Town CrierWest Orange, New Jersey
← Back to search

Supporting Documentation · Oct 7, 2026

7 1 26 WO PB Draft Minutes

Preserved file SHA-2562e4c7c42a270498c0c3576e47d85bc4d985dc27f3a8f765c33c1de4f25d6b446

Indexed text

Page 1

1 MINUTES TOWNSHIP OF WEST ORANGE PLANNING BOARD MEETING July 1, 2026, 7:30 P.M. The Township of West Orange Planning Board held a special meeting on July 1, 2026, at 7:30 P.M. via virtual ZOOM videoconference. Chairman Bagoff called the meeting to order at approximately 7:30 P.M. He announced that notification of the meeting was given to the Township Clerk, and posted on the Township Bulletin Board, sent to the West Orange Chronicle and the Star Ledger, and posted on the Township’s website calendar. This meeting has been properly noticed to the public in accordance with the Open Public Meetings Act. No new matters will start after 10:30 P.M. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE • Chairman Bagoff requested all persons stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. ANNOUNCEMENTS ● The next Planner Board regular meeting will be held Wednesday, August 12, 2026 at 6:30 p.m via Zoom. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Dr. Robert Bagoff; Mr. Ken Alper; Mr. Christopher Morgan, Sr.; Mayor Susan McCartney; Mr. Frank Noborine; Council president Susan Scarpa; Ms. Lori Kapferer; Mr. Jerry Guarino (9:25 PM); ABSENT: Mr. John Cardoza; Mr. Lee Klein; Mr. William Wilkes ALSO PRESENT: Diana P. McGovern, Esq., Planning Board Attorney; Jamilet Baquerizo Vite, Planning Board Secretary SWEARING IN ● The Township Professionals: Mr. Ryan MacNeil (Consultant Engineer) and Ms. Apte (Consultant Planner) were sworn under oath. MINUTES & RESOLUTIONS 5-6-26-WO-PB-Draft-Minutes Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mr. Morgan Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y

Page 2

2 Cardoza (Alt.2): ---- Noborine: Y Guarino: ---- Scarpa: Y Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Klein: ---- APPLICATIONS ● PB-23-04 Redwood LLC 200 Pleasant Valley Way Block: 151 Lot: 33 Zone: IHO-2 Applicant proposes to construct a four (4) story/142-unit residential rental community with luxury amenities and on-site parking for 338 vehicles. BOARD QUESTIONS - Council president Scarpa asked if the applicant is using the board’s updated stormwater ordinance. Chairman Bagoff explained that the application predated the updated stormwater ordinance. He stated that the applicant was asking for an extension without changing the previously adopted resolution. ○ Ms. McGovern stated that the resolution was first adopted on July 5, 2023. She stated the applicant is allowed three one-year extensions of time, provided there is good reason for the extension. ○ Ms. Gabrielle Bambersky, Esq, on behalf of the applicant, explained that the Essex County Planning Board required installation of a traffic light. She stated that the traffic light had been installed, but the applicant was waiting for approval from the County Planning Board. - Council president Scarpa asked whether, if the Board did not continue to grant the approvals and the applicant had to come back, the applicant would then have to use the enhanced stormwater ordinance. Ms. McGovern responded yes. PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS - Ms. McGovern stated that she had prepared a draft resolution because she saw that the application was coming close to its expiration date if the extension was granted. She stated that she had adjusted the draft because she had expected Mr. Dimin to appear and revised it accordingly. She stated that the date of memorialization could then be inserted. Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mayor McCartney Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): ---- Noborine: Y Guarino: ---- Scarpa: N

Page 3

3 Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- Motion: Chairman Bagoff Second: Mayor McCartney Alper: Y Mayor McCartney: Y Bagoff: Y Morgan: Y Cardoza (Alt.2): ---- Noborine: Y Guarino: ---- Scarpa: N Kapferer: Y Wilkes: ---- ● PB-25-09 Perez 68 Whittlesey Avenue Block: 129 Lot: 58 Zone: R-T The applicant proposes to subdivide the property into two 50-foot lots, convert the existing single-family dwelling to a two-family dwelling, and construct a new two-family dwelling on the subdivided lot. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on August 12, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. ● PB-25-11 525 Northfield Ave LLC 525 Northfield Avenue Block: 159.04 Lot: 1.01 Zone: B-2 The applicant is proposing a 4-story mixed-use building containing 1,200 sq. ft commercial space on the ground floor and 95 residential units on the upper floors, and 165 off-street parking spaces. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on August 12, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. ● PB-26-01 15 Ridgeway LLC 15 Ridgeway LLC Block: 158 Lot: 28.01 Zone: R4 The applicant is seeking a minor subdivision with bulk variance approval to create an additional building lot from an oversized lot The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on August 12, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. ● PB-25-12 262 & 270 Main Street Realty LLC 262 & 270 Main Street Block: 114 Lot: 50 & 55 Zone: B-1

