Supporting Documentation · Oct 27, 2026
292-26 PE Proposal - West Orange TAP 2025 Rev1.pdf
123fd7b84af07daec629295c9cc99cb18d816b1d26e78e69f670188f2b23e404Indexed text
ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES & PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT Activity 3300 – Initiate Cultural Resources (Section 106) Process Richard Grubb & Associates (RGA), as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S’ supervision, will provide cultural resources services necessary to initiate the Section 106 consultation process. RGA will review available information, identify known historic properties and archaeological resources within or adjacent to the project area, assist in establishing the Area of Potential Effects (APE), and prepare applicable cultural resources documentation and recommendations in accordance with NJDOT and Section 106 requirements. RGA will coordinate its findings with M&S for incorporation into the environmental documentation and Preliminary Engineering design. M&S will manage and coordinate RGA's services and provide available project plans, mapping, and design information necessary to support the cultural resources review. Activity 3305 – Conduct Cultural Resources Survey RGA, as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S’ supervision, will conduct a Cultural Resources Survey to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, and will conform to all requirements of the NJDOT and NJHPO for such studies. The initial survey will include an Intensive-level historic architectural survey. Background research will be performed using available and accessible NJHPO files, New Jersey State Library, and local repositories, if feasible. Pertinent planning and regulatory surveys at the NJHPO will be reviewed. Historic atlases and maps will be reviewed. RGA will use the NJHPO’s GIS data for information on known historic properties proximate to the project area. RGA will also review internal files for information on prior cultural resources surveys. An archaeological survey is not included. Intensive-level Historic Architectural Survey The Intensive-level historic architectural survey will determine if previously identified cultural resources and any unidentified significant buildings, historic districts, and structures of greater than 50 years in age are present within the APE-Architecture and will be impacted by the project. Preliminary background research suggests there are approximately 11 previously unidentified and/or unevaluated historic resources within a probable APE-Architecture, consisting primarily of early to mid-twentieth century
nd research suggests there are approximately 11 previously unidentified and/or unevaluated historic resources within a probable APE-Architecture, consisting primarily of early to mid-twentieth century dwellings and commercial properties. These resources include Block 176.05, Lot 10; Block 176.03, Lots 16 and 17; Block 152.22, Lots 142.01, 142.02, 142.03, and 142.05; Block 154.06, Lots 13, 14, 15, and 18. RGA does not anticipate that all 11 resources will require Intensive-level survey. Important considerations will be if the architectural resource possesses the requisite historical significance and integrity for listing in the NRHP and whether the proposed undertaking has the potential to impact the resource’s ability to meet the NRHP Criteria. Project effects will be assessed on all identified historic properties. Activity 3310 – Prepare Cultural Resources Survey Report RGA, as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S’ supervision, will prepare a Cultural Resources Survey Report covering historic architecture. The report will describe the survey and identification/evaluation of resources associated with the project and will follow current guidelines prepared by the NJDOT and the NJHPO. The report will summarize the results of Activity 3305 and will provide the basis for consultation with the NJHPO. Activity 3320 – Address Comments on Cultural Resources Survey Report RGA, as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S’ supervision, will incorporate comments received from the NJDOT into a final Cultural Resources Survey report to be submitted to the NJHPO. 10
