Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Feb 26, 2025

February 26, 2025, Planning Board Special Meeting Transcript - WEHI

Preserved file SHA-2566444b25b07a6ea7cce3d02395fb097530d2e082d17ce0e6fd654a9ec620f72a0

Indexed text · page 23

Show all pages
Page 23

23 of 46 sheets Page 89 to 92 of 115 03/03/2025 06:36:47 AM 89 number 18?1 THE WITNESS: Yeah. Now, again, I don't2 know what the systems going to be set up in3 construction, so I don't -- I'm speaking generally.4 THE PUBLIC: So you haven't seen any reports5 of what could be set up during construction to mitigate6 any potential issues, damage, high flow rates?7 THE WITNESS: I didn't review the erosion8 control -- sediment control plan, no.9 THE PUBLIC: I guess a point Mr. Chairman,10 were erosion controls submitted to the board?11 THE WITNESS: I believe they have erosion12 control.13 THE PUBLIC: There are so many documents.14 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Okay.15 THE WITNESS: It's outside my review.16 THE PUBLIC: Okay. Thank you.17 That's all for now.18 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank you very much.19 Any other members of the public have any20 questions on Mr. Walsh's testimony? Please come up.21 THE PUBLIC: Orin Knights.22 I have a question for Mr. Walsh. As far as23 with the deforestation of hundreds of trees that's going24 to be taken from that area, how will that it affect the25 90 drainage as far as, because you're not going to have the1 trees there anymore. This plays a major part in2 absorbing the water. So is the catch basin, those3 things enough to stop major flooding not only uphill but4 downhill?5 THE WITNESS: Well, when they remove --6 THE PUBLIC: We're talking hundreds of7 trees.8 THE WITNESS: No, I understand. It's a9 large area the development. So when they remove those10 trees they're going to change the landscape type which11 means it's going to generate runoff. The forest doesn't12 generate a lot of runoff. Now, what's supposed to13 happen, is the design system is supposed to understand14 that and counteract that and capture stormwater in15 pipes, trap it in basins and slowly release it. What I16 was trying to say was, I think there was some flaws in17 some calculations where it's not actually going to do18 that. It is their intent to do that. They're not19 trying to intentionally flood anyone, but I think there20 were some missed calculations and missed observations21 that I think this design will increase flooding. Will22 increase runoff that can trigger flooding.23 THE PUBLIC: Thank you, Mr. Walsh.24 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank any.25 91 Any other members of the public have1 questions for Mr. Walsh on his testimony? Please come2 up and identify yourself.3 MS.

Page 23

ding.23 THE PUBLIC: Thank you, Mr. Walsh.24 CHAIRMAN BAGOFF: Thank any.25 91 Any other members of the public have1 questions for Mr. Walsh on his testimony? Please come2 up and identify yourself.3 MS. MCGOVERN: Mr. Afran, is Ms. Pannullo4 your client?5 MR. AFRAN: As far I know Ms. Pannullo is6 not an officer of my client. She may be married to an7 officer, but as far I know she's not an officer.8 THE PUBLIC: I am a neurosurgeon not a9 client of his.10 MS. MCGOVERN: You're not a client?11 MR. AFRAN: As far I know Ms. Pannullo is12 not an officer retaining jurisdiction.13 MS. MCGOVERN: We Care is his client, if14 you're representing --15 MR. AFRAN: I don't represent Ms. Pannullo.16 Her husband is the president of We Care NJ. As far as I17 know Ms. Pannullo is not an officer of my client.18 THE PUBLIC: I am not an officer.19 MR. AFRAN: Therefore I have no client20 relationship with her.21 MS. MCGOVERN: My understanding was that22 nobody -- my understanding was that if you are23 representing the organization that any member of the24 organization was therefore being represented by you and25 92 you were going to be asking the questions on their1 behalf.2 MR. AFRAN: As far as I know they only have3 officers, it's not a member corporation and I think we4 progressed to the point, Ms. McGovern, the wife of an5 officer is an individual in her own right.6 MS. McGOVERN: Believe me, I'm not7 challenging that. My point, my question is, if she's8 part of the organization, separate and distinct from her9 husband?10 MR. AFRAN: Allow me to ask a question. One11 moment.12 THE PUBLIC: Ask my husband.13 MS. MCGOVERN: You can ask her.14 MR. AFRAN: I'm asking Mr. --15 MS. MCGOVERN: I'm asking who you represent.16 MR. AFRAN: I'm not asking Mr. Pannullo17 about his wife. I'm asking Mr. Pannullo about the18 structure of We Care NJ.19 MS. MCGOVERN: Fine.20 (Whereupon, a short recess is taken.)21 MR. AFRAN: We Care NJ is not a member22 Corporation, it is a 501(c)(3) but not a member23 corporation -- 501(c)(4), does not have members. It24 only has officers. So all though I understand Ms.25

File revisions (1)