Minutes · Jul 1, 2026
July 1, 2026 Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
06070d63f2cc8bfb6a92457924418aabf3e97673b3f2b795c15b74aa405db158Indexed text
ing the parking area toward the north of the site. Mr. Cote also addressed comments from the engineers’ and planners’ letters. He explained that one of the EV spaces would be required to be an ADA EV space. Mr. Cote stated that the ADA EV space would be provided by using the existing ADA space on the site and accommodating the requirement for one EV space to be an ADA space. Mr. Cote then returned to the orientation of the western side of the site, where the stormwater basin and parking lot are shown together. Mr. Cote then identified the widening of Eagle Rock Avenue as another component of the improvements. Mr. Cote explained that part of the widening involves grading Eagle Rock Avenue in accordance with Mr. Pehnke’s testimony to level off the area adjacent to the roadway and provide a level area. Mr. Cote stated that a wall is proposed along the frontage and that it will run along the length of Eagle Rock Avenue from Laurel Avenue into the proposed new intersection. Mr. Cote then switched to the easterly site plan sheet. Mr. Cote explained that the easterly partial site plan shows the intersection discussed in Mr. Pehnke’s earlier testimony, including Eagle Rock Avenue and the on-site improvements associated with the new egress drive. Nu Ss
Mr. Cote stated that the new egress drive begins at the upper-level parking lot and progresses down to the new intersection with Oval Road. The proposed egress roadway would be 24 feet wide and would provide two lanes, including left and right movements and a through movement, exiting onto Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote then described the underlying parking area, which he referred to as the “lower level.” He explained that the lower-level parking lot is being modified and reconfigured to create a 64-space parking lot. The lower-level parking lot will connect to the new egress drive while maintaining the existing connection to the upper-level parking lot along the south-central portion of the lower lot. Mr. Cote stated that the lower-level lot will also include an area for water quality measures, including forest pavement, along the northern portion of the lot. He explained that this area will tie into other water quality measures being provided for the site. Mr. Cote noted that, for purposes of the variance, there is a location where a fence/guide rail is located less than 5 feet from a parking space. He explained that this configuration is based upon the previously approved modular structure that was built there to provide separation between the parking spaces and pedestrian movements to that building. He identified this as one element of the variance being requested. Mr. Cote then discussed the eastern edge on the northern side of the site, where another detention basin is being proposed. He explained that, similar to the basin at the corner of Eagle Rock Avenue and Laurel Avenue, this detention basin will treat both water quality and water quantity for purposes of balancing stormwater and achieving compliance with the stormwater regulations. Mr. Cote pointed out that, based on the combination of the two site plan sheets, the existing site currently has 256 parking spaces. He stated that the prior variance granted for the site was actually based on 252 spaces, but a physical count of the existing spaces yielded 256. Mr. Cote explained that, based upon the 256 existing spaces, the application is adding 36 spaces. He stated that there are 32 physical spaces being added in total, representing the net between the revisions to the new parking lot and the reconfiguration of the lower lot. Mr. Cote explained that four of the total spaces are referred to as
es being added in total, representing the net between the revisions to the new parking lot and the reconfiguration of the lower lot. Mr. Cote explained that four of the total spaces are referred to as EV credits. For each EV space, there is a credit of one additional parking space that counts toward parking compliance, and those credits are part of the calculation. Mr. Cote stated that, physically, there will be 288 parking spaces built when the additional spaces are completed. The additional four spaces included in the parking count for purposes of the variance request, bringing the total to 292, are EV credit spaces. Mr. Schkolnick clarified that when they refer to a variance request, there is already an existing deficit and that the proposal is reducing the existing deficit. Mr. Cote agreed and explained that the increase in parking spaces reduces the current relief previously granted for the site. He stated that the site is going from 252 spaces previously approved under a prior site plan variance, against the 700 spaces that the ordinance would require, to 292 spaces, thereby reducing the relief previously granted on the site. Mr. Cote then discussed the roadway layouts, standard parking spaces, 24-foot drive aisles, and the configuration of the connection previously referenced. Mr. Cote moved to the fire truck circulation plan and explained that the plans route emergency vehicles through the new features being added to the site to demonstrate that they can maneuver, access the various locations, and progress through the site. 23
On the westerly side, Mr. Cote showed the fire truck circulation through the new parking facility, based upon the dimensions of the West Orange ladder truck that had been provided for purposes of supporting the area. Mr. Cote explained that there are a number of locations where the project is overcoming existing conditions and grades. He stated that one of the driving factors behind where the walls have been placed, and the reason for the walls, is to help minimize the number of trees removed. To provide perspective on the elevations, Mr. Cote explained that if Eagle Rock Avenue is at approximately elevation 547 in the area he was pointing to, the upper parking lot is at approximately elevation 566. Mr. Cote explained that the stormwater and grading associated with the project are designed to control all runoff from the site through a combination of the small-scale basins previously discussed, including one in the northwest corner and one at the east/northeast