Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Minutes · Aug 12, 2026

August 12, 2026, Planning Board Regular Meeting Minutes

Preserved file SHA-256e70fb166374efcc58fdf24a4881520d4bb1d2f20e40efa25c502122978b84f93

Indexed text

Page 27

isibility is maintained. Mr. Mastropietro stated that the information concerning the proposed trees is contained in the civil and landscaping plans. Mr. Mastropietro stated that the bench had not been discussed previously, but following the last meeting, the applicant had considered placing it either in the front area or another indicated area. o He stated that the applicant was open to suggestions from the Board or community regarding its placement. Mr. Mastropietro stated that, although he is not a traffic engineer, he is an advocate for pedestrian safety. He testified that he lives in the neighboring town of Millburn, is part of the pedestrian safety committee and planning board, and considers pedestrian safety very important. Mr. Mastropietro explained that the applicant was considering measures within the parking lot to slow vehicles down, including a patterned surface in areas where vehicles drive. He also discussed changing the surface of the sidewalk near the parking lot entrance and exit, including painting or otherwise changing the sidewalk surface to identify the pedestrian area. 27

Page 28

Mr. Mastropietro testified that having the loading space parallel to the sidewalk was the safest approach. He stated that going in and out through a loading dock is dangerous because delivery vehicles would have to cross the sidewalk multiple times, particularly for 20- to 30-minute deliveries. Mr. Mastropietro stated that he believed it was safer to avoid having delivery vehicles repeatedly cross the sidewalk. BOARD QUESTIONS Chairman Bagoff asked Mr. Mastropietro to address Mr. Malanga's question concerning the water collection system on the roofline and how it would drain into the stormwater management system. Mr. Mastropietro reiterated that the drainage could be hidden and showed another image illustrating how the system could be constructed. Mr. Mastropietro testified that the method had been used on other buildings and was not an idea being created solely for this project. He explained that the drainage would go inside the building and down through the building. PRESENTATION Msi Wolfe stated that reducing the proposed physical spaces to 43 would be ideal. She explained that they may not need all of the space, but did not want to have to return if they could not make it work. She stated that, due to the Fire Department’s concerns regarding placement of the EV space near the building, it was'more difficult to determine where to place the ADA space. Ms. Wolfe confirmed that there was only one EV space at issue. The professional planner, Kate Keller, entered on the record; she was sworn under oath. Her credentials were accepted by the board and she testified to the following: Ms. Keller reviewed the existing site conditions, utilizing a previously marked presentation slide. She described the property as a relatively large site of almost three- quarters of an acre, approximately 0.7 acres, located in the heart of one of the downtown nodes. o She noted that the property had previously been a vacant pharmacy site with substantial parking and discussed the negatives of the prior site design. Ms. Keller stated that the existing site had approximately 99% impervious coverage and that the frontage was essentially non-existent. She explained that the proposal would replace the existing one-story, relatively nondescript buildings and parking areas with a permitted and encouraged supermarket/retail use. Ms. Keller described the proposed use as an

Page 28

he proposal would replace the existing one-story, relatively nondescript buildings and parking areas with a permitted and encouraged supermarket/retail use. Ms. Keller described the proposed use as an appropriately scaled neighborhood market with approximately 13,000 square feet of actual retail space. She emphasized that the proposal was not a ShopRite or a large-scale market, but rather something designed to fit the context of the downtown area. Ms. Keller noted that the property has three street frontages: Main Street, Irwin Place, and a small Prospect Place frontage. She stated that, although she would not characterize the situation strictly as a C1 hardship because the lot was not assembled for that purpose, having three frontages represented some hardship with respect to certain of the requested variances. Ms. Keller stated that the requested variances could be considered in several categories, including existing conditions, parking and loading, and other site-related requirements. Ms. Keller identified the existing rear yard setback as 2 feet, 11 inches, which is also what is proposed. She noted that lot coverage would be reduced from 99% to 97%. 28

Page 29

Regarding parking, Ms. Keller stated that the ordinance strictly requires 57 parking spaces, including the first and second floors of the building and accounting for the 1,000- square-foot exception provided in the CBD. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal had originally provided for 44 parking spaces and had now been reduced to 43 spaces, with a credit for four EV spaces. She explained that, from the perspective of someone looking for parking on the site, there would be 43 spaces, while for purposes of variance relief and the resolution, there would be 47 spaces because of the EV credit. Ms. Keller stated that, in her opinion, the difference between the required 57 spaces and the proposed parking was not major and that the proposed parking was appropriate for a neighborhood supermarket. Ms. Keller explained that the parking was based on operational and real demand and was designed specifically for this type of market. She addressed what she believed had been some confusion regarding what areas were counted, noting that the second-floor area, mezzanine, and storage space were all part of the proofs. Ms. Keller stated that the proposed building and parking area were appropriately sized for the proposed use and that the balance between floor area and parking was an important consideration for the operator. She explained that the parking demand was driven by customers and not storage space. Ms. Keller stated that the parking calculation was a general retail parking calculation applicable throughout the CBD and B1 zones. She noted that the proposal provided parking on the site in addition to off-street parking available in the surrounding area. Ms. Keller stated that the site design provided a balance of usable building area while avoiding excessive pavement and keeping impervious coverage down, resulting in a better fit with the surrounding downtown setting. She also noted that ADA and EV requirements were being met on the site. Regarding off-site parking, Ms. Keller stated that the issue had been discussed at TRC meetings. She indicated that the applicant did not believe it was necessary to approach additional off-site parking and believed that the parking could be accommodated on the site. She noted that the requirement could not be met within 250 feet and stated that the needs of customers would be satisfied by the proposed parking. Ms. Keller