Activity 3765 – Conduct Ecology Study M&S will evaluate the site’s existing conditions and potential impacts of the project to natural resources. This includes surface water quality, upland forests, soils, wetlands, waterbodies including aquatic species and habitats, floodplains and flooding, riparian zones, terrestrial species and habitats, and threatened and endangered species. A preliminary review of NJDEP geospatial data on-line mapping indicates that there are no mapped waters or wetlands in the project area. M&S will conduct field reconnaissance to confirm the presence of regulated features (1 day/2 people). M&S will begin initial coordination with the appropriate regulatory agencies having jurisdiction over resources that will be potentially affected, including US Fish & Wildlife Service and NJDEP Natural Heritage Program (NHP). An Environmental Screening Report will be prepared to identify potential environmental constraints and support the Categorical Exclusion Document (CED). NJDOT BEPR will lead all federal agency consultations with M&S providing the necessary technical support, if required. Activity 3840 – Conduct Hazardous Waste Study Several historic and active NJDEP Site Remediation Program cases are present along the project corridor. M&S will evaluate the project’s potential involvement with known or suspected contaminated waste sites through the review of available data including an environmental database search (EDR), review of historic aerials and land use, Sanborn maps, and geospatial data. Additionally, M&S will research and inquire from NJDEP any known case files within the vicinity of the project. Site reconnaissance will be performed to visually identify recognized environmental concerns and hazardous materials within the vicinity of the project. The results of the Hazardous Waste Study will be presented in a memorandum for use in completing the CED. Activity 3865 – Hold Public Information Center Colliers Engineering & Design (Colliers) will organize, coordinate and facilitate one (1) Public Information Center (PIC) during the Preliminary Engineering phase in accordance with NJDOT public involvement requirements and in coordination with M&S, the Township, and NJDOT. The Public Information Center will be conducted at a Township-provided venue and will present the proposed conceptual improvements to the public, elected officials,
with M&S, the Township, and NJDOT. The Public Information Center will be conducted at a Township-provided venue and will present the proposed conceptual improvements to the public, elected officials, stakeholders, businesses, and adjacent property owners. M&S will provide the applicable preliminary design information and technical exhibits. Colliers will prepare the public presentation materials, meeting handouts, sign-in sheets, and meeting advertisements and coordinate meeting logistics with the Township and NJDOT. Following the meeting, Colliers will prepare meeting minutes summarizing the public comments received and document responses to comments for incorporation into the environmental documentation and project development process. Public input will be evaluated to determine whether refinements to the preliminary design are warranted. Activity 3874 – Execute PE Public Involvement Action Plan (PIAP) Colliers, as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S' supervision, will coordinate stakeholder outreach during Preliminary Engineering. Stakeholder coordination is anticipated to include: • One (1) meeting with the Downtown West Orange Alliance. • Two (2) meetings with the Township Historic Preservation Commission. • Coordination with the Pedestrian Safety Advisory Board, as appropriate. • Coordination with Essex County, as appropriate. Colliers will coordinate with M&S and the Township to schedule the meetings; prepare appropriate meeting materials using technical information provided by M&S; participate in and facilitate the meetings; and document substantive comments, decisions, and action items. Colliers will coordinate 11
stakeholder comments with M&S for consideration in the Preliminary Engineering design and environmental documentation and will assist the Township in obtaining the anticipated Historic Preservation Commission Resolution of Support. Activity 3890 – Prepare Certified Categorical Exclusion (CCE) Document It is anticipated that the project meets the Programmatic Agreement for Approval of Certain Categorical Exclusions between the FHWA and NJDOT. M&S will assist NJDOT BEPR with preparation of the Certified Categorical Exclusion Document (CCED) by preparing Section I. General Information and Section II. Project Description and environmental constraints mapping to support the CCED. PRELIMINARY ENGINEERING DOCUMENTATION Activity 3160 – Prepare Draft Preliminary Engineering Report M&S will prepare the Draft Preliminary Engineering (PE) Report documenting the engineering, environmental, utility, and public involvement activities completed during Preliminary Engineering and the resulting design decisions and recommendations. The report will be prepared in accordance with NJDOT requirements and will include or reference the applicable environmental documentation, Preliminary Roadway Plans, technical studies and memoranda, Construction Cost Estimate, stakeholder coordination documentation, and other required supporting information for NJDOT review and advancement of the project into Final Design. Activity 3165 – Finalize Project Plan Following receipt of Preliminary Engineering review comments, M&S will coordinate with the Township and NJDOT to address applicable comments and revise the Preliminary Roadway Plans and supporting PE documentation, as appropriate. The finalized plans will incorporate accepted design refinements, stakeholder input, environmental commitments, utility coordination requirements, and other applicable revisions and will establish the approved Project Plan for advancement into Final Design. Activity 3185 – Develop Final Design Public Involvement Action Plan Colliers, as a subconsultant to M&S and under M&S' supervision, will prepare the Final Design Public Involvement Action Plan (PIAP) based on the public and stakeholder coordination completed during Preliminary Engineering. The PIAP will identify anticipated Final Design outreach activities, stakeholders, communication methods, project milestones, and opportunities for public participation and
ng Preliminary Engineering. The PIAP will identify anticipated Final Design outreach activities, stakeholders, communication methods, project milestones, and opportunities for public participation and will address applicable comments and commitments developed during Preliminary Engineering. Colliers will submit the draft PIAP to M&S for review and address comments necessary to finalize the document. 12
PRELIMINARY ENGINEERING COST PROPOSAL TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE NJDOT Transportation Alternatives Set-Aside Program 2025 Pleasantdale Streetscape Project - Pleasant Valley Way (from 250 Feet South of Greenwood Avenue to Kenz Terrace) Township of West Orange, Essex County, New Jersey 8/20/2026 TASK # / TASK NAME 3006 Prepare & Submit PE Complete Streets Checklist 3012 Develop Landscape Architectural Design 3015 Prepare Control Survey Report 3020 Conduct Topographic Survey 3025 Prepare Base Maps 3030 Prepare Horizontal & Vertical Geometry 3035 Prepare Utility Base Plans 3045 Send Utility Verification Request Letter 3055 Conduct Utility Risk Analysis 3070 Prepare Preliminary Roadway Plans TITLE 3080 Conduct Subsurface Utility Engineering 3085 Prepare Preliminary Drainage Design 3090 Determine Traffic Engineering Facility Locations 3130 3135 Update Preliminary Detour and Construction Staging Plans Prepare Construction Cost Estimate 3160 Prepare Draft Preliminary Engineering Report 3165 Finalize Project Plan 3185 Develop FD Public Involvement Action Plan 3300 3305 Initiate Cultural Resources (Section 106) Process Conduct CR Survey 3310 Prepare CR Survey Report 3320 Address Comments on CR Survey Report 3765 Conduct Ecology Study 3840 Conduct Hazardous Waste Study 3865 Hold Public Information Center 3874 Execute PE Public Involvement Action Plan (PIAP) 3890 Prepare Certified Categorical Exclusion (CCE) Document Update Utility Risk Assessment Plan 3985 Sr. Professional PVII Principal Engr/Surveyor PV Project Engineer PIV Engineer PIII Engineer PII Engineer PI Senior Designer ETIV Survey Crew Instrument Chief/ Sr Tech Operator / Tech ETIII ETII Research Clerk TOTAL
Principal Engr/Surveyor PV Project Engineer PIV Engineer PIII Engineer PII Engineer PI Senior Designer ETIV Survey Crew Instrument Chief/ Sr Tech Operator / Tech ETIII ETII Research Clerk TOTAL HOURS 2.00 8.00 12.00 1.00 8.00 16.00 24.00 1.00 1.00 8.00 16.00 17.00 38.00 52.00 130.00 130.00 12.00 379.00 22.00 96.00 192.00 10.00 10.00 16.00 365.00 32.00 81.00 26.00 1.00 40.00 1.00 2.00 1.00 2.00 10.00 12.00 25.00 4.00 20.00 21.00 45.00 10.00 32.00 2.00 8.00 16.00 8.00 36.00 26.00 90.00 104.00 180.00 6.00 16.00 8.00 16.00 24.00 24.00 2.00 40.00 94.00 102.00 1.00 2.00 8.00 4.00 2.00 6.00 16.00 1.00 8.00 16.00 8.00 4.00 8.00 8.00 2.00 35.00 48.00 12.00 2.00 48.00 238.00 24.00 39.00 24.00 48.00 8.00 16.00 57.00 16.00 8.00 44.00 4.00 6.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 2.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 1.00 1.00 2.00 12.00 32.00 62.00 106.00 10.00 40.00 64.00 114.00 16.00 16.00 24.00 16.00 3.00 TOTAL MANHOURS 3.00 32.00 40.00 9.00 1.00 3.00 10.00 16.00 245.00 244.00 12.00 17.00 250.00 294.00 240.00 126.00 374.00 31.00 140.00 140.00 28.00 2097.00 DIRECT RATE $ 122.50 $ 99.60 $ 90.00 $ 73.60 $ 65.50 $ 50.44 $ 36.94 $ 58.75 $ 47.17 $ 38.07 $ 39.50 TOTAL DIRECT SALARY $ 1,960.00 $ 24,402.00 $ 21,960.00 $ 18,400.00 $ 19,257.00 $ 12,105.60 $ 4,654.44 $ 21,972.50 $ 6,603.80 $ 5,329.80 $ 1,106.00 $ 137,751.14 SUBTOTAL DIRECT LABOR COSTS $ OVERHEAD BASED ON NJDOT APPROVED OVERHEAD ( 99.88%) $ 137,751.14 137,585.84 FIXED FEE (22.5% X DIRECT LABOR COSTS) $ PROFESSIONAL FEE $ OUT-OF-POCKET EXPENSES $ TOTAL SUBCONSULTANT COST $ TOTAL COST $ 30,994.01 306,330.99 22,485.00 87,684.87 416,500.86 OUT-OF-POCKET EXPENSES Deed Packets & Maps MPT (Shoulder Closures) Traffic Count Processing Natural Heritage Program Data Environmental Data (EDR) Subsurface Utility Engineering (SUE) Total Expense Project Manager PVI $ SUBCONULTANTS 540.00 Richard Grubb & Associates $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 4,500.00 Colliers Engineering & Design 1,575.00 70.00 800.00 Total Cost for Subconsultants 15,000.00 22,485.00 $ 54,687.46 $ $ $ $ 32,997.41 87,684.87
FIXED FEE CALCULATION PROJECT: 2025 TAP - W Orange Pleasantdale Streescape Project - PE CONSULTANT: Malick & Scherer, P.C. AGREEMENT OR CAM NO. TP-806 PREPARED BY: DATE: R. Zalewski 6/20/2026 EVALUATE PROJECT SPECIFICS: Directions: Prime Consultant will use Total Project Design Cost (or Task Order Design Cost) for the SIZE criteria Each Subconsultant will assign points for SIZE, COMPLEXITY, DURATION, & DEGREE OF RISK based on its specific project tasks. SPECIFICS CRITERIA SIZE: COMPLEXITY: DURATION: DEGREE OF RISK: POINTS RATING SMALL - Total Fee (Project Design Cost) < $1,250,000 15 15 LARGE - Total Fee (Project Design Cost) > $1,250,000 20 SIMPLE - Limited Scope of Work; Deck Patching, Resurfacing, Restoration, Inspection, Concept Development Services 10 STANDARD - Moderate Scope; Rehabilitation, New, or Reconstruction 15 COMPLEX - Multi-disciplined, Highly Specialized, or Major Unusual 20 STANDARD - Appropriate Schedule 15 AGGRESSIVE - Designers Schedule Reduced > 10 % 20 LEVEL 1 - Low Risk of Claims; Studies, Surveys, Landscape, Inspections 20 LEVEL 2 - Average Risk of Claims; Standard Complexity or Level 1 with High Public Exposure 30 LEVEL 3 - High Risk of Claims; Hazardous, Experimental, or Bonus/Penalty Clauses 40 TOTAL RATING = 15 15 30 75 CALCULATE FEE: PROJECT SPECIFICS FACTOR (Total Rating /100) = 0.75 FEE FACTOR ( Project Specifics Factor x 0.30) = 0.225 DIRECT LABOR COSTS $ 137,751.14 TOTAL FEE (Direct Labor Costs x Fee Factor) = $ 30,994 Fixed Fee Calculation Page 1 Revised 04/22/2014
Firm Name: Date: Malick & Scherer, P.C. August 1, 2026 Employee Name ASCE Grade Title Consultant/ Subconsultant Name Reason for Change Certified Payroll Michael McAlpin PVII Director Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Robert Zalewski PVII Director Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Steven C. Ragazzo PVII Director Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Andrew Schueller PVII Director Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Stefan Eskesen PVI Project Manager Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Kellen Sporny PVI Project Manager Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Aino-Liis Tootsov PVI Project Manager Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Anne Napolitano PVI Project Manager Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Gregory Sullivan PVI Project Manager Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Chad Davis PV Principal Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Adel Elsekhily PV Principal Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Ryan S. Teets PV Principal Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 2 Nicholas DiMichele PIV Project Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. James Kleen PIV Project Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Andrew Ferri PIV Project Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Kevin R. Carroll PIV Project Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Peter Fleming PIV Project Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 John Beringer PIII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Ali Malick PIII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Ashley Sidhu PIII Environmental Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Amin Abdelhafeez PIII Office Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. Mohammed Rashid PIII Office Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. Abdel-Hady Hussein Hosny PIII Office Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. Wenhui (Terry) Kong PIII Office Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Anthony Zegarra PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Anthony Passalacqua PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Christopher Stiles PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 David Marihugh PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Thomas Nadolsky PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 2 2 Camilo Arteaga Rodriguez PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. Ryan Biesty PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Jordan Williams PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 John Boyce PII Environmental Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Yenny Molano PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Collin Herbert PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Ahmed
File revisions (1)
- Oct 24, 2026
123fd7b84af02,296,343 bytes