end of the site. Mr. Cote stated that a swale is also being provided at the top of the wall to direct water rather than allowing it to sheet flow onto Eagle Rock Avenue. The water will progress into the system and into a controlled drainage conveyance system, including the piping network that conveys the flow from the site. Mr. Cote stated that, as part of the discussion regarding safety on Eagle Rock Avenue, the stormwater on Eagle Rock Avenue was also evaluated. He explained that the existing system was found to be deficient and that the applicant is upgrading the system along Eagle Rock Avenue to accommodate the flows. He stated that this will improve the drainage aspects of Eagle Rock Avenue by controlling the sheet flow that is uncontrolled today, as well as providing the flow reductions necessary to comply with the stormwater regulations. Mr. Cote then discussed the second sheet on the east side of the site and again referenced the upper parking lot configuration to provide a sense of the elevations. Mr. Cote stated that the upper lot ranges from approximately elevation 560 to 558 at the top end and then rises to approximately elevation 564 toward the top of the new exit driveway. Mr. Cote explained that the new exit driveway begins at approximately elevation 564 and runs down toward Eagle Rock Avenue, which is approximately elevation 538. Mr. Cote stated that, in order to transition
e explained that the new exit driveway begins at approximately elevation 564 and runs down toward Eagle Rock Avenue, which is approximately elevation 538. Mr. Cote stated that, in order to transition from elevation 564 to approximately 538 at Eagle Rock Avenue, the driveway needs to be at an 8.5% grade. Mr. Cote further explained that, in addition to the 8.5% transition needed to reach Eagle Rock Avenue, walls are required to support the changes in grade, maintain the upper- level parking lot grades adjacent to the slope leading down to Eagle Rock Avenue, and allow for a stormwater basin to be constructed on the site. Mr. Cote explained that the 21.5-foot wall occurs where the lower-level basin is located. He stated that the basin is at a level compatible with reaching street grade, dealing with the Eagle Rock Avenue discharges, supporting the upper-level parking, and creating the transition at the northern end. Mr. Cote stated that the walls along Eagle Rock Avenue, resulting from the pullback of the grades previously referred to by Mr. Pehnke, will create an approximately 8- to 9- foot-high wall along Eagle Rock Avenue from the corner of Laurel Avenue and Eagle Rock Avenue to the new egress drive. Mr. Cote then discussed the existing driveways. He stated that the existing driveway that had been referred to multiple times as the “acute angle driveway” is being removed in its entirety. 24
Mr. Cote explained that the slope conditions associated with that driveway will therefore be eliminated. However, the existing 10.5% drive connecting the lower-level and upper- level parking lots will remain. Mr. Cote stated that the variance therefore also addresses the existing 10.5% driveway slope. He explained that the driveway is being slightly modified but will not be made steeper, in order to maintain the connection between the two parking lots. Mr. Cote then discussed the area associated with both detention basins and their role in handling the parking lots and the new driveway. He moved to the drainage plan and discussed the small-scale bioretention basin. Mr. Cote explained that the small-scale bioretention basin will provide water quality and water quantity reduction. Drains that previously allowed water to sheet flow off the site will be connected, with the goal of getting everything into pipes rather than allowing it to sheet flow over Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote stated that this would help address potential icing conditions and similar safety concerns on Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote explained that the eastern side of the site has a similar small-scale bioretention basin. One basin will be planted with woody vegetation, which will be part of the landscaping discussion. Mr. Cote stated that the bioretention provides water quality treatment in conjunction with the porous pavement proposed in the parking lot. Mr. Cote emphasized that the detention basins, porous pavement, and other measures have been tied together'to achieve compliance with the current stormwater regulations. Mr. Cote then moved to the tree count and tree removal and replacement and switched to the partial tree removal plan. Mr. Cote explained that the partial tree removal plan identifies trees within the limit of disturbance that are being removed. Replacement calculations are based upon the town’s requirements and the diameters of the existing trees. Mr. Cote stated that 313 trees are being removed. Based upon the replacement ratios required by the town ordinance, the project will replace those trees with a total of 486 trees. Mr. Cote then modified that number by 11 trees. He explained that the plan had counted 11 trees toward compliance with the landscaping and parking lot requirements, and that the applicant would not take credit for those 11 trees as replacement
ees. He explained that the plan had counted 11 trees toward compliance with the landscaping and parking lot requirements, and that the applicant would not take credit for those 11 trees as replacement trees. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant would therefore add 11 more trees, resulting in a total of 597 trees for purposes of the replacement tree count. Mr. Schkolnick asked Mr. Cote what sheet he was on. Mr. Cote responded that he was on the partial tree removal plan, sheet LD101. Mr. Schkolnick clarified that Mr. Cote was making an oral amendment to the application to comply with the review letter and add 11 additional trees because of the way the calculation had been done. Mr. Cote confirmed this and explained that, based on the ratios, the count was 586, but the trees are being replaced in a combination of locations throughout the site. Mr. Cote stated that there is a summary table on the plan identifying the 586 trees and their placement relative to areas where bulk improvements are being made, including along Eagle Rock Avenue and Laurel Avenue and in the parking areas being reconfigured. Mr. Cote explained that additional trees will also be planted throughout the Crestmont property as a whole. He stated that 303 trees will be placed along the frontage area and an additional 239 trees will be placed on the overall Crestmont property. 25
