purposes of the Municipal Land Use Law. Purpose A, which encourages action to guide appropriate use and development of land, promoting the public health, safety, and general welfare. The improvements will result in safety, circulation, aesthetic improvements on Eagle Rock Avenue, on-site stormwater management improvements that benefit beyond the site to Eagle Rock also. Purpose D, which is to ensure that the development of individual municipalities doesn't conflict with development and general welfare of neighboring municipalities; West Orange, Essex County, Roseland Borough,

Page 25

, which is to ensure that the development of individual municipalities doesn't conflict with development and general welfare of neighboring municipalities; West Orange, Essex County, Roseland Borough, Essex Fells, beyond that, but those three immediate jurisdictions will benefit from the improvements, the traffic signal, the driveway reconfiguration, the related Eagle Rock Avenue1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 93 improvements, drainage, site triangles, et cetera. Purpose H, which encourages the location and design of transportation routes which promote the free flow of traffic while discouraging the location of such facilities, which result in congestion or blight. Relocating the driveway reduces the points of conflict along Eagle Rock, and it aligns the driveway with Oval Roads to form the four-leg intersection. The associated widening improves safety at the intersection, allows left-turn vehicles safely queuing separate from the eastbound through lane. Purpose I, promoting desirable visual environment through creative design techniques and good civic design. The tree replacement throughout the site, the site improvements and enhancing aesthetics along the Eagle Rock Avenue frontage. So, in addition to the site, there's also the public benefit from an aesthetic, perspective. And then Purpose M, which encourages coordination of various public and private procedures and activities shaping land development, the view of lessening costs of such development, more efficient use of the land. Our -- the applicant has worked with Essex County to provide land along its road frontage for roadway improvements. The alignment, the realignment, creates1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 94 an intersection. It removes a driveway that otherwise would not align with the other intersection. I believe this is an overall public benefit as we know that applications, it's not just benefits that accrue to the applicant, it's what is the overall public benefit, and there are several of them with this application. We have to address the negative criteria. There's no substantial detriment to the public good. Every -- every application may have an impact. The question is, does it rise to such a level that it's substantial? And if it is, is it being addressed? We know that the county is

Page 25

to the public good. Every -- every application may have an impact. The question is, does it rise to such a level that it's substantial? And if it is, is it being addressed? We know that the county is favorable to -- regarding the intersection improvements, the driveway relocation, which was suggested by the traffic -- county traffic engineer years ago. Widening Eagle Rock, provide the left turn lane to Oval, to lengthen the left turn lane onto Laurel. These are all benefits. It'll include coordination with the Laurel Avenue signal. It'll improve sight distances. The project improves stormwater management. It's a benefit to the surrounding area. The existing driveway drains water to Eagle Rock. The driveway removal will remedy the situation. Stalling drainage improvements on Eagle Rock. The sidewalk, which was

Page 26

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 95 recommended by this board, from Laurel Avenue to the end of the property line, not on any other property, but the idea to enhance the potential for pedestrian activity. The site improvements do not increase the intensity of the use, they improve the parking situation. We're not proposing any buildings here. We're not proposing to increase the intensity of the site. The tree replacement plan that contributes to the aesthetic improvements, and that's noted throughout the plans, and -- and the documents. There are no NJ DEP permits required, for the project. Mr. Cote did note that the 8 percent grade is acceptable in winter conditions. There are other areas that are steeper, such as I noted, near Laurel. A detention system is required for the Eagle Rock Avenue improvements. The applicant has agreed to the condition to maintain the sidewalk on Eagle Rock Avenue. The sidewalk was already accounted for in the retaining wall design. And in terms of the area -- in terms of the impervious coverage, it was noted in testimony, about 12,000 square feet on site, a quarter of an acre, another quarter of an acre off-site. The project area itself, this was noted, was just1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 96 a little under four acres, 3.95 acres, and we're talking about this on an overall 146-acre site. So we're focusing on a very small area which has some very practical improvements which make substantial -- substantial beneficial impacts, as I've noted. There's no substantial impairment to the intent and purpose of the zone plan or the zoning ordinance. We're a permitted use in the R-2 zone. We're increasing the number of parking spaces. Yes, we're not near 700, we're not going to get there, but we are moving in a direction where we can combine with minimizing the disturbance. The sidewalk provides connectivity. Your 2019 Master Plan update, it talks about a couple of purposes that are relevant here. Master Plan Purpose 8, which is on page 8 of the update, providing a safe, efficient transportation and circulation routes, which, this is an objective that remains valid. They talk about transportation modes beyond motor vehicles. The township has taken actions to promote pedestrian and bicyclist safety. While it may not be at this specific

Page 26

bjective that remains valid. They talk about transportation modes beyond motor vehicles. The township has taken actions to promote pedestrian and bicyclist safety. While it may not be at this specific location, the overall township theme, the idea is to provide options in terms of circulation safety. Also in your 2019 Master Plan update, Master Plan1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 97 Purpose 15, Coordinating Public and Private Procedures and Activities, that's on page 10 of the 2019 update. And that goes hand-in-hand with the Municipal Land Use Law Purpose M about coordination of various public and private procedures. It was noted about the site plan waiver, that this board can grant exceptions as may be reasonable and within the general purpose and intent of the site plan ordinance. And this is with regards to the removal of the trees, proposing to remove 191 trees on slopes greater than 10 percent. This is simil -- the rationale is similar to the steep slope disturbances and the retaining wall variances. It's driven by the topographic condition. The tree replacement plan is in accord with the proposed tree restoration plan. Those drawings are in the site plans. The overall number of trees is 313 that would be removed, but in terms of replacement trees, it's well over 500 trees, most of which are going to be on site. There was testimony to that. There's gonna be coordination, with the -- with the forester, again, working hand-in-hand with the -- with the township's professionals to meet the intent of the tree replacement ordinance. So, in terms of the -- the variances, I do believe1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Moronski - Direct 98 they can be granted under the various C criteria, whether the C-2 or, in the cases of the steep slope and the retaining walls, the C-1(b) criteria and that the site plan waiver is driven by the conditions with regards to the steep -- the steep slopes and the topography, the idea being that it's to minimize the disturbance while providing the proposed improvements. And that sums up my testimony. Thank you. Q Okay. A couple questions for you, Sean. You certainly touched on it, on the negative impacts to surrounding properties, because we heard from a lot of people tonight, some living in Essex Fells, and some living pretty far away, but in terms

Page 26

You certainly touched on it, on the negative impacts to surrounding properties, because we heard from a lot of people tonight, some living in Essex Fells, and some living pretty far away, but in terms of your planning testimony, do you see any negatives to any of those immediate neighbors in the surrounding area? A I don't, and I think that was as supported by the testimony presented by our prior professionals in terms of the drainage improvements, in terms of the circulation improvements. And yes, the terms to the on-site improvements, because it is a benefit to enhance the Crestmont Country Club, which is a fixture in the community, long, long established, also. So you have both public and private benefits. The plan minimizes concerns with regards to disturbance of trees, addressing drainage and

File revisions (1)