Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Sep 17, 2026

Variance Proposal 5 6 26rcd 5 7 2026

Preserved file SHA-25654fcf4faab1431af643c3d90853c07e31c3fad3d87ab9c4097e703a750763db1

Indexed text · page 2

Show all pages
Page 2

A photograph of the neighboring garage to the north—which already features a similar second-floor -- has been submitted alongside the site plans, elevations, engineering plans, and property survey. This photograph includes a scaled drawing of the proposed garage superimposed on it to illustrate the visual compatibility with the existing neighborhood context. The structure has been designed with high-performance insulation throughout to ensure both climate control and acoustic mitigation. The roof assembly incorporates Rockwool R38 batt insulation (approximately 10” thick), which provides excellent thermal performance for the second floor woodworking studio while significantly attenuating sound transmission from power tools and machinery to the exterior. The first floor walls are insulated with Rockwool R23 batt (5.5” in 2x6 stud bays), providing an additional sound-dampening layer around the ground floor workspace. Rockwool is specifically chosen for its superior acoustic properties relative to fiberglass insulation of equivalent R-value. Together, these assemblies ensure that the hobby woodworking use will have minimal impact on neighboring properties. I have been practicing woodworking as best as I can in the limited space available since I purchased the property in 2018 and have never received a noise complaint from any of my neighbors. I am very conscious about the time I spend using tools and machinery so as not to disrupt anyone. This construction project will enhance the property’s permeable space by removing the non-conforming “bump-out” and replacing it with permeable soil and grass seed. Any additional storm runoff from the larger roof will be controlled by roof gutters and plumbed into the existing underground gutter pipe that drains out to the street gutter. Ultimately, it will transform the garage into a functional, modern structure suitable for its intended purpose. C-2 Variance Chart for R-T Zone Standard Required per Zone Existing Proposed Variance Needed Accessory Structure Height 15’ Maximum 15’ 20.6’ Yes (5.6’ over) Side Yard Setback 5’ Minimum 5.13’ – 5.2’ 5.13’ – 5.2’ No Rear Yard Setback 5’ Minimum 10” – 4.65’ (bump-out causes 10” measurement) 4.65’ (improved by bump-out removal) Yes (improves existing non-compliance) Second Story on Accessory 1.5 Stories 1.5 Stories 2 Stories Yes (full height second story) Accessory Building Proximity

Page 2

ent) 4.65’ (improved by bump-out removal) Yes (improves existing non-compliance) Second Story on Accessory 1.5 Stories 1.5 Stories 2 Stories Yes (full height second story) Accessory Building Proximity to Residence 15’ Minimum 42’ 9” 34’ 9” No Rear Yard Coverage of Not more than ⅓ (33%) of total rear yard (2,617 sq ft) 375.8 sq ft (14.4%) 499.5 sq ft (19%) No

File revisions (1)