Mr. Cote stated that, to reach the full count of 586, the applicant had proposed 44 trees off-site in coordination with the town forester. As a result of the oral amendment, the 44 off-site trees will become 55 trees in order to provide the additional 11 trees. Mr. Cote then discussed where the trees are being removed based on the limits of disturbance of the property. Mr. Cote addressed the question of why walls are being proposed in steep slope areas. He explained that, by using the wall configuration and grading proposed, the applicant has been able to minimize the number of trees that need to be removed. Mr. Cote stated that if the walls along Eagle Rock Avenue or at the base elevation of the upper-level parking improvements and increased parking had been eliminated, additional trees that are currently outside the disturbance area would have had to be removed as a function of the grading. Mr. Cote explained that the walls serve two purposes: to consolidate the development limits and minimize disturbance, and to eliminate the removal of additional trees. Mr. Cote then moved to the planting plans and reviewed the easterly sheet. Mr. Cote explained that, on the easterly portion of the site, trees being removed are associated with the areas of disturbance. Trees outside the limit of disturbance will be subject to tree protection measures consistent with the requirements of the town forester and the ordinance. Mr. Cote then reviewed the planting plan and discussed the total number of trees being placed on the site as a whole. Mr. Cote stated that the 303 trees proposed along the frontage area, which he described as the northerly portion where the predominant improvements are being proposed, will consist of a combination of different types of trees. Mr. Cote stated that he would not discuss the specific species of trees because those are identified on the plans. He noted that substitutions will be made in accordance with the review comments received, and that the plan will be made consistent with those comments. Mr. Cote explained that the replacement planting will include a combination of shade trees and ornamental trees. He also identified evergreen trees, shrubs including evergreen and deciduous shrubs, ornamental grasses, ground covers, and perennials as part of the planting program. Mr. Cote described the planting program as substantial and
n trees, shrubs including evergreen and deciduous shrubs, ornamental grasses, ground covers, and perennials as part of the planting program. Mr. Cote described the planting program as substantial and stated that the small-scale bioretention basin will also be planted in compliance with DEP standards. Mr. Cote stated that 40 trees will be planted within the bioretention basin. He explained that these trees will be “whips.” Mr. Cote clarified that the 40 whip trees do not count toward the restoration calculation and are not being used to offset the trees removed and trees restored. However, he stated that they will grow into additional trees over time and should become a substantial feature of additional trees as they grow. Mr. Cote described the existing trees along Eagle Rock Avenue as being in various conditions, with substantial scrub and other growth located on the embankment slope. Mr. Cote stated that the applicant will clean up the area to create the streetscape area previously discussed. The walls will be imposed along the area to allow the grades to be pulled back. Mr. Cote explained that, adjacent to Eagle Rock Avenue, there will be significant replacement planting in areas where trees were removed and will now be replaced by new trees. 26
Mr. Cote stated that a similar scenario will occur at the east end of the site along Eagle Rock Avenue and within the islands being reconfigured as part of the existing lower-level parking area. Mr. Cote characterized the planting plan as an extensive planting scenario. Mr. Cote explained that additional trees are also being planted elsewhere on the property to reach the tree count for the property as a whole, with the exception of the 55 trees proposed off-site. Mr. Cote then moved to the tree restoration plans. He identified the tree restoration plan as sheet LP201 and explained that it shows the “big picture” of where additional planting areas are located. Mr. Cote identified areas A through H throughout the site as locations where additional trees can be planted. Mr. Cote explained that these areas were coordinated with the golf course operations staff. The applicant walked the entire site with golf course operations personnel to identify locations where additional trees could be planted without interfering with golf operations or the golf experience. Mr. Cote stated that the purpose was to provide supplemental tree plantings and fill in areas where there was an opportunity for additional trees. Mr. Cote explained that these areas extend from the northerly Eagle Rock Avenue location through the southern portion of the site and throughout the property located within the West Orange limits. Mr. Cote then returned to the plant set and discussed lighting as another element being added to the project. Mr. Cote identified the lighting plan as sheet LL101 and explained that it shows the partial lighting plan associated with the westerly portion of the site. Mr. Cote stated that fixtures are being provided in the new parking lot area and along Eagle Rock Avenue. Mr. Cote addressed comments regarding the two different mounting heights. He explained that on-site lighting will use an 18-foot mounting height, consistent with the ordinance. Mr. Cote stated that off-site lighting will work with the existing layout of the poles that are currently there, which operate at a 27-foot height. Mr. Cote explained that these are standard “cobra head-type lights” and that the lighting along Eagle Rock Avenue will be within the county’s jurisdiction. Mr. Cote clarified that the applicant is not proposing 27-foot-high lighting on the property and therefore does not
File revisions (1)
- Nov 3, 2026
06070d63f2cc21,327,306 bytes