Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Jul 1, 2026

July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-25606070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158

Indexed text

Page 27

that the lighting along Eagle Rock Avenue will be within the county’s jurisdiction. Mr. Cote clarified that the applicant is not proposing 27-foot-high lighting on the property and therefore does not view the 27-foot height as a variance because it will be under the county’s jurisdiction. He stated that the difference in mounting heights was being noted for the record. Mr. Cote then moved to the easterly lighting drawing, sheet LL102. He stated that lighting is being provided in the upper parking lot area and down the access drive. Mr. Cote noted that, at the end of the access drive, there is a potential variance regarding a foot-candle intensity of 3.5 at the property line where the driveway exits. Mr. Cote explained that the driveway is being lit for purposes of the county’s review and stated that he was not certain whether it would be considered a variance because it would be under county jurisdiction for lighting. Mr. Cote then referred to the detail sheet, LL501, and explained that the pedestrian fixtures are “post top pedestrian lights,” with fixture heads mounted at the 18-foot height required by the ordinance. Mr. Cote stated that along Eagle Rock Avenue there will be “cobra head” lights, which he described as similar to the lighting currently existing along Eagle Rock Avenue. 27

Page 28

Mr. Cote then returned to the overall site plan and stated that he wanted to enumerate the requested variances for the record. Mr. Cote identified the first variance as Section 25-12.1.B, concerning the minimum distance from the parking area to fencing, screening, or a structure. Mr. Cote explained that this variance occurs in proximity to the recently constructed modular structure and that the fencing is being used as a protective measure while still allowing pedestrian access adjacent to the modular building. Mr. Cote identified the next variance as the minimum number of parking spaces. He stated that 700 spaces are required, and the application is reducing the current variance from 252 spaces to 292 spaces. Mr. Cote then identified the variance under Section 25-28.0.8.0.f.11, concerning the maximum retaining wall height of four feet. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant is proposing a 21.5-foot wall. He explained that this is specifically related to the area where the upper lot improvements are being combined with the lower-level detention/retention small-scale bioretention basin needed to meet water quality and water quantity requirements for stormwater management. Mr. Cote then discussed the variance requests related to steep slopes. He referred to the steep slope exhibits contained in the plan set and identified the partial steep slope analysis with site plan overlay as drawing EX04. Mr. Cote explained that EX04 identifies the various areas of the site and the extent of the slopes within those areas. Mr. Cote explained that, from the overall perspective, the site has a transition in topography between the upper-level parking lot, lower-level parking lot, and Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote stated that the elevations change by approximately 20 to 30 feet over portions of the site. Mr. Cote explained that, in order to minimize disturbances, the applicant is imposing a wall along portions of the steep slopes. He stated that the walls will be designed and will have to be approved by the Building Department for purposes of construction. Mr. Cote then discussed the transition from the upper-level parking lot to the lower-level parking lot. He explained that the project traverses a slope and that, in order to smooth the slope and create a drivable exit maneuver, walls and roadway improvements are required through portions of the steep slopes. Mr. Cote

Page 28

at the project traverses a slope and that, in order to smooth the slope and create a drivable exit maneuver, walls and roadway improvements are required through portions of the steep slopes. Mr. Cote similarly discussed the area along Eagle Rock Avenue where the project is leveling the steeper slope that currently exists from the curb line to the top of the slope. Mr. Cote explained that the applicant is pulling that slope back and imposing a retaining wall along the length of the area to create a safe zone adjacent to the roadway. Mr. Cote stated that, from a steep slopes perspective, 0.38 acres of disturbance are associated with the total of 3.8 acres of areas containing slopes of 25% or greater. Mr. Cote explained that the disturbance is associated with minimizing disturbance, allowing roadway access to proceed through the site, and allowing for the proper design of the off-site roadway, Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote then identified the last variance as the maximum driveway slope under Section 25-28.f.8. Mr. Cote stated that 6% is allowed, while the proposal includes a combination of 8.5% and 10.5% grades. He explained that the 10.5% grade is the existing condition and the 8.5% grade is on the main driveway. Mr. Cote explained that the difficulty on the site is connecting the grades at a county- compliant access point to Eagle Rock Avenue. 28

Page 29

- Mr. Cote stated that the grades range from approximately 5% coming off the intersection, through 8.5%, and then back to the grades that tie into the upper-level parking lot. - Mr. Cote explained that this creates the 8.5% condition, while the 10.5% condition is existing. - Mr. Cote then referenced Section 25-14.1 concerning lighting. He stated that, if the lighting is determined to require a variance, the applicant will request it if necessary. He explained that the lighting is being provided for safety for both vehicular and pedestrian movements through the intersection. - Mr. Cote also identified requests for a site plan waiver regarding the removal of trees on slopes of 10% or greater. - Mr. Cote stated that there are a significant number of areas with 10% slopes. He explained that the trees being removed are also being replaced using the multiplier required by the town for the restoration component. - Mr. Cote stated that the tree removals are associated with the grading needed from Eagle Rock Avenue and with efforts to minimize grades and impacts associated with the new parking lot and driveways. - Mr. Cote explained that the trees being removed in those areas are associated with the need to place the various improvements while attempting to minimize impacts. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on August 12, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. Jamilet Ba i ite Planning Board Secretary ADOPTED: 10] +|26 : ib! Soe

File revisions (1)