Page 29

arking could be accommodated on the site. She noted that the requirement could not be met within 250 feet and stated that the needs of customers would be satisfied by the proposed parking. Ms. Keller discussed the variance required for off-street parking that abuts residential property. She explained that where a neighborhood business district, B1, is located adjacent to residential uses, it is difficult to provide the required 10-foot setback. She stated that the existing condition was generally being maintained, with improvements being made to certain portions of the parking area. Ms. Keller stated that the proposed site plan was a realistic plan for the proposed use. She noted that the area adjacent to the parking was residentially zoned and that the 10-foot parking setback was not a condition commonly met elsewhere in the B1 zone. Ms. Keller also addressed the requirement for a buffer strip from residential property, She stated that these requirements applied throughout the Township and that there could sometimes be a conflict between such requirements and downtown business district sites, as opposed to suburban, highway-oriented sites. Regarding two employee parking spaces shown on the site plan, Ms. Keller reiterated Mr. Dean’s testimony that this was a limited-mobility scenario involving employees only. She stated that the spaces would not have high turnover and would not be used during the busiest times of the day. She stated that she did not see any safety issues associated with those spaces. Ms. Keller addressed the loading areas and stated that two off-street loading areas were proposed, which is the number required. Although the location and size were not 29

Page 30

specifically aligned with the ordinance, she reiterated testimony from Mr. Dean and the other professionals that the proposal had been heavily studied, including by the County, and that the proposed arrangement was the safest and most appropriate planning alternative for the downtown location. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal would result in a much safer pedestrian environment because of the improvements proposed and because there would not be the same amount of vehicles turning through the crosswalk. Ms. Keller compared the existing conditions, where vehicles could enter and exit from multiple locations, and stated that the proposal would take traffic away from the intersection and bring it toward the middle of the street, which she considered safer. Ms. Keller noted that the loading space also involved a property-line issue and stated that the same testimony previously provided regarding the buffer and off-street parking applied. Ms. Keller addressed the requested sign variances. She stated that a fagade sign was proposed at 8 feet in height, where 2 feet is permitted, and that a canopy sign was proposed at 1.5 feet, where 8 inches is permitted. Ms. Keller stated that the proposed signage was appropriately scaled for the building and the proposed use. She explained that a supermarket has different signage needs than a small storefront and that the building had been designed to incorporate the signage as part of a cohesive architectural package intended to activate the corner. Ms. Keller identified’a variance for a fence located less than 5 feet from an adjacent residential building. She stated that this was related to the site configuration, existing conditions, and the relationship between the B1 zone and the adjacent properties. Ms. Keller also identified the requirement for a sidewalk between the parking and the building. She stated that testimony had already been provided on this issue and that, because the site would be controlled by bollards and would contain safety features, the additional sidewalk would primarily add pavement and would reduce the available parking count. Ms. Keller reviewed the application under the C2 flexible criteria. She stated that the benefits of the Municipal Land Use Law and the purposes of zoning would be advanced and that the benefits would substantially outweigh the detriments. Ms. Keller described the

Page 30

ia. She stated that the benefits of the Municipal Land Use Law and the purposes of zoning would be advanced and that the benefits would substantially outweigh the detriments. Ms. Keller described the proposal as a state-of-the-art supermarket with food options, walkability, and parking on the site. She stated that it would provide what would be expected from a neighborhood market and would beautify a corner that had been significantly underutilized for an important site. Ms. Keller stated that the project would help revitalize this portion of downtown and noted that there were vacant commercial sites in the vicinity. She stated that the proposal would contribute to the pedestrian environment and the overall retail environment. Ms. Keller noted that the area was walkable and that a substantial portion of the Township could be covered within a 10-minute radius. She stated that this was a benefit to the community at large. Ms. Keller stated that, with respect to the purposes of the Municipal Land Use Law, the proposal would advance Purpose A by advancing the general welfare, filling a commercial gap, and providing an appropriately scaled, mid-size supermarket at the location. Ms. Keller stated that Purpose G would be advanced because the proposal provides a permitted use and sufficient space for commercial uses. She stated that, when viewed as a whole, many of the requested variances were relatively small. 30