Page 4

4 The applicant proposes to construct a two-story supermarket building consisting of 13,934 square feet on the first floor and 5,810 square feet on the second floor, for a total of 19,744 square feet. The application will be carried to the next planning board regular meeting on August 12, 2026, without further notice at 6:30 P.M. ● PB-26-03 Crestmont Country Club 750 Eagle Rock Avenue Block: 174 Lot: 1.01 Zone: R-2 The applicant is proposing the installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Eagle Rock Avenue and Oval Road. Modifications to the existing driveway and parking area are also being proposed. PRESENTATION - The attorney, Richard Schkolnick, appeared on behalf of the applicant. - Mr. Schkolnick stated that the applicant has a permitted use. - Mr. Schkolnick reiterated information from the June meeting and stated that the applicant is not proposing any new buildings. - The proposal consists of new driveways, a parking area, grading, and the proposed signal to create a new and safer four-way intersection with Oval Road. - Mr. Schkolnick stated that the application began on June 3rd. ○ Exhibit A1, an aerial photo, was marked ○ The civil engineer, John Cote, testified briefly ○ The Board then heard testimony from Dana Cancellero, Crestmont’s general manager and COO. ■ Ms. Cancellero discussed the Country Club’s need for the project and why the project makes sense. ■ She discussed safety improvements, the new driveway, the four-way intersection and the advantages that it would bring, as well as the additional parking and how it would help solve issues faced by the Country Club. ○ Carl Penke, a traffic expert, full testimony was completed, but cross-examination had not yet occurred - Mr. Cote’s remaining testimony would address grading, trees, and stormwater. - Mr. Schkolnick stated that he would then conclude with the applicant’s planner, Sean Moronski of Langan, who had approximately 20 minutes of testimony. - Mr. Schkolnick noted that they have the review letters from the board’s professionals. ○ He stated that the applicant did not have any issues addressing the concerns raised in the review letters and believed that the concerns were technical in nature. ○ He also stated that, if the Board was inclined, the concerns could be handled as conditions of approval in a resolution. - Mr. Pehnke began by sharing his screen and identifying the plan

Page 4

in nature. ○ He also stated that, if the Board was inclined, the concerns could be handled as conditions of approval in a resolution. - Mr. Pehnke began by sharing his screen and identifying the plan he was referencing. He stated that it was a plan submitted as part of the record and part of the plan set for improvements along Eagle Rock Avenue. He identified the document as the “Signing and Striping Plan,” Sheet 14 of 22, dated 3-12-2026. - Mr. Pehnke briefly summarized the application, explaining that it involves improvements within Crestmont Country Club, including:

Page 5

5 ○ Expansion of parking ○ Improvement of internal circulation ○ Relocation of the existing egress drive, which currently approaches Eagle Rock Avenue at an acute angle ○ Realignment of the egress drive opposite Oval Road ○ Improvement of the grading on the approach to Oval Road by flattening the approach in accordance with design standards ○ Widening Eagle Rock Avenue toward the project site to separate left-turn movements onto Oval Road from through movements, which Mr. Pehnke identified as providing a public safety benefit ○ Installation of a traffic signal that would control vehicular movements and provide full pedestrian crossings - Mr. Pehnke reported that, since the previous meeting, the applicant had an opportunity to participate in a pre-application meeting with Essex County. - Mr. Pehnke stated that the County agreed that the proposed improvement was appropriate for the location. He said the County liked the proposed traffic signal and believed that it was needed today. - Mr. Pehnke explained that the County identified pedestrian crossings in the area as challenging. - He stated that, over the last five years, the County had probably faced approximately 200 pedestrian incidents involving people crossing a road. ○ He said the County therefore viewed the signalization of this location as providing a positive benefit from a pedestrian safety standpoint. - Mr. Pehnke stated that the County also supported the relocation of the driveway and had actually suggested the relocation a few years ago. He explained that the relocation would: ○ Eliminate the acute angle of the existing driveway ○ Improve drainage, which currently flows down onto Eagle Rock Avenue - Mr. Pehnke identified two requests made by the County: ○ The applicant must remove the old pavement associated with the old driveway. Mr. Pehnke stated that the applicant had assured the County this would be done. ○ Equipment must be added to the Laurel Avenue intersection and the proposed intersection so that the two intersections are coordinated and “talked to each other.” Mr. Pehnke stated that this was already part of the design, as he had testified at the previous meeting. BOARD QUESTIONS - Ms. Kapferer asked him to review the proposed crosswalks and whether they would connect to any existing sidewalk. Mr. Pehnke explained that the sidewalk system ends near Wakeman Street. He stated that there was

Page 5

er asked him to review the proposed crosswalks and whether they would connect to any existing sidewalk. Mr. Pehnke explained that the sidewalk system ends near Wakeman Street. He stated that there was evidence of a path just to the west of that location. He explained that, in the area of the proposed signal, the signal would include: ○ Connecting sidewalks on the quadrants ○ Handicap ramps ○ Crosswalks themselves ○ A crossing specifically intended to provide a safe crossing of Eagle Rock Avenue. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether the applicant would have a sidewalk from Laurel Avenue down to the easterly aspect of the property. Mr. Pehnke stated that the applicant had not proposed a sidewalk in that section as part of the application.

