Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text · page 5

Show all pages
Page 5

He stated that RSIS requires parking spaces to be 9 feet by 18 feet. The proposed parking spaces are 8 feet wide, with two spaces being 16 feet long and the remaining spaces being 18 feet long. Mr. Trembulak confirmed that the plan shows four parking spaces for proposed Lot 58.02, which is one more space than required. o Mr. Flynn confirmed that one and one-half parking spaces are required for a two- bedroom unit and that the plan therefore provides one additional parking space. Mr. Flynn stated that there may be room in the backyard to move one of the parking spaces from the front to the back, which could allow for an 18-foot-long space instead of a 16-foot-long space. He stated that there was some room to adjust the plan if the Board was uncomfortable with the current arrangement. Mr. Trembulak stated that, if necessary, one of the parking spaces could be eliminated, which would allow for a better plan because the proposal provides one more parking space than required. Mr. Flynn agreed. Mr. Trembulak asked Mr. Flynn to discuss the driveway widths shown on the plan. Mr. Flynn stated that one of the driveways, for proposed Lot 58.02. is shown at 8 feet in width. He stated that the other driveway appeared to be somewhat wider, although the exact width was not clearly shown. Mr. Flynn stated that 14 feet is required for the driveway width and that both proposed driveways would therefore be variance conditions. In'response to Mr. Trembulak's question as to whether an 8-foot-wide driveway was sufficieiit; Mr. Flynn stated that a car could easily get in and out. He added that, on Lot 58.02, approximately 2 additional feet could conceivably be added if the Board felt that was necessary to get closer to the property line. Mr. Flynn stated that, as proposed, the variance conditions would include variances for the size of the parking spaces and the driveway width. Mr. Flynn stated that, from a planning standpoint, for C relief, they look to either the C2 test or the Cl test. o He addressed the C2 test, known as the balancing test, under which the benefits of the application as a whole substantially outweigh any detriments. o He referenced the Pullen case and stated that the Board does not need to look at the benefits accruing from cach individual variance, but rather the project as a whole. Mr. Flynn stated that Purpose A of the Municipal Land Use Law concerns

Page 5

that the Board does not need to look at the benefits accruing from cach individual variance, but rather the project as a whole. Mr. Flynn stated that Purpose A of the Municipal Land Use Law concerns promotion of the general welfare. o He stated that the application would improve the existing housing stock by bringing the relatively small existing home up to modern living conditions and would also contribute to new housing stock. Mr. Flynn stated that the proposal would contribute housing not only for the applicant, but for anyone who wishes to live in the community. He described two-family housing as "missing middle housing," noting that not everyone can afford to live in a single-family dwelling and not everyone wants to live in an apartment building. Mr. Flynn addressed Purpose G, variety of uses in appropriate locations. o Referring to his exhibit, he stated that, in terms of neighborhood compatibility, there are two-family homes on similarly sized and even smaller properties, and that the particular property size frequently contains three-family homes. Mr. Flynn addressed Purpose I, desirable aesthetics.

File revisions (1)