Minutes · Aug 12, 2026
August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes
e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93Indexed text
MINUTES TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE PLANNING BOARD MEETING August 12, 2026, 6:30 P.M. The Township of West Orange Planning Board held a special meeting on August 12, 2026, at 6:30 P.M. via virtual ZOOM videoconference. Chairman Bagoff called the meeting to order at approximately 6:30 P.M. He announced that notification of the meeting was given to the Township Clerk, and posted on the Township Bulletin Board, sent to the West Orange Chronicle and the Star Ledger, and posted on the Township’s website calendar. This meeting has been properly noticed to the public in accordance with the Open Public Meetings Act. No new matters will start after 10:30 P.M. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE * Chairman Bagoff requested all persons stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. ANNOUNCEMENTS e The next Planner Board regular meeting will be held Wednesday, September 2, 2026, at 6:30 p.m. via Zoom. e The next Planner Board special meeting will be held Wednesday, September 9, 2026 at 6:30 p.m. via Zoom. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Dr. Robert Bagoff; Mr. Ken Alper; Mr. Christopher Morgan, Sr.; Mayor Susan McCartney; Mr. Frank Noborine; Council President Susan Scarpa; Ms. Lori Kapferer; Mr. John Cardoza; Mr. Lee Klein; Mr. Jerry Guarino; ABSENT: Mr. William Wilkes ALSO PRESENT: | Diana P. McGovern, Esq., Planning Board Attorney; Jamilet Baquerizo Vite, Planning Board Secretary SWEARING IN ° The Township Professionals: Mr. Greg Valesi (Consultant Engineer) and Mr. Michael Davis (Consultant Planner) were sworn under oath. MINUTES & RESOLUTIONS PB 26-04 Orange Prospect LLC Draft Resolution Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mayor McCartney a Alper: 4 Mayor McCartney: ™
Bagoff: Y Morgan: ¥ Cardoza (Alt.2): Y Noborine: _ Guarino: _ Scarpa: _- Kapferer: —- Wilkes: -— Klein: 4 APPLICATIONS e PB-26-03 Crestmont Country Club 750 Eagle Rock Avenue Block: 174 Lot: 1.01 Zone: R-2 [Application only appearing with preservation of notice to schedule to another meeting. No testimony provided/nor a vote on this application tonight.] The applicant is proposing the installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Eagle Rock Avenue and Oval Road. Modifications to the existing driveway and parking area are also being proposed. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on September 2, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. e PB-25-09 Perez 68 Whittlesey Avenue Block: 129 Lot: 58 Zone: R-T The applicant proposes to subdivide the property into two 50-foot lots, convert the existing single-family dwelling to a two-family dwelling, and construct a new two-family dwelling on the subdivided lot. PRESENTATION - Alan Trembulak appeared on behalf of Johnny Perez, the applicant. - Mr. Trembulak stated that this was a continuation of the hearing on the minor subdivision application for 68 Whittlesey Avenue, which commenced on May 6th. - Mr. Trembulak reviewed the relief being sought. o The property is a 100-foot-wide lot in the RT zone district. o The application proposes to subdivide the existing lot into two 50-foot-wide lots, convert or expand the existing single-family house to a two-family dwelling, and construct a new two-family dwelling on the subdivided lot. © Each of the two lots would contain a two-family dwelling, with all dwelling units being two-bedroom units. He noted that this was important because of the parking requirement. - Mr. Trembulak stated that the RT zone permits two-family dwellings and 50-foot lots; however, a two-family dwelling requires a 75-foot-wide lot, and the lot area requirements also differ for single-family and two-family dwellings. - Mr. Trembulak referred to testimony provided by his client, Johnny Perez, at the May 6th hearing. o He stated that Mr. Perez and his family have a history on Whittlesey Avenue.
