Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text

Page 32

de additional contours extending off-site. Because of the wall separating the shopping center from the residential area, he stated that the additional contours should be provided. - Mr. Valesi stated that, regarding the drainage calculations and drainage map, he had already spoken with Mr. Cecini, who indicated that those materials would also be provided. - Mr. Valesi initially identified those as the only three waivers from an engineering standpoint. - Chairman Bagoff noted that six waivers had been requested and that Mr. Valesi had discussed two. - Ms. Wolfe identified numbers 41 and 42 as waivers, with number 41 concerning road and paving cross-sections and number 42 concerning proposed street names. - Ms. McGovern asked him to identify the waivers that, from his perspective, were acceptable and could therefore be granted. - Mr. Valesi identified three engineering-related waivers concerning existing and proposed contour intervals based on UGS and GS datum, and contours extending at least 200 feet beyond the subject property. 32

Page 33

- Mr. Cecini asked whether the applicant could use USGS 7.5-minute maps to make up the difference because requiring contours 200 feet beyond the property would require a significant amount of surveying. Mr. Valesi stated that contours would need to be provided within the immediate adjacent properties so that the existing grade on those properties could be tied into the proposed site improvements and it could be confirmed that the adjacent properties would not be negatively impacted. - Mr. Cecini agreed and asked whether the requirement could be limited to approximately 20 to 25 feet beyond the property, stating that this would sufficiently provide the necessary information. Ms. McGovern noted that the Board would make the final decision but stated that she was making a note of the proposed 20-foot area. - Ms. McGovern addressed number 34, the drainage area map. Mr. Valesi stated that the drainage area map should be provided. - Ms. McGovern addressed number 35, drainage calculations. Mr. Valesi confirmed that the drainage calculations should be provided. - Ms. McGovern addressed number 41, road and paving cross-sections. Mr. Valesi stated that he saw that the Planner had approved the waiver and that he agreed with the approval. - Ms. McGovern addressed number 42, proposed street names. Mr. Valesi stated that the Planner had also indicated that the waiver was acceptable. APPLICANT CONCLUSION - Ms. Wolfe summarized:that the Board had heard substantial testimony and had reviewed numerous exhibits and presentations. She stated that the applicant had spent significant time working through the loading situation and pedestrian situation and had done everything within its power to make the proposal function. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant believed the proposal was better than what currently exists. She noted that Ms. Keller had identified four entrances and exits on the existing site and that the proposal would reduce that to fewer entrances and exits, which she characterized as much safer. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the entrances and exits would be designated. - Regarding the loading spaces, Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant believed the proposal would work and that the applicant would work with the County and governing body to obtain the necessary approvals. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant had worked with the Board to the extent

Page 33

oposal would work and that the applicant would work with the County and governing body to obtain the necessary approvals. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant had worked with the Board to the extent possible, attended several TRCs, and made significant changes as a result of comments and questions received during those meetings. She stated that the applicant had continued making changes throughout the entire process. - Ms. Wolfe also directed the Board’s attention to the review issued by the Downtown Commission. She stated that the Downtown Commission had provided a very positive review and explained that the proposed use was desirable and necessary in the area. - Ms. Wolfe concluded that the applicant had done whatever it could to make the project the safest and best project possible. She stated that the proposal would be a significant improvement over the existing conditions and would bring something necessary to the community. PUBLIC COMMENTS - Tez Roro, 24 Hutton, stated that the presentation was great and that she was excited about potentially seeing a neighborhood grocery come to the area. She asked whether there 33

Page 34

would be consideration for hiring local residents for the business. Ms. Wolfe stated that it was the applicant’s intent to hire local residents. BOARD RECOMMENDATION - Chairman Bagoff stated that there had been a very clear enumeration of the potential C variances and that it was not necessary to review each one unless a member of the Board requested it. - Chairman Bagoff noted that parking was one of the major variances and stated that the site was very amenable to people walking and bicycling, in addition to driving. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the neighborhood would avail itself of the business and complimented the applicant on the architecture and the cohesiveness of the group assembled by the applicant. - Chairman Bagoff stated that he appreciated the succinctness of the presentations and the ability of the applicant and its experts to listen to the Board and its experts and work with them to provide a potentially outstanding project in the Township. - Chairman Bagoff stated that he believed the benefits outweigh the detriments and that the area was in need of redevelopment. - Chairman Bagoff referenced the Downtown Alliance letter, which had been posted on the website, stating that the Downtown Alliance was in favor of the project, including the building structure and the concept of a supermarket in that area of town. - | Chairman Bagoff noted that'the project provides walkability and that there were bicycle racks around the area. He also stated that the Board was hoping a bench would be provided for seniors so that the jitney would be able to stop there and provide space for them to sit. - Chairman Bagoff stated that the application advances the zone plan and is exactly what the 2019 Master Plan discussed when seeking to upgrade the downtown. - Chairman Bagoff recommended approval of PB 25-12, 262 and 270 Main Street Realty LLC, Block 114, Lots 50 and 55, Zone B1. - Motion: Chairman Bagoff - Second: Mr. Noborine Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: ¥. Bagoff: Y Morgan: ¥ Cardoza (Alt.2): — Noborine: ix Guarino: _ Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: — Klein: Y e PB-25-11 525 Northfield Ave LLC 525 Northfield Avenue Block: 159.04 Lot: 1.01 Zone: B-2 34

Page 35

The applicant is proposing a 4-story mixed-use building containing 1,200 sq. ft commercial space on the ground floor and 95 residential units on the upper floors; and 165 off-street parking spaces. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on September 2, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. via Zoom. e PB-26-01 15 Ridgeway LLC 15 Ridgeway LLC Block: 158 Lot: 28.01 Zone: R4 The applicant is seeking a minor subdivision with bulk variance approval to create an additional building lot from an oversized lot. The application will be carried to the next Planning Board special meeting on September 9, 2026, without further notice, at 6:30 P.M. via Zoom. ADOPTED: iol? | 26 Planning Board Secretary 35

File revisions (1)