Page 6

6 ○ Chairman Bagoff stated that once the Board was finished discussing the matter, his recommendation would be for a sidewalk from Eagle Rock Avenue to the easterly side of the property, all along Eagle Rock Avenue. ○ Mr. Schkolnick clarified that the applicant could not agree to perform work on other property. Chairman Bagoff clarified that the sidewalk would be on the applicant's property. - Mayor McCartney asked whether there was a bus stop along the path. Mr. Pehnke stated that there was not a New Jersey Transit bus stop. He explained that he had been advised that paratransit occurs in the area. He stated that he could not find evidence of a formal, signed bus stop but had been told through the years that paratransit does occur at that location. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether the proposed design is consistent with what the RSIS recommends. Mr. Pehnke stated that RSIS would not apply in this instance. - Chairman Bagoff asked whether intersections are generally better when they are located across from each other. Mr. Pehnke answered absolutely. He clarified that this principle is not coming from RSIS but is instead embodied in engineering design manuals. PUBLIC QUESTIONS - Ms. Shana Toscano asked whether the 3 major reasons for the traffic light being proposed are to make it easier for Country Club members to get in and out, to prevent pedestrian crossing accidents, and drainage. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had walked through multiple existing conditions that were challenging and impacted public safety. He stated that it was a “multitude of items” being addressed. - Ms. Toscano referenced a three-page letter regarding the preliminary site plan and asked whether the applicant was asking for exceptions on all seven items, including the minimum distance, number of parking spaces, setback, required feet, and other requirements. Mr. Pehnke explained that Mr. Cote and Mr. Moronski would address each of those items. - Ms. Toscano asked what alternatives had been proposed or researched other than the plan that requires multiple exceptions for the Crestmont Country Club. Mr. Pehnke responded that the application before the Board that evening was the proposed improvement. - Ms. Toscano clarified whether any other alternatives had been explored. Mr. Pehnke stated that there was no other alternative for consideration. - Ms. Toscano asked whether alternatives had been

Page 6

nt. - Ms. Toscano clarified whether any other alternatives had been explored. Mr. Pehnke stated that there was no other alternative for consideration. - Ms. Toscano asked whether alternatives had been explored and rejected or whether this was the first idea that had been developed. Mr. Pehnke stated that he had not explored any other alternatives because he was in design and permitting for this project - Ms. Toscano asked whether anyone else on the applicant's team knew if Crestmont Country Club had explored any other ideas or alternatives. Mr. Pehnke stated that they were not aware of anyone - Mr. Kevin Malanga, at Ridge Road, asked whether he was familiar with an application made by the applicant in 2017 for an expansion of its parking lot. Mr. Pehnke stated that he was not familiar with that application. He said he was aware that there had been prior applications as Crestmont Country Club had proceeded through the years and addressed its needs. - Mr. Malanga stated that he understood Mr. Pehnke was not familiar with the fact that Crestmont had made an application for a parking lot expansion based on the needs of its members but had not requested that a traffic light be constructed at the location presently proposed. Mr. Pehnke responded that this application is before the Board, based on Crestmont Country Club's current proposal.

Page 7

7 - Mr. Malanga asked what factors resulted in the need for the traffic light at the end of the parking lot and driveway. Mr. Pehnke stated that this had been testified to by the Country Club manager at the previous meeting. - Mr. Malanga asked whether anyone had provided Mr. Pehnke with that information other than through that testimony. Mr. Pehnke stated that substantial testimony had been given regarding the application, its relationship to the needs of the Country Club, and the signalization of the intersection, which he stated was also a desire of the Township. - Mr. Malanga asked whether the driveway at Laurel Avenue was the entrance to the club. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it was. - Mr. Malanga asked whether there was no means of egress from the Laurel Avenue driveway. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that there was no egress from that driveway. - Mr. Malanga asked whether consideration had been given to converting the Laurel Avenue driveway to provide both ingress and egress. Mr. Pehnke stated that this had not been considered. - Mr. Malanga asked why. Mr. Pehnke explained that the applicant had an established circulation pattern on the site and that its porte-cocheres were oriented to receive traffic from that driveway. - Mr. Malanga suggested that the proposed traffic light was therefore really for the convenience of the applicant. Mr. Pehnke stated that he would not say it was the convenience of the applicant and explained that there was “a host of factors” driving the proposal. - Mr. Malanga asked, in Mr. Pehnke's professional opinion, whether it would be possible to construct a driveway at Laurel Avenue that provides both ingress and egress. Mr. Pehnke stated that it would not be possible. - Mr. Malanga asked why. Mr. Pehnke explained that the Laurel Avenue driveway is too close to the intersection with Eagle Rock Avenue. - Mr. Malanga returned to Mr. Pehnke's testimony concerning discussions with Essex County and asked whether “pedestrian incidents” was the term Mr. Pehnke had used. Mr. Pehnke confirmed that it was. - Mr. Malanga asked Mr. Pehnke to describe what those pedestrian incidents were and where they occurred. Mr. Pehnke explained that the incidents were countywide. He stated that the County had indicated in their conversation that, over the previous five years, there had been over 200 pedestrian hits. - Mr. Malanga asked whether there had been any

File revisions (1)