o Mr. Perez grew up on the block, and his parents and brother currently live at 66 Whittlesey Avenue, next door to 68 Whittlesey Avenue. o Mr. Perez lives at 68 Whittlesey Avenue. Mr. Trembulak stated that Mr. Perez intends to create the two two-family units for his two sons, with each son anticipated to live in one of the houses. o Ultimately, Mr. Perez intends to pass the houses on and keep them in the family, resulting in three generations of Perezes on Whittlesey Avenue. Mr. Trembulak stated that the Board requested additional information on the subdivision plan showing how the required parking would be provided while remaining within the lot coverage and building coverage requirements. Mr. Trembulak stated that a revised plan had been submitted, although it did not reach the Board until that day. © The revised plans show four parking spaces on one lot and three parking spaces on the other, while remaining within the coverage requirements. Mr. Trembulak stated that Matt Flynn, the applicant's professional Planner, would discuss the plans, the variances, and provide additional testimony in support of the application. Mr. Trembulak noted that the applicant received a supplemental memorandum from the Board's Planner dated June 26, 2026. o. He stated that the applicant intends to comply with all comments in the Planner's memorandum, most of which concern building code issues or other matters more appropriately addressed when building permit applications are submitted. Mr. Trembulak stated that the current application is only seeking subdivision approval, but the applicant would comply with all building code requirements, height requirements, and the Board's design requirements concerning the appearance of the houses. The professional planner, Matt Flynn, entered on the record and was sworn under oath. He testified to the following: Mr. Flynn confirmed that he was familiar with the application and had reviewed the subdivision plans, including the most recent revised plan dated July | of the current year. Mr. Flynn referred to his two-page planning exhibit, entitled "Planning Exhibits for Johnny R. Perez," which he stated was dated May 6, 2026. The exhibit showed the subject property highlighted in red, with the proposed subdivision line represented by a red dashed line splitting the existing property approximately in half. Mr. Flynn stated that a
ibit showed the subject property highlighted in red, with the proposed subdivision line represented by a red dashed line splitting the existing property approximately in half. Mr. Flynn stated that a variance was required for lot area because the existing property is 10,000 square feet and the proposed subdivision would create two 5,000-square-foot properties. He stated that a two-family dwelling requires 7,500 square feet, resulting in a deficiency for both proposed properties. Mr. Flynn stated that the purpose of his exhibit was to show that, despite the strict requirements in the zoning ordinance, the properties in the immediate area include several lots that are just as small, or smaller, than what is being proposed and are similarly developed with two-family dwellings. Mr. Flynn stated that the properties highlighted in yellow on his exhibit are two-family properties on 5,000-square-foot lots or smaller. © He noted that several properties are 2,500 square feet, approximately half the size of the proposed lots, with frontages of approximately 25 feet and 34 feet in some cases. He stated that the 2,500-square-foot lot size is prevalent in the area. Mr. Flynn also pointed out that there are many three-family properties in the neighborhood. o The properties shown in orange are developed with three-family structures, and many are located on 50-by-100-foot lots, similar to what is being proposed.
o He stated that, from a density standpoint, the proposal is "right on par" with what is seen in the immediate neighborhood. Mr. Flynn stated that the lot area and lot width are both variance conditions for the two proposed lots. Mr. Flynn moved to the second sheet of the exhibit, which showed the property outlined in yellow. He identified the existing two-family home that would remain on what he referred to as the bottom property based on the orientation of the exhibit. o The newly created property would be above it, where there is currently a surface parking condition. Mr. Flynn stated that the area contains many 25-foot and 50-foot lot widths. He stated that the existing 10,000-square-foot property with 100 feet of width, with approximately half of the property dedicated to parking, is out of context with the area and "sort of stands out as a void in the streetscape." Mr. Flynn stated that there is a lot of variety in the area in terms of building separation and density. He pointed out several buildings across the street that are relatively close together in terms of their setbacks. Mr. Flynn stated that building separation relates to another variance being sought for the existing building, involving the proposed side setback relative to the new shared property line in the middle of the property. Mr. Flynn then presented the revised site plan and reviewed the bulk table. He stated that the relief included variances for lot area and lot width. Mr. Flynn stated that the existing home has a non-conforming front setback of 16.71 feet. where 30 feet is required. The property on the newly created lot would comply with all setbacks. Mr. Flynn emphasized that, even with the proposed new building, the building and lot coverages would be compliant. Mr. Flynn reviewed the existing and proposed conditions. o The existing property currently contains one two-family dwelling. o Under the proposed conditions, the existing two-family dwelling would remain, with an addition extending to the left. A new two-family dwelling would be constructed on the newly created lot to the right. Mr. Flynn stated that the existing non-conforming front setback is 16.71 feet and would remain unchanged. He noted that the proposed work would not bring the building any closer to the front property line. Mr. Flynn identified the side setback variance associated with the existing
would remain unchanged. He noted that the proposed work would not bring the building any closer to the front property line. Mr. Flynn identified the side setback variance associated with the existing building and the new shared property line. He stated that the setback is 1.67 feet, where 8 feet is required. In response to Mr. Trembulak's question regarding the distance between the existing house and the proposed two-family dwelling on the subdivided lot, Mr. Flynn stated that the separation would be a little over 15 and a half feet. Mr. Trembulak noted that the zoning permits 8-foot side yard setbacks, which would translate to approximately 16 feet of separation between the two structures if both houses had compliant setbacks. Mr. Flynn stated that the proposed building separation of a little over 15 and a half feet would not stand out and that the immediate area contains buildings that are much closer together. Mr. Flynn stated that there are waivers associated with the parking, including an RSIS waiver for the proposed parking stall size.