Page 31

Ms. Keller stated that Purpose I, promoting a desirable visual environment, would also be advanced. She described the project as exciting in terms of its purpose, design, and other features. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal would constitute infill development with continuous building frontage and would incorporate elements identified in the Master Plan. She also noted that the project would promote renewable energy through solar panels and other design features previously addressed by the architect. Regarding the negative criteria, Ms. Keller stated that she did not see any substantial detriment to the public good associated with the requested variances. She noted enhanced safety features around the site and stated that the proposal was consistent with the intended purpose of corner lots under the Master Plan and zoning. Ms. Keller stated that the building was not excessively high, did not require additional building setbacks or building-height relief, and that the massing was appropriate. She described the proposal as an exceptional use of the corner site within the retail environment. Ms. Keller stated that the loading and off-street parking variances tepresented a better planning alternative, in her opinion. Regarding substantial impairment to the zone plan, Ms. Keller stated that the applicant had reviewed the 2019 Master Plan update and believed the proposal was consistent with what the Township was seeking when the Master Plan was prepared. Ms. Keller noted that the 2019 Master Plan specifically recommended flexibility in downtown parking ratios. She stated that, although the ordinance had not been changed, the recommendation was indicative of the importance of balancing uses and parking in downtown sites. Ms. Keller identified the incorporation of green infrastructure, maintaining a balance of land uses including non-residential uses in downtown core areas, streetscape and parking improvements, and making West Orange more environmentally and economically sustainable through a mix of land uses as objectives supported by the proposal. Ms. Keller stated that the proposal also continued longstanding Master Plan objectives concerning development, redevelopment, and rehabilitation of the Main Street Central Business District. Ms. Keller stated that the Master Plan focused on ensuring continued investment and improvements to the downtown and Main

Page 31

development, and rehabilitation of the Main Street Central Business District. Ms. Keller stated that the Master Plan focused on ensuring continued investment and improvements to the downtown and Main Street corridor. She concluded that the proposed development was consistent with the Master Plan, would not substantially impair the zoning ordinance or zone plan, and that the positive and negative criteria had been satisfied and the requested relief could be granted. Ms. Wolfe asked Ms. Keller to address the requested waivers. Ms. Keller initially understood the question to concern checklist waivers and indicated that she would defer to engineering or counsel regarding those items. Ms. Wolfe identified the illumination waivers, including illumination levels at the pedestrian walkway. Ms. Keller stated that the proposed illumination level at the pedestrian walkway was 5 foot-candles, where 0.9 is required, and referred to the engineer’s testimony that the requirement could be addressed as part of resolution compliance if the application were approved. Ms. Keller stated that light levels at the property line abutting residential uses were proposed at 0.5 foot-candles, where a maximum of 0.3 foot-candles is permitted. She stated that, given the context of the site and the existing conditions, the waiver was reasonable. 31

Page 32

- Ms. Keller stated that the site would use modern lighting fixtures, that the fixtures would be pointed downward, and that the purpose of the lighting was safety and illumination of the parking area, not to disturb neighboring properties. She stated that the goal was to keep the lighting on the site and provide efficient lighting levels. - Ms. Keller addressed the CBD design standards, noting that they are listed as guidelines in the ordinance. She stated that the applicant wanted to address them, particularly the use of certain building materials, including metal and zinc panels. - Ms. Keller stated that “context is everything” and reiterated the architect’s testimony that the building had been designed as a cohesive whole. She described the metal panels as a tasteful use of the material rather than an inexpensive or incompatible feature. - Ms. Keller stated that the purpose of the downtown design standards was not necessarily to make everything exactly cohesive, but to limit the ways in which buildings stand out in a downtown environment. She stated that this site was intended to stand out and described the design as modern without being hyper-modern. - Ms. Keller stated that the building fit into the surrounding architecture because of the way it blended into the site and that the use of metal panels on the roof and certain building materials would not be detrimental to the overall downtown goals. - Ms. Wolfe stated that the applicant was also seeking site plan approval and subdivision approval. She explained that the subdivision was unusual because the applicant was actually merging the lots, but wanted to place on the record that the approvals were required. - Ms. Keller confirmed that the application required preliminary and final major site plan approval and a technical subdivision for merging the lots. Ms. McGovern referred to it as a “reverse subdivision.” NO BOARD QUESTIONS GENERAL DISCUSSION - Mr. Valesi stated that the submission waivers requested by the applicant were incorporated into the engineering comments and offered to review them specifically for the record. - Mr. Valesi stated that the applicant had requested a waiver to provide additional contours extending off-site. Because of the wall separating the shopping center from the residential area, he stated that the additional contours should be provided. - Mr. Valesi stated

File revisions (1)