Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 27, 2026

292-26 PE Proposal - West Orange TAP 2025 Rev1.pdf

Preserved file SHA-256123fd7b84af07daec629295c9cc99cb18d816b1d26e78e69f670188f2b23e404

Indexed text

Page 19

er, P.C. 2 John Boyce PII Environmental Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Yenny Molano PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Collin Herbert PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Ahmed Elshorbagy PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Thomas Urban PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Mary Nadolsky PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Yunjie Li PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Lini Agudelo Salazar PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Norbert Lapczynski PI Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Ashley Pastore PI Environmental Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Tiffany Bai PI Environmental Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Emily Padilla-Chicas PI Planner Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 THE CONSULTANT'S SIGNATORY HEREBY CERTIFIES THAT IT HAS NOT EMPLOYED OR RETAINED ANY COMPANY OR PERSON, OTHER THAN A BONA FIDE EMPLOYEE WORKING FOR THE CONSULTANT, ON A FULL OR PART TIME BASIS, THAT THEY HAVE USED THE DOT FORM, AND THE HOURLY WAGE RATE SHOWN IS THE ACTUAL RATE PAID THE EMPLOYEE AS OF THE SELECTION POSTING DATE FOR THIS CONTRACT. FULL TIME AND PART TIME EMPLOYEES ARE LISTED SEPARATELY AND ACTUAL HOURLY RATES ARE STATED. CERTIFICATION: PRINCIPAL OF THE FIRM Page 1 of 2 Average of each ASCE grade $122.50 $99.60 $90.00 $90.00 $73.60 $65.50 $68.00 $65.51 $50.44 $48.00 $36.94 $36.00 $40.00

Page 20

Firm Name: Date: Malick & Scherer, P.C. August 1, 2026 Ryan Smith ETV Sr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Luis Ramirez ETV Sr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Molly Bloom ETV Sr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 James Coyle ETIV Senior Designer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Claudia Reyes-Estrada ETIV Senior Designer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Thomas Hannan ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Thomas J. Drumm ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Femi Ogundare ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Zane Brouty ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Matthew Fritz ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Phillip Smith ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Marc Garafano ETIII Community Liaison Malick & Scherer, P.C. Jose Sarmiento ETIII Community Liaison Malick & Scherer, P.C. Andrew Zimmer ETIII Community Liaison Malick & Scherer, P.C. Bahaa Judeh ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Ala Abedalnabi ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Hazim Habbul ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Jake Berfond ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Karim Hamza ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. $58.83 $58.75 $47.17 $44.33 2 $53.75 4 Bajwa Abdul ur Rehman ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Nileshkumar Patel ETIII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Jason Davis ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Randal Acosta ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Colin Williamson ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Azhari Asghedom ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Julie Cerroni ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Gary Switzer ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Travis Klingback ETII Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Nicolas DeCarlo ETII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. Derian Melendez ETII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Thomas McKenna ETII Inspector Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Edward Mack IV ETI Jr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Patrick Milewski ETI Jr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Anthony Heater ETI Jr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Mark Albright ETI Jr. Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Travis Humza ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Elizabeth Donnelly-Bruno ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Kaushika Mistry ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Frank

Page 20

erer, P.C. 2 Travis Humza ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Elizabeth Donnelly-Bruno ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Kaushika Mistry ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Frank Olshefski ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Shawn Calario ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 Amanda Herrick CL Clerical Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 $38.07 $33.33 $27.50 $28.20 Amanda Redcay CL Clerical Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Carmen Manzueta CL Clerical Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Malik Umair CL Clerical Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 Sharon McAlpin CL Clerical Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 $38.00 George Dimitrakis ETI Drafter Malick & Scherer, P.C. 2 $34.00 Abdurrahman Hagag PII Engineer Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 $56.00 Venancio Macuray ETIII Surveyor Malick & Scherer, P.C. 4 $45.00 John Jimenez PVII Sr. Enviro Specialist Malick & Scherer, P.C. 5 $150.00 $39.50 Part Time REASON FOR CHANGE: MERIT INCREASE COST OF LIVING PROMOTION NEW EMPLOYEE 1 2 3 4 OTHER 5 THE CONSULTANT'S SIGNATORY HEREBY CERTIFIES THAT IT HAS NOT EMPLOYED OR RETAINED ANY COMPANY OR PERSON, OTHER THAN A BONA FIDE EMPLOYEE WORKING FOR THE CONSULTANT, ON A FULL OR PART TIME BASIS, THAT THEY HAVE USED THE DOT FORM, AND THE HOURLY WAGE RATE SHOWN IS THE ACTUAL RATE PAID THE EMPLOYEE AS OF THE SELECTION POSTING DATE FOR THIS CONTRACT. FULL TIME AND PART TIME EMPLOYEES ARE LISTED SEPARATELY AND ACTUAL HOURLY RATES ARE STATED. CERTIFICATION: PRINCIPAL OF THE FIRM Page 2 of 2

Page 21

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION P.O. Box 600 Trenton, New Jersey 08625-0600 MIKIE SHERRILL Governor PRIYA JAIN Commissioner DR. DALE G. CALDWELL Lt. Governor July 27, 2026 Arif Malick, President Malick & Scherer, P.C. 53 Frontage Road, Suite 170 Hampton, NJ 08827 Dear Arif Malick: Based on our review of Malick & Scherer, P.C.’s Statement of Direct Labor, Fringe Benefits and General Overhead for the Year Ended December 31, 2025, we recommend overhead rates of 91.09 percent be used for construction inspection projects, 99.88 percent be used for home office projects, and 97.95 percent be used for additional work modifications for contracts entered into prior to your firm selecting to use split rates or the time split rates were required on all new contracts and extra work modifications. Additionally, in accordance with current Department policy, if FCCM is specifically identified in the cost proposals relating to the contract under which the cost is to be claimed, the audited FCCM rates of 0.26 percent should be used for construction inspection projects, 0.29 percent should be used for home office projects, and 0.28 percent should be used for additional work modifications for contracts entered into prior to your firm selecting to use split rates or the time split rates were required on all new contracts and extra work modifications. The above rates should be used for funding all new contracts. In addition, the overhead rates proposed on this overhead letter expire on July 1, 2027. These rates are subject to audit verification. Our acceptance of these rates does not extend beyond contracts with the New Jersey Department of Transportation. Any other entity contracting with the firm is responsible for determining the acceptability of the overhead statement. This letter will be provided to other governmental entities upon request, in accordance with 23 U.S.C. § 112(d). If you have any questions, feel free to contact Timothy Groark at (609)-963-2412 or Timothy.Groark@dot.nj.gov. Sincerely, Marie Samson Administrative Analyst IV Management Auditor, Bureau of External Audit New Jersey Department of Transportation TG “IMPROVING LIVES BY IMPROVING TRANSPORTATION” New Jersey Is An Equal Opportunity Employer • Printed on Recycled and Recyclable Paper

Page 23

Richard Grubb & Associates

Page 24

CULTURAL RESOURCES SCOPE OF WORK CULTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY 2025 TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES SET-ASIDE PROGRAM PLEASANTDALE STREETSCAPE PROJECT TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE, ESSEX COUNTY, NEW JERSEY August 20, 2026 Richard Grubb & Associates, Inc. (RGA) will complete a Cultural Resources Survey in support of the Township of West Orange’s proposed streetscape improvements to an approximately 1,250-foot segment of Pleasant Valley Way, between Greenwood Avenue and Marmon/Kenz Terrace. As part of the proposed project, the Township is proposing key improvements designed to elevate safety and accessibility for commuters alongside beautification enhancements. Planned upgrades include, but are not limited to, new brick pavers and stamped concrete crosswalks, ADA-compliant curb ramps, flashing LED pedestrian beacons, decorative lighting fixtures, benches, and trash receptacles, among other work. The proposed project will include the installation of trees, PSEG decorative light poles and fixtures, planters, bus shelters, benches, bike racks, trash receptacles, detectable warning surfaces, and an asphalt-stamped or brick paver crosswalk at various points throughout the project limits. These enhancements are essential for maintaining consistency and accessibility throughout Pleasant Valley Way, as well as improving overall safety for the community. The Preliminary Engineering (PE) phase will be funded, in part, by a 2025 Transportation Alternatives Set-Aside grant that is administered by the New Jersey Department of Transportation-Bureau of Environmental Program Resources (NJDOT-BEPR) in partnership with the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority (NJTPA). The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) is the lead federal agency. Due to the use of federal funding, the proposed project is an undertaking subject to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (NHPA), as amended (Public Law 89-665; 54 USC §; 300101 et seq.), and its implementing regulations (36 CFR § 800), the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and Section 4(f) of the US Department of Transportation Act. The Cultural Resources Survey described herein will be sufficient to complete Section 106 consultation between the NJDOT and New Jersey Historic Preservation Office (NJHPO) through determinations of National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) eligibility and assessments of effects

Page 24

tion 106 consultation between the NJDOT and New Jersey Historic Preservation Office (NJHPO) through determinations of National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) eligibility and assessments of effects should historic properties be identified. Historic properties are defined as resources listed in or eligible for listing in the NRHP. A review of the NJ Cultural Resources GIS Online Map Viewer (NJ-GeoWeb) indicates that the project location is not situated within the boundaries of a historic property previously determined eligible for or listed in the NRHP, nor is the project location situated within an archaeological site grid. Preliminary background suggests there are several historic resources lining the project limits that have not been previously identified or evaluated for the NRHP by the NJHPO. As currently proposed, a number of the proposed project elements consist of activities on the NJDOT’s current List of Undertakings Which Have Limited or No Effect on Cultural Resources in New Jersey, including the installation of trash receptacles, bike racks, and benches.

Page 25

Proposal, Cultural Resources Township of West Orange Pleasantdale Streetscape Improvements August 20, 2026 Page 2 CULTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY The goal of the Cultural Resources Survey will be to initiate the Section 106 process, define appropriate Areas of Potential Effects for Archaeology (APE-Archaeology) and Historic Architecture (APE-Architecture), evaluate the eligibility for the NRHP of all historic architectural resources within the APE-Architecture, and to assess effects of the project on historic properties, if any. The proposed effort will comprise an Intensive-level historic architectural survey. Based on the limited extent and nature of the undertaking, a formal archaeological survey is not included. The NJDOT staff will lead the coordination effort with NJHPO. The results of the Cultural Resources Survey will be presented in a report that meets the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards and Guidelines for Archaeology and Historic Preservation (1983) and will meet the requirements of the NJHPO’s Guidelines for Architectural Survey (1999). The project archaeologist will meet the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualifications Standards for Archaeology (36 CFR § 61). The project architectural historian will meet the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualifications Standards for Architectural History (36 CFR § 61). ACTIVITIES Activity Codes 3300, 3305, 3310, and 3320 will be completed in accordance with the NJ Project Delivery Process for Preliminary Engineering. Initiate Cultural Resources (Section 106) Process (3300) RGA will prepare a letter that delineates the APEs to facilitate the NJDOT’s initiation of Section 106 consultation with the NJHPO. This will entail a review of project maps to identify the proposed limits of disturbance, which will be used to delineate the APE-Archaeology. The APE-Architecture will encompass the APE-Archaeology. A site visit will be conducted to document existing conditions within the APE-Architecture using digital photography. Representative photographs of the APE-Architecture will be included in the APE letter submitted to the NJHPO. RGA will also prepare a list of potential consulting parties. RGA will check the archaeological site files at the New Jersey State Museum (NJSM) for previously registered archaeological sites within or proximate to the APE-Archaeology. Since it is unlikely that the project

Page 25

eck the archaeological site files at the New Jersey State Museum (NJSM) for previously registered archaeological sites within or proximate to the APE-Archaeology. Since it is unlikely that the project will impact archaeological historic properties, it is anticipated that the archaeological effort will end with the Section 106 initiation process. A recommendation for no further archaeological survey is expected within the Section 106 initiation letter. Project mapping is requested to help complete the Section 106 initiation letter. Estimated duration: 1-2 months. Conduct Cultural Resources Survey (3305) A Cultural Resources Survey will be performed to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, and will conform to all requirements of the NJDOT and NJHPO for such studies. The initial survey will include an Intensive-level historic architectural survey. Background research will be performed using available and accessible NJHPO files, New Jersey State Library, and local repositories, if feasible. Pertinent planning and regulatory surveys at the NJHPO will be reviewed. Historic atlases and maps will be reviewed. RGA will use the NJHPO’s GIS data for information on known historic properties proximate to the project area. RGA will also review internal files for information on prior cultural resources surveys. An archaeological survey is not included.

Page 26

Proposal, Cultural Resources Township of West Orange Pleasantdale Streetscape Improvements August 20, 2026 Page 3 Intensive-level Historic Architectural Survey The Intensive-level historic architectural survey will determine if previously identified cultural resources and any unidentified significant buildings, historic districts, and structures of greater than 50 years in age are present within the APE-Architecture and will be impacted by the project. Preliminary background research suggests there are approximately 11 previously unidentified and/or unevaluated historic resources within a probable APE-Architecture, consisting primarily of early to mid-twentieth century dwellings and commercial properties. These resources include Block 176.05, Lot 10; Block 176.03, Lots 16 and 17; Block 152.22, Lots 142.01, 142.02, 142.03, and 142.05; Block 154.06, Lots 13, 14, 15, and 18. RGA does not anticipate that all 11 resources will require Intensive-level survey. Important considerations will be if the architectural resource possesses the requisite historical significance and integrity for listing in the NRHP and whether the proposed undertaking has the potential to impact the resource’s ability to meet the NRHP Criteria. Project effects will be assessed on all identified historic properties. Estimated duration: 3 months. Prepare CR Survey Report (3310) RGA will prepare a Cultural Resources Survey Report covering historic architecture. The report will describe the survey and identification/evaluation of resources associated with the project and will follow current guidelines prepared by the NJDOT and the NJHPO. The report will summarize the results of Activity 3305 and will provide the basis for consultation with the NJHPO. Estimated duration: 2 months from completion of all fieldwork. Review CR Survey Report (3315) To be completed by the NJDOT. Estimated duration: 2 weeks. Address NJDOT Comments on CR Survey Report (3320) RGA will incorporate comments received from the NJDOT into a final Cultural Resources Survey report to be submitted to the NJHPO. Estimated duration: 2 weeks. Approve CR Survey Report (3325) To be completed by the NJDOT. Estimated duration: To be determined based on report complexity. ASSUMPTIONS/EXCLUSIONS This proposal assumes that the contractor and/or NJDOT will facilitate entry onto private properties, if necessary, to enable the completion of

File revisions (1)