He stated that RSIS requires parking spaces to be 9 feet by 18 feet. The proposed parking spaces are 8 feet wide, with two spaces being 16 feet long and the remaining spaces being 18 feet long. Mr. Trembulak confirmed that the plan shows four parking spaces for proposed Lot 58.02, which is one more space than required. o Mr. Flynn confirmed that one and one-half parking spaces are required for a two- bedroom unit and that the plan therefore provides one additional parking space. Mr. Flynn stated that there may be room in the backyard to move one of the parking spaces from the front to the back, which could allow for an 18-foot-long space instead of a 16-foot-long space. He stated that there was some room to adjust the plan if the Board was uncomfortable with the current arrangement. Mr. Trembulak stated that, if necessary, one of the parking spaces could be eliminated, which would allow for a better plan because the proposal provides one more parking space than required. Mr. Flynn agreed. Mr. Trembulak asked Mr. Flynn to discuss the driveway widths shown on the plan. Mr. Flynn stated that one of the driveways, for proposed Lot 58.02. is shown at 8 feet in width. He stated that the other driveway appeared to be somewhat wider, although the exact width was not clearly shown. Mr. Flynn stated that 14 feet is required for the driveway width and that both proposed driveways would therefore be variance conditions. In'response to Mr. Trembulak's question as to whether an 8-foot-wide driveway was sufficieiit; Mr. Flynn stated that a car could easily get in and out. He added that, on Lot 58.02, approximately 2 additional feet could conceivably be added if the Board felt that was necessary to get closer to the property line. Mr. Flynn stated that, as proposed, the variance conditions would include variances for the size of the parking spaces and the driveway width. Mr. Flynn stated that, from a planning standpoint, for C relief, they look to either the C2 test or the Cl test. o He addressed the C2 test, known as the balancing test, under which the benefits of the application as a whole substantially outweigh any detriments. o He referenced the Pullen case and stated that the Board does not need to look at the benefits accruing from cach individual variance, but rather the project as a whole. Mr. Flynn stated that Purpose A of the Municipal Land Use Law concerns
that the Board does not need to look at the benefits accruing from cach individual variance, but rather the project as a whole. Mr. Flynn stated that Purpose A of the Municipal Land Use Law concerns promotion of the general welfare. o He stated that the application would improve the existing housing stock by bringing the relatively small existing home up to modern living conditions and would also contribute to new housing stock. Mr. Flynn stated that the proposal would contribute housing not only for the applicant, but for anyone who wishes to live in the community. He described two-family housing as "missing middle housing," noting that not everyone can afford to live in a single-family dwelling and not everyone wants to live in an apartment building. Mr. Flynn addressed Purpose G, variety of uses in appropriate locations. o Referring to his exhibit, he stated that, in terms of neighborhood compatibility, there are two-family homes on similarly sized and even smaller properties, and that the particular property size frequently contains three-family homes. Mr. Flynn addressed Purpose I, desirable aesthetics.
o He stated that, in terms of compatibility, the proposed development would blend in and would not stand out as buildings crammed together in the context of the neighborhood and streetscape. o Mr. Flynn stated that, aesthetically, because the property is currently oversized, the proposal would have a cleaner aesthetic than one very large home, which could have much more building massing than what is being proposed. Mr. Flynn discussed the Kauffman case, which he identified as the pertinent case law for subdivision applications. o He stated that the court found a two-lot subdivision creating deficient lot widths and areas to be appropriate when the proposed subdivision provided for more consistent lot sizes with the surrounding area. o He stated that the existing 10,000-square-foot lot stands out in its existing condition because many lots in the area are much smaller. Mr. Flynn addressed the negative criteria and stated that there would be no substantial detriment to the public or the zone. o He again stated that the proposal would be less impactful than one very large home. Mr. Flynn stated that the proposed building coverage for both lots combined is approximately 2,400 square feet. He stated that up to 4,000 square feet could be placed in one building on the property in its current form, resulting in much more building massing than proposed. He stated that the proposal is therefore not maximizing the development potential of the property. Mr. Flynn stated that two dwellings could still be placed on the property and that having two distinct-homes is not out of keeping with the zoning because two single-family homes could be developed as of right. The proposal differs in that the two homes would be two-family rather than single-family. Mr. Flynn stated that the Master Plan discusses improving and maintaining existing residential neighborhoods. o Hestated that the proposal would improve and maintain what is currently in the neighborhood and would provide appropriate residential development taking into account the distinct areas throughout the community. Mr. Flynn stated that, based on his analysis, the application is appropriate and is a blend of what is permitted by zoning and what is seen in the community today. Mr. Trembulak asked Mr. Flynn whether he had reviewed the Board Planner's June 26th memorandum. Mr. Flynn confirmed that he had. Mr.
t is permitted by zoning and what is seen in the community today. Mr. Trembulak asked Mr. Flynn whether he had reviewed the Board Planner's June 26th memorandum. Mr. Flynn confirmed that he had. Mr. Trembulak asked whether Mr. Flynn agreed that the applicant is able and willing to comply with all other code and ordinance requirements identified in the memorandum. Mr. Flynn agreed. BOARD QUESTIONS Chairman Bagoff asked Mr. Flynn whether he would characterize the proposal as infill housing in the area. Mr. Flynn stated that he would. Chairman Bagoff asked whether the Kauffman case was Kauffman versus the Planning Board of the Township of Warren, 1988. Mr. Flynn stated that he believed so. Mr. Guarino stated that his concern was that the proposal would take away lawn and curb appearance and load the front with parking spaces. He asked whether the parking spaces could be placed in the rear of the property. Mr. Flynn stated that, on proposed Lot 58.01, the rear yard setback is 30 feet and that, based on the dimensions, it appeared that the parking could probably be placed in the rear.
File revisions (1)
- Nov 3, 2026
e70fb166374e25,949,455 bytes