160-26 Exhibit A-Competitive Contracting Report SS4A 2026.pdf

Evaluation The methodology for awarding competitive contracts is based on an evaluation and ranking, which shall include technical, management, and cost pursuant to the Local Public Contracts Law. The Township formed a committee to review and evaluate proposals received. The committee members are Panayiota Reynolds, Purchasing Agent; Zayibeth Carballo, Engineer and Director of Engineering; Matthew Reiss, Sergeant for the West Orange Police Department, Jared Malveda, Assistant Municipal Engineer, and Glenn McCarthy, Administrative Analyst for the Department of Engineering. The results of the committee's assessment and scoring are: Scoring weight 1-100 Panayiota Reynolds Boswell Engineering 77 CME 77 Neglia 42 NV5 82 Michael Baker International 85 Zayibeth Carballo Boswell Engineering 79 CME 79 Neglia 28 NV5 86 Michael Baker International 92 Matthew Reiss Boswell Engineering 80 CME 76 Neglia 37 NV5 83 Michael Baker International 88 Jared Malveda Boswell Engineering 98 CME 94 Neglia 21 NV5 100 Michael Baker International 100 Glenn McCarthy Boswell Engineering 92 CME 82 Neglia 48 NV5 92 Michael